See it if You want a provocative, thought-provoking theater experience. There's a lot of unpack & think about. Was great; not at all what I expected.
Don't see it if You want lighter, fun fare. This show is a lot to process. Race, rape, slavery, nudity. If you can't handle those, stay clear of this show.
See it if Fun improv skits put to music. We laughed a lot. Think musical segments of "Whose Line is it Anyways" but a bit racier/raunchier at times
Don't see it if If the chance at a celebrity guest is the big draw for you. We didn't have a guest & it was disappointing. Some bits dragged on too long.
See it if You enjoyed the Disney cartoon, enjoy community theater based productions, want a fun, carefree show/evening. 100 min show w no intermission
Don't see it if You don't like community theater productions, want a more put together show. Don't want to sit outside all night.
See it if To see Laurie Metcalf & John Lithgow. Superb acting from both. Interesting look at a made-up evening of the 2008 primaries. Pre-Trump era.
Don't see it if You are tired of politics or the Clintons. Set was very minimal. Props/costumes strewn on floor cuz no set pieces-- I found it distracting.
See it if Bryan Cranston is amazing, very relevant, fast-paced play. Shows how news can be manipulated for ratings. Disturbingly relevant.
Don't see it if You want lighter fare. Long w no intermission. Lots of scenes slightly off stage projected on screens, screens were sometimes distracting.
See it if you're a big fan of Star Wars or an actor/friends with actors (lots of insider jokes). [title of show] meets Star Wars.
Don't see it if you don't like/know Star Wars (jokes/references will be lost on you), don't like low budget theater.
See it if You have an interest in politics, the Constitution, hearing personal stories as it pertains to the Constitution. Good, interactive debate.
Don't see it if You are conservative-leaning, don't want to hear how the Constitution applies/doesn't apply to women & POC. More speech than play.
See it if You love the Temptations/Motown. Great singing/dancing. More concert than musical.
Don't see it if You don't like Temptations/Motown or jukebox musicals. Glosses over the story. Jukebox musicals bring jukebox crowds.
See it if You like artsy re-imaginings of classics, shows that take risks, getting up close to the actors. Free chili/cornbread at intermission.
Don't see it if You are a traditionalist. Had an artsy/edgy Brooklyn feel to it. Most voices not up to the challenge of the music. Pared down arrangements.
See it if You want an epic drama with storytelling woven so well that you never lose interest. Great acting. Intense with some levity.
Don't see it if You can't handle 3+ hours, accents are difficult for you to understand, some mild violence & loud noises, or epic dramas are too much.
See it if Little Shop meets Dear Evan Hansen. Geared towards teens. Fun, quirky. Talented leads. Memorable, albeit simple, music. Pop/rock feel.
Don't see it if VERY youthful show-- too young for me. Music elementary/simplistic. Lots of bright, flashy lights. Loud. Tiffany Mann's talents wasted.
See it if You like tiny productions that constantly change based on the news cycle. Actors did great with the material they were given. Fun ad-libbing
Don't see it if You are conservative/Republican/Trump supporter. It's NYC so very left-leaning. It's mediocre, low-budget theater so don't expect a lot.
See it if You like to see new works, like Tom Kitt's music & cast. Great singing and show has potential but needs some refining. Fun superhero moments
Don't see it if Needs a lot of work, most of the songs sounded the same, the superhero idea wasn't developed enough.
See it if You are a fan of Fiddler, cast/staging is fantastic. Simple staging but so moving. Being in Yiddish adds a new layer. Tevye is phenomenal.
Don't see it if You don't like reading subtitles, not a fan of Fiddler, want a big, epic production or big names/talent.
See it if You love Cher & jukebox musicals. Bob Mackie costumes are worth the price of admission alone. Stephanie J. Block is a GODDESS as Star Cher.
Don't see it if You don't like Cher, jukebox musicals, or are tired of the 3 women playing 1 role idea. Show was lighthearted & didn't take itself seriously
See it if You like music of the Go-Go's, jukebox musical comedies, ridiculous/funny story w an ancient theme, non-binary LGBTQ friendly.
Don't see it if Don't like jukebox musicals, LGBTQ themes, comedies, or think the idea of combining Go-Go's music with ancient text is ridiculous.
See it if You want a fluffy/cute/feel-good show, don't mind LGBTQ themes/shows about teens. Fans of Bob Martin. Drowsy Chaperone meets Mean Girls.
Don't see it if You don't like in-your-face LGBTQ themes, comedies that make fun of everyone, clever/witty writing that is also a bit cliched. Very cute.
See it if You like intimate, quirky shows based on Shakespeare, everything is spoken in rhyme, fun music. Very cute & funny. Most of cast was great.
Don't see it if You don't like rhyme, country-westerns, comedies. Nun was very wooden/stiff, hard to watch-- rest of cast was great.
See it if you like smart plays, intelligent writing, masterful acting and are comfortable with