FinishingTheHat54

See it if You want to see a modern classic on Broadway. Fuller's script deserves the attention and praise. The cast is very talented to boot!

Don't see it if You want to see a "good" production of the show. Felt as though all the tension was sucked out of the piece due to the direction.

Also I'd love to see this show done with urgency or with anything that leans into the actual "murder mystery" of the story. This production ignored that HUGE party of the plot causing this relatively short play to feel like an overly lengthy slog.

Mr. Underwood handles the play comfortably, but the real stars of the show are the soldiers. Combined, their performances are deep and magnetic. Go for them... Read more Read less

See it if You are a die hard Tomei fan or are a subscriber to RTC

Don't see it if you want to see a show with good acting, scenic design, script, or direction...everything is messy and weird

See it if You want to see one of the greats! What a night!!

Don't see it if You...um... I don’t know. Go see it.

See it if You want to support new theatre and you like new takes on current events

Don't see it if You’re wanting a spark of brilliance or true creativity. The cast is generally good but the material services no one. Fluff loses the point

See it if You want an incredible theatrical experience that can’t be matched!

Don't see it if You hate yourself

See it if You want to check out all the shows coming out this season

Don't see it if You want to take the kids (lots of nudity and sex), or if you want a riveting piece of drama.

See it if You’re a Shakespeare fan and looking for a great new take with a great experience.

Don't see it if ...um... maybe just go see it

See it if You want to see two new age masters work in the respective wheelhouses. Both provide powerful and dominant performances. WOW.

Don't see it if small plays aren't your thing or if you are looking to take the kids to a "fun" night out.

See it if You want a fun evening of spectacular spectacle! Great vocal performances from Tveit, Olivo, and the ever entertaining Danny Burstein.

Don't see it if You want a moving experience or anything subtle. This show is loud and brash and is here to be a party.

See it if You want a fast-paced drama that isn’t afraid of comedy or creative story-telling. Great acting all around!!

Don't see it if You want to take your kids to the theatre. They might get bored

See it if you want to see an new, fully exposed, version of a show YOU THINK you know

Don't see it if experimental theatre scares you. It is VERY MUCH it's own thing

See it if You want to see a great Arthur Miller play performed at the highest caliber. Banning, Letts, and Walker are truly amazing!

Don't see it if You don’t like classics, dramas, or foliage... so much foliage

See it if You want to experience a moving and important piece of extremely personal theater.

Don't see it if you can't deal with the truth of our current situation...

See it if You want to spend a dreadfully uninspired evening of “seen it all before” theater. The performers are great but they can’t save this mess...

Don't see it if You have something else you want to see... maybe even skip it if you DON’T have anything else to see

See it if You are a fan of Hnath and his work and style. Ms. Metcalf gives yet another praiseworthy, earth-shaking performance. See it for her.

Don't see it if You are wanting a perfect piece of theatre. It’s entertaining, yes, but the show is missing that little something. See it for the actors

See it if You want a fun and flashy night of good theatre! The cast is absolutely remarkable and the songs are legendary.

Don't see it if You are wanting anything truly new. It’s very formulaic like “Jersey Boys” but, hey, it still works. Check it out!

See it if You want to support new theatre and fresh talent. The cast is very talented.

Don't see it if You want to feel anything from your experience. It was mostly style over substance, sadly. The ending 10 minutes are the REAL play...

See it if You want a fresh new show acted by wonderful, young, fresh actors. Beautiful story and storytelling.

Don't see it if You don’t like new plays or trying anything new at all. It’s a wonderful show.

See it if you want a well acted modern classic performed extremely well. Ethan Hawke gives a masterclass performance!

Don't see it if straight plays aren't your thing.

See it if You want to see a brilliant adaptation of this much beloved work. Wonderful acting, staging, set, and direction.

Don't see it if You are in the mood for a musical. But when you do feel like seeing a play go ahead and see this.

See it if you only care about spectacle. The show has some entertaining moments but they are surrounded by missed opportunities

Don't see it if you are wanting to see the next hit or wanting to be moved by anything. There's really no gain or loss to seeing the show.

Also Everything either goes too far or doesn't go far enough. Kong had nuance, though, which is impressive for a puppet.... Read more Read less

See it if You want a night full of laughs and heart. A perfect show!

Don't see it if You hate laughing...

See it if You want to support new playwrights or enjoy seeing shows in very early stages

Don't see it if you want mediocre acting for an extremely long 90 minutes. I was annoyed by 3 of the 4 characters. oy

See it if You want to experience the newest piece of sweeping theater. A brisk 3 1/4 hrs of the finest acting and writing. A true pleasure.

Don't see it if Long plays discourage you. But I still recommend checking it out

See it if You want to prep yourself for the holidays. A spectacular production of a beloved tale! Unique in its telling and style! Wonderful!

Don't see it if You’re an unchanged Scrooge... :)

See it if You are looking for a unique theatrical experience: a new majestic modern epic. Wow!

Don't see it if You’re looking for a brief show or want to take the kids. The two parts together total about 7hrs worth of theatre

See it if you want a new, smart, dark play that challenges as well as welcomes. It's a beautifully written piece by Mr. Rapp.

Don't see it if dark/heavy subject matter is not your thing

See it if You want to see a great cast sing and act one of the best musicals ever written! Super fun and nice to see a lot of kids in the crowd!

Don't see it if You are looking for a "new" version of it. This is a big throwback to (what I imagine) the original '82 production was like.

