See it if you like adaptations of Russian stories. Like small intimate shows. OK with multiple actors reading main character's lines.
Don't see it if I honestly don't understand the raves for this show. I just didn't connect to it and found it hard to stay engaged. Very slow moving.
See it if for Sondheim's score, a top notch supporting cast, andPatti Lupone! I liked the gender-swap. Fun night of theater. Also poignant at times.
Don't see it if not a fan of Sondheim. I expected more from Lenk--whenever she sang she adopted Dina's accent from Band's Visit. Very weird.
See it if Great performance by Munoz. Starts strong, lots of interesting themes/ideas. Some parts were great but writer unable to sustain greatness.
Don't see it if you don't like 1 person monologue or plays dealing with heavy themes. Gets muddled in 2nd half, felt like too much was thrown in.
See it if Lovely singing from Anderson and wonderful acting (and singing) from Glick and Siebert. I enjoyed the present day story more than the past.
Don't see it if you don't like shows that are set in varying time periods. WW1 story could be better fleshed out--I found parts of it confusing .
See it if you are a fan of So You Think You Can Dance. Basically a 2 hour SYTYCD routine. Talented and energetic company with some creative choreo.
Don't see it if you aren't interested in hip hop/contemporary dance. Romeo and Juliet plot felt like a stretch.
See it if history told through song, personal stories & exploration of current events. Nice use of projections. Miller is very talented and likable.
Don't see it if A bit all over the place--wish it went a bit deeper and used more of the music to tell the stories. 2nd act much better than 1st.
See it if you enjoy plays that don't take themselves too seriously. This is pure camp, just go with it and enjoy. Very talented and committed cast.
Don't see it if you want something deep or profound. If you are bothered by a man playing a woman.
See it if you are interested in the life of Bess Myerson. Her daughter wrote & stars in this piece-- funny & sad, often at same time. Honest & raw.
Don't see it if you prefer to think of beauty queens as perfect & don't want to see the truth behind the facade. If you don't want mother/daughter conflict.
See it if to see great acting, Ivey and Donovan especially. Sad, bleak story about troubled characters and loss of a town.
Don't see it if you want something light and uplifting. Interesting staging makes it often hard to see. Actors at times talk over each other, hard to hear.
See it if you enjoy modern interpretations of Shakespeare. Good job of making problematic play relevant for today. Injects humor into the story.
Don't see it if you're a Shakespeare purist. If you want elaborate sets and costumes--this is bare bones. Can be a bit hard to follow the plot/characters.
See it if you're a fan of Judy Gold. To see something very funny with some poignant and touching moments. She commands the stage.
Don't see it if you don't like one woman shows or an exploration of mother/daughter dynamics. If you have seen Judy do stand-up, it might feel repetitive.
See it if it's a remarkable if flawed piece of theater. Very ambitious, covers a lot of ground. Great acting and writing. Interesting staging.
Don't see it if at over 6 hours, it's a commitment. If you don't like shows that are too self referential--sometimes heavy handed framing device.
See it if you want to see a hip hop take on culture, gender, race, science, literature. Original clever, and different. Brinkman is very engaging.
Don't see it if you don't like hip hop or one man shows. A bit repetitive but still worth seeing.
See it if great acting from Price and Atkins. They are the only reason to see this.
Don't see it if you want to understand what you are seeing. It's ok to ask the audience to work a bit but this is ridiculous.
See it if you like psychological mysteries. Shows shifting perspectives of 3 characters. If you don't mind an ending that's not neatly tied up.
Don't see it if you want to be more certain of the conclusion. This felt like a work in progress to me--would love to see it more developed.
See it if you are interested in NY political history, remember Bella Abzug or are a Fierstein fan. 1970s politics feel strangely relevant today.
Don't see it if you can't deal with Harvey's voice--this is just him for 90 minutes. Helpful to understand a few words of Yiddish although not necessary.
See it if you enjoy smaller, talky plays with some fabulous writing. Witty, funny lines but serious themes. There's a lot to digest in 90 minutes.
