See it if You want to see A-list dancing talent.
Don't see it if You don't like classics
See it if You not only love old films and Broadway, but if you love ballet. It's a beautifully done musical with wonderful performances by all.
Don't see it if Dancing and ballet are not your thing.
See it if you enjoy the best of what Broadway has to offer
Don't see it if you hate Gershwin. But, you might want to consider therapy if you dislike Gershwin.
See it if you love Gershwin, ballet, Paris, showgirls, romance, and stairways to paradise.
Don't see it if you want to see a recreation of the MGM musical, if you don't like ballet, if you're cynical about love, if you're an old grouch.
See it if You love dancing, classic music and a riveting story.
Don't see it if You don't like dance shows
See it if You love Gerswhin, dancing, a full orchestra, and a presentation that results in an absolute delight.
Don't see it if You want original music and book.
See it if you love incredible choreography and Gershwin music
Don't see it if This is a must see.
See it if you love great music and great dancing. The scenery and lighting are fabulous also.
Don't see it if you don't like Gershwin
"'An American In Paris' presents a new and remarkably effective book and new, breathtaking choreography...Lucas’s narrative succeeds so well because it’s dramatically character-driven...It’s all a thoroughly effervescent delight...The production design only enhances the emotional destinies of the characters and dramatic peaks of choreography. These elements, like every aspect of 'An American in Paris,' are sustained in perfect balance by Wheeldon. C’est magnifique."
Read more
"This season on Broadway features multiple musicals that are based on iconic films. One of the most sublime among them is surely "An American in Paris," helmed with panache by top director and choreographer Christopher Wheeldon. Gloriously inventive and balletic, it has an intriguing new book...Beneath the considerable pizazz, Wheeldon conveys with grace and style the heartfelt romance and emotional colors that keep us enchanted until the last beautiful note has been sung."
Read more
"I did my best to focus on what was happening on-stage, but it was hard to find any of it compelling. Perhaps it deserves another chance given the circumstances but time and money are limited and there are other shows I’d rather give a shot. It was eye-opening in terms of how elements outside the actual production of the show can influence someone’s theater-going experience — if this was the ONE show I saw a year, or the first time I was taking a chance on Broadway, I’m not sure I’d go back."
Read more
"Director/choreographer Christopher Wheeldon, who has worked with ballet companies worldwide, has created one of the most extraordinary and spectacular works for the musical theater I have seen in many years. Working with librettist, Craig Lucas, he has fashioned a book musical that is utterly alive with song and dance."
Read more
"Inspired by the beloved 1951 film, Wheeldon has created what might best be described as a story ballet on steroids. Everything in this new musical moves — from the actors (two of whom just happen to be world class dancers), to the fabulously “choreographed” projection-enhanced sets and costumes...And even when the dialogue falls a bit flat, the story is in such perpetual motion that words seem almost beside the point. Dance is the only language really needed here."
Read more
"Surreal collisions of song, dance and visual art capture the desires of young expats and Parisians to create something beautiful as they rediscover their city in the aftermath of World War II...It feels like two shows. One is a great ballet, the other an uneven musical...the book can be heavy-handed...These spoken scenes often give way to appealingly sung classics, but it's when dance is involved that the show truly takes off."
Read more
"A visual, dance-driven Broadway story-telling creation that is gorgeous, enchanting, seamless and sophisticated. It is a tribute not only to the music of George and Ira Gershwin, but to the genius of director Christopher Wheeldon, and the performance abilities of a stellar cast."
Read more
"Every so often a gem the likes of “An American in Paris” is brought from screen to stage, and for a moment you can stop asking why so many movies are made into musicals. With exquisite performances and aesthetics, this ballet-musical theater hybrid makes good on a title with Oscar-winning clout. The similarities don’t end there — but this adaptation goes its own way and then some, with an innovative approach to staging and a breathtaking melding of art forms."
Read more