7 critics reviewed the show, resulting in a weighted average of 71.
"Max von Essen and Elisabeth Gray do an admirable job portraying the seesaw emotions of the convention-bending pair, but Malleson's uneven script makes us wait until the final act for a dramatic payoff...The earnest plot, unfortunately, begs for a more comedic treatment. Director Jonathan Bank squeezes in a few chuckles now and then, but this is far from the smart comedy it could have been...Still, 'Yours Unfaithfully' offers keen insights into the destructiveness of jealousy."
The New York Times
"A refined, rueful and often shrewd comedy about polyamory, written decades before open relationships were quite so openly discussed...Under the polished direction of Bank, its arguments remain provocative, while its structure feels familiar, its tone decorous...It is often very funny; it is also very nearly a tragedy...What is extraordinary about Malleson is his ability to create characters who are capable of feeling several things at once, or who don’t really know what they’re feeling at all."
Time Out New York
"Malleson’s bio suggests a life story considerably more colorful than the tidy marital drama that unfolds onstage...The script offers a scrupulous examination of two warring impulses: the urge to explore versus the instinct to nurture and protect. Happily, we’re spared the wink-wink prompts of farce, though Malleson does allude to an extremely vulgar adage of the day, sanitized here as 'Fresh kiss, fresh courage.' If only he had applied that tenet to his rather dry disquisition."
The show was also reviewed by 42 Show-Score members, whose collective ShowScore is a weighted average of 82.
Top five adjectives describing the show:
Thought-provoking, Intelligent, Great acting, Relevant, Entertaining
See it if…"You like good acting, thoughtful plays, and a taste of forgotten theater from decades past."
Don't see it if…"You need action and are easily bored when dialogue gets preachy."
See it if…"Written in 1933, but never produced. Now we know why. Two and a half hours of explanations of why a husband and wife might want to cheat."
Don't see it if…"Thank goodness Max von Essen was on the stage. He supplied needed spark."
See it if…"You enjoy old-fashioned shows which have intelligent plot lines and good acting. Had to keep reminding myself this took place in 1933."
Don't see it if…"Old-fashioned shows are just not your thing. You need high drama and bad language to keep you interested."
See the Show Page with all critic and member reviews.
Note: The ShowScore displayed above is current as of right now, and may be different from the ShowScore when the article was published.