Don't see it if You aren't prepared to concentrate and give this your full attention. If you want more action. If you don't like quiet, small plays.
See it if for the spectacle of it all! Great performances all around but Olivo & Burstein shine. Enjoy for what it is & don't overthink it. It's fun!
Don't see it if you want substance and depth. If you don't like snippets of pop songs. This is an over the top jukebox musical on steroids.
See it if you want theater to challenge you. I appreciated this more than I liked it. Great acting and some brilliant moments but didn't work for me.
Don't see it if Over 2 hours w/out an intermission is way too long--all 3 acts could be cut. If you are disturbed by graphic sex and violence.
See it if you are a fan of Sondheim's work. Some lovely songs. Uranowitz and Jin Ha standouts. If you like Encores stripped down format.
Don't see it if not a great book and I don't feel the Encores format worked very well for this show. Presented as a radio broadcast but not consistently so.
See it if you like shows that don't take themselves too seriously. Just enjoy without overthinking. Annie Golden is great with strong supporting cast.
Don't see it if you want something deep or profound. If you like big productions--this is pretty bare bones but makes effective use of projections.
See it if Talented and energetic cast (including a few understudies) do a great job with mediocre material.
Don't see it if you're not very interested teenagers and/or sci-fi. Stories of teen angst have been done before and done better.
See it if some beautiful songs and fabulous voices. Andrea Burns a standout but strong overall cast. Solid Encores production.
Don't see it if you want a plot driven show-this is mostly a collection of songs. Some of the narratives worked better than others. Some clunky transitions.
See it if to see a well constructed show where all parts work together--good acting, singing, music, story. I was invested in it from the beginning.
Don't see it if you don't like smaller or more minimalist staging. If you don't want to be see horrible racial injustice and abuse.
See it if to experience the journey of the protagonist (playwright). While funny at times, his pain is palpable. Ambitious & creative show. Very meta.
Don't see it if not comfortable with LGBT themes, explicit depiction/description of sexuality, or going deep with painful experiences. Could be tightened.
See it if you enjoy musicals about relationships, Cast is great. Kantor and Walton have lovely voices. Not life changing but I enjoyed the ride.
Don't see it if you aren't in the least bit romantic. Songs aren't terribly memorable. I wish Walton's character of Louise had more of an arc.
See it if for the beautiful voices. I especially loved when the women sang together. A show that evokes a mood rather than tells a coherent story,
Don't see it if you want something plot driven. This is a slice of life piece.We meet people a in depression era boarding house but are left with questions.
See it if you want to hear a Jerry Herman score. Encores orchestra sounds great as always. Act 2 better than act 1.
Don't see it if you want a strong book or to see leads who have chemistry. This fell flat for me, unfortunately.
See it if Malone shines with a fabulous talented supporting cast. Singing especially is beautiful. New interpretation of classic show that works well.
Don't see it if If you don't like old fashioned style of musicals. Dragged a bit in the middle of act 2 but this shouldn't deter you from seeing it.
See it if interested in immigrant stories, told with music and dance. Like to see plays that make you think about contemporary issues.
Don't see it if you want a splashy show--this is very simply staged. If you don't want to hear about the lives of documented and undocumented immigrants.
See it if you are a fan of Linney--she does a great job portraying both protagonist and estranged mother. Some individual monologues are excellent.
Don't see it if you don't want to watch 90 minutes of mother/daughter conflict. Parts don't add up to a whole. Not sure what the point was.
See it if good acting across the board.Interesting premise, wish it went deeper. Mostly good writing although some characters felt a bit like cliches.
Don't see it if I'm not sure how much I will remember of this show but I enjoyed it as I was watching it.
See it if you like your comedy explicit & intelligent at the same time. Unexpected literary references, expected frank talk about sex. Funny moments.
Don't see it if you don't like stand up comedy. If you don't want to hear about a woman's sexual experiences. Show was too long--it felt repetitive.
