Dear Evan Hansen (NYC)

See it if want your emotions ripped apart and shredded, especially if you've ever felt like an outsider...AND it's a musical! FANTASTIC SHOW!

Don't see it if you don't want people to see you crying like a baby. This show is a rollercoaster of emotions and feels Ben Platt will rip your heart out

Also This show made me its bitch! We have all felt like the outsider at some point in our lives, or have lost someone dear, or have had issues connecting with loved ones. This show preys on all those insecurities. Ben Platt gives a performance on a par with Cynthia Erivo's The Color Purple (which was mind blowing). Brutally emotional while at the same time likable and vulnerable. This show and Ben's performance are my early pick for the 2017 Tony Awards. It's really THAT good.
Kleenex Alert!!! You will be drained emotionally.... Read more Read less

See it if you want to see a groundbreaking new show, one that is both funny, profound and deeply moving

Don't see it if you don't care about the troubles of teenagers or if you need to see spectacle.

See it if you can. Ben Platt gives 110% to the show, I don't know how he does it day after day. Other actors fine, music lovely, writing strong

Don't see it if you don't want to be manipulated a bit (yeah I cried) or if you've lost someone to suicide, as it could be tough to watch

See it if you can get here in time for Ben Platt's performance. Platt truly is the strongest element of the production.

Don't see it if you don't like being manipulated. An invisible choir will repeatedly appear and basically scream their intended emotional response at you.

Also the show's most "inspiring" lyrics are actually ironic in context. This is a decent think piece, but not an uplifting one. I consider it a character study and luckily, Platt completely rises to the occasion.

The book presents multiple issues and steers away from addressing them in favor of a hopeful, manipulative, and unearned resolution. It inadvertently advocates the very behavior it initially demoralizes, which, I think, is irresponsible when teens and preteens are the target audience.

This is a rare case where I think this show will fatally suffer without a performer of its original star's caliber. It’s a worthwhile evening and ticket purchase just to see Platt flex his musical theater muscles.... Read more Read less

See it if You want to hear the amazing soundtrack live and want an all-around entertaining production.

Don't see it if You're bothered by a cast that overacts sometimes - might have been more powerful with original cast. It's enjoyable but kinda melodrama.

See it if You want to see an outstanding and uncomfortable performance by Ben Platt as the socially misfit Evan Hanson.

Don't see it if You aren't interested in teen angst or the excesses of social media.

See it if I expected a lot and got disappointed. The music is not bad, Trensch delivered a decent act. But it dragged and didn’t do the magic for me.

Don't see it if you go in with huge expectations. It’s too tearful. Needs more songs and a set to support the acting. It’s not worth the fuss around it.

Also The theatre shouldn’t be selling 1st row tickets. The actors are visible up to the waist, the hollow stage resonates the orchestra beat and overturnes the voices.... Read more Read less

See it if you seek message musicals.... if you are or have teens/ 20 somethings. Fabulous lead actor on powerful subject (albeit implausible setup).

Don't see it if you are sensitive to end of life drama.. it will traumatize you (take tissues). If you're annoyed by emotional manipulation- it might annoy

See it if you want to see the Tony Best Musical of 2017. It is an original story, with original music.

Don't see it if you just want to hear want boy singing all the time.

Also It is an original and intelligent story, with a message. The acting of the mother and son are outstanding. I watched it in my birthday and it was a beautiful experience. Both won the Tony award. It has very powerful songs. Classic songs. The music composers are the same form the movie La La Land.... Read more Read less

See it if you can relate to being young, confused and desperate for a feeling of importance. And if you can appreciate a well-conceived project

Don't see it if you cannot relate to or empathize with those who are isolated and depressed. or if you do not want your emotions hammered.

See it if you want to see a Tony-worthy performance from Ben Platt in an original, heartfelt tale. Even if the music felt a bit over the top at times.

Don't see it if the topics of social anxiety, depression, and teen suicide frighten you.

Also I saw the off-Broadway production at 2nd Stage -- haven't seen the transfer yet but aside from the one casting change I've heard that the production is essentially intact.... Read more Read less

See it if Ben Platt gives an awe-inspiring performance! Knocks-it-outta-the-park-good! This production was raw & incredibly moving! Get a ticket now!

Don't see it if You'd be a fool not to catch this musical. You must see Ben Platt in this role. Be ready to cry and have your emotions stirred. Perfection.

See it if A beautiful, powerful, moving musical that is both entertaining and thought provoking. The book, score, direction and cast is outstanding!

Don't see it if You don't like musicals or looking for light old fashion entertainment.

See it if You like musical theater about social anxiety, drug use, suicide, family disfunction, impact of social media. Extraordinary performances!

Don't see it if You are critical of second rate score, lyrics, book. These are incidental to fact that this material is being presented on Broadway at all.

See it if Extraordinary show even with understudy for Evan. Relevant

Don't see it if looking for old style big musical or great dancing

See it if this truly lives up to the hype: great songs, great performances, clever staging, surprising and unexpected plot twists, just stunning

Don't see it if you don't like teen dramas, complicated family dilemmas, harmony-based​ songs, complexities of social media on life,

Also This sincere reflection told through a musical is surprisingly complex and intelligent. The performances were phenomenal. Very moving experience​ all around.... Read more Read less

See it if Want to see superb talent, hear beautiful music and lyrics and profound drama with hints of joy and laughter

Don't see it if You do not like dealing with teenage angst and being friendless and the consequences of depression

Also This is a life changing show that will teach you to be kind to others. Bring tissues.... Read more Read less

See it if You want to see a show that is relevant, has incredible acting, has outstanding songs, and makes you laugh and cry.

Don't see it if You likes shows with elaborate staging.

See it if you want to see something unique. Great acting and music. Perfect combination of humor and drama.

Don't see it if you want a classic fluffy fun musical.

See it if You've ever been to high school; you want to see an amazing lead performance - really incredible.

Don't see it if Everyone should see it once.

Also Ok, maybe it was all the hype and the waiting but this didn't move me the way it moved all my friends and people I've talked to.

Having said that : the songs are great - I'm still humming them 3 days later. The lighting/set design was incredible - the use of social media is timely and very very moving.

Ben Platt as Evan is one of the most exceptional male lead performances I've seen - full of nuance and his voice is stunning. How he does this 8x/week is mind blowing.

The rest of the cast was also on par.

I definitely think everyone should see it because of the acting and the message about being alone/not being alone. It's important in this age of only knowing people online to remember that people exist. This shows us that in a very real relevant modern way.... Read more Read less

See it if The reason for the success of the show is Tony Winner Ben Platt. He owns the stage and the audience. His acting and singing are outstanding.

Don't see it if Like "Once", I wished the show would be one act and I found the length a bit unnecessary. I think I would like it without an intermission.

See it if you'd enjoy an original musical with a very interesting story, great score and terrific acting.

Don't see it if you don't enjoy an emotional story with many layers.

See it if You want to truly be moved. It is both inspirational and heartbreaking. The show is highly relevant and important.

Don't see it if Issues regarding mental health are triggering. Also the set was disappointing to me.

See it if You've ever felt alone or felt as if you didn't fit in. And, you enjoy a good show with wonderful singing, acting and staging.

Don't see it if You cannot appreciate a dark sense of humor, you're not prepared to emote.

See it if you enjoy the work of Pasek and Paul, and want to see an amazing breakthrough performance from Ben Platt.

Don't see it if you want to see a show with more musical variety, as well as a show that directly speaks about the socially relevant issue at hand.