Also Biggest let down: rough puppetry. It was a preview, yes, but... i mean... come on... Read more Read less

See it if You want to experience a fantastic new piece! Hard topics, challenging ideas, hilarious and raw approach. O'Hara+O'Harris=excellence!

Don't see it if you are offended by extreme sexual content and language. lots of racial slurs are used, too (it's basically the point)

See it if You have an affinity for LBJ and like plays that are a slice of history

Don't see it if You are looking for the same electric chemistry that “All the Way” provided. The script for this piece can’t hold a candle to the other.

Also The actors are trying their best to suck every bit of nuance they can out this aggressively flat “news article” of a script. The staging is flat and amateur-ish. It seems as though all the good ideas were used for All The Way and now Mr. Rauch has nothing left in terms of creativity.... Read more Read less

See it if You can get lucky enough to snag a ticket! And, also, if you love the movie and the community. It’s an NYC staple. So. Much. Fun.

Don't see it if ... you can’t? I mean, if you can you DEFINITELY should! Take the kids. Take snacks! Have a great night!

See it if You want a fun night out and want to see new theater. Fun throwback to the 70’s

Don't see it if You’re wanting something revelatory or artistically moving. Not that kind of show

See it if you want to experience and support new musical theatre. It is a fascinating insight to a world many of us know nothing about

Don't see it if you are easily offended or if you are looking for a perfectly polished product. most of the second half of the show seemed to lose the point

See it if You are wanting a night of excellence. Top tier performances from top tier performers. See it!

Don't see it if You want to take your children to a show. Lots of nudity, sexual content, language and other things kids won’t understand.

See it if You want a fun & fluffy evening of dark humor and “eye-candy” design elements!

Don't see it if Dirty humor isn’t your thing. Also, the show is fun but not perfect. Act 2 kind of trails off on its way to hell

See it if you want to check out what is BOUND to be a musical sensation. The best new musical of the season!

Don't see it if You don't like unconventional theater or musicals...or mythology

See it if you want a fun fresh evening for kids and adults

Don't see it if you don't know the difference between a noun and a verb

See it if You want to see Adam Driver at his best. He brings so much energy it almost sets the theatre on fire.

Don't see it if You want a musical, a show for the kids, or light theater. Funny, yes, but also heavy themes and strong language.

See it if You want to see a master of comedy, Mr, Lane, own the stage for 90 minutes

Don't see it if You are easily offended or you are looking for anything deep. The show rests in low humor (fart and penis jokes) and there is no real point.

See it if You want a new show with a talented young fresh cast. Quirky and fun!

Don't see it if You want to be moved or are looking for a serious outing. This is NOT that kind of show.

See it if You want to see a classic musical re-staged with high class talent. The singing and dancing is top notch

Don't see it if You are looking for a brief evening of theatre.

See it if You want to experience everything Sondheim on a NYC stage. They have present a solid/new take on an ultimately flawed show.

Don't see it if Musicals annoying you or you need a hummable melody ;)

See it if You are looking for a fun evening of theatre with a great message. Brooks Ashmanskas is gold!

Don't see it if You are looking for something deep and moving. Very mucha fluff piece.

Also While still performed well by all the show remains completely predictable. And even though Christopher Sieber and the cast perform their hearts out on “Love Thy Neighbor” it is still the LOW moment of the show.... Read more Read less

See it if Supporting new theater is your thing. Extremely well acted and a beautiful design. Slow at moments but the acting elevates through.

Don't see it if Dramas or plays aren’t your thing. It’s only 90 mins but still felt long at spots.

See it if Realistic dramas are your thing. Tragically beautiful and well acted. Elaine May and Lucas Hedges are fabulous.

Don't see it if Heavy dramas aren’t your thing. The topic is bleak but relatable. Definitely not for those seeking “light” entertainment.

See it if You want to watch Mr. Cranston at his best! Any chance to see him live is a reason to show up.

Don't see it if You expect to be really interested in this thinly adapted story. Also, the rest of the acting seems like amateur-your compared to Cranston.

Also The direction is ambitious but ultimately gratuitous and distracting. The first half of the show works well... the second half drags and the overall point is lost. Also, the presidential commentary at the end was very much lost on me. I have a vague idea what it was alluding to but I could also be wrong.... Read more Read less

See it if you want to see the play that put Harvey Fierstein on the map. Also, Michael Urie shines extremely bright. Do not miss his performance.

Don't see it if long plays bother you or period pieces aren't your thing.

Also Here's my review:
The production is stellar! Michael Urie owns the stage and from what I've seen so far this season he deserves the Tony for best leading actor. The entire production rests comfortably on his shoulders and he is revelatory. Ms. Ruehl and Mr. Horton are great in the show, too. They make for great counterparts to Urie and add fuel to his fire. I had some issues with some of the other acting but the roles aren't nearly as prominent so it didn't bother me much.
The direction is lovely as is the staging. The set is awesome and the entire aesthetic of the production is so so so cool!
I guess they dropped the "Trilogy" from what used to be "Torch Song Trilogy" because it's now only two acts? What used to be acts 1 and 2 are combined (though obviously separate moments in time) and then the single intermission and act 3 stands alone. Didn't bother me much just made me curious as to why they didn't keep it the three acts and maybe just put a slight pause between 1 and 2.... Read more Read less

See it if You want to see a star-studded cast in a new, very smart and fresh, piece.

Don't see it if Plays bother you, but at 85-minutes as the runtime you might as well go

See it if You want to see stage-great Janet McTeer chew every word and spit them back out with the most thorough analysis possible. She’s a genius.

Don't see it if You are wanting to see a musical.