See it if you want to see a modern retelling of classic myth that isn't Hadestown. Talented and charismatic actors mostly succeed. Some lovely music.
Don't see it if you don't like bare bones, no set or costumes. Story can be a bit hard to follow at times. English accents can be hard to understand.
See it if fan of Esparza--he and rest of the cast are excellent. If you want to see behind the scenes at a restaurant, with lots of yelling.
Don't see it if I'm not sure what the playwright wanted to say. I didn't see growth or change. What is motivation for Krysta's character's involvement?
See it if excellent acting from all 3 leads. Interesting premise of telling story backward. Quiet, slow play demands concentration.
Don't see it if you prefer more action--this is all talk. If you want an elaborate set. If you want likable characters.
See it if you are a fan of the HP books. If unfamiliar, this show won't make much sense. The staging and stagecraft are the real stars here.
Don't see it if you don't have patience for almost 6 hours of theater. Second part especially can be confusing and requires a lot of attention.
See it if you see a lot of theater and enjoy gentle satire. Some skits work better than others. Enjoyable enough but I hoped for more.
Don't see it if you haven't seen most current shows. This is better appreciated by serious theater fans. Spamilton was much more clever.
See it if to get a peek into the creative mind of David Byrne. If you like stylized concerts with interesting staging & choreography. Unique and fun.
Don't see it if you want something with a plot. If you actively dislike Byrne's music--you don't need to be familiar with his work to enjoy this.
See it if you read and enjoyed the book--it's a faithful adaptation in terms of tone. If you are interested in coming of age stories, Latino culture.
Don't see it if you don't want to read supertitles, if you don't understand even a little Spanish (or don't mind missing some words that aren't translated.)
See it if Joshua Henry is phenomenal and rest of the cast is very strong. Music, dancing and choreography mostly great. Some powerhouse songs.
Don't see it if you want a flashy production--this is very simply but effectively staged. Story could be better fleshed out--it feels underdeveloped.
See it if you like improv. The skills of these performers are top-notch. If you are open to a non-traditional theater experience.
Don't see it if you only want to see Lin-Manuel--no guarantee of who will be at any given show. If you don't like not knowing what to expect.
See it if you enjoy family dramas. Unfolds slowly and is entertaining while watching. I was engaged in the story and It held my interest throughout.
Don't see it if Some behavior of characters not believable. I don't think this one is going to stay with me.
See it if you like Meat Loaf and don't mind seeing a story that doesn't make sense. This would have been better as a 90 minute sung through show.
Don't see it if you want to know what you are seeing. Is it an earnest teen dystopian drama? A campy show that winks at the audience? Or just a hot mess?
See it if for the funny lines sprinkled in what is otherwise a mediocre musical. Rudner is fun to watch.
Don't see it if would have worked better as a play rather than a musical. Under 2 hours but felt long. Trite, and predictable.
See it if you like immigrant stories, to see a talented cast giving it their all. Willing to see a show that feels like a work in progress.
Don't see it if you don't have patience for songs that go on too long without providing new information. It's a clever premise that doesn't always deliver.
See it if to see an experimental play that deals with race. If you like absurdist theater. If you want to see this year's Pulitzer prize winner.
Don't see it if I appreciate that the writer wanted to make a statement about race/racism but this just didn't work for me. I didn't like it at all.
See it if you like improv and are willing to take a chance Talented cast and pianist. Some skits worked better than others. Silly fun.
Don't see it if you are not a fan of improv. If it will bother you when some moments fall flat.Not as good as Freestyle Love Supreme--they set a high bar.
See it if you want to see some phenomenal performers in a mostly good (but very by the book) Cirque show and don't mind some weaker numbers mixed in.
Don't see it if you're not a fan of Cirque du Soleil, this won't make you one. They do what they do well but it can get repetitive.
See it if you enjoy study of relationships, plays with talk not action. Story unfolded like a mystery, info revealed little by little.
Don't see it if you don't like going back and forth in time, or same actor playing 2 roles (although it was very clear which he was at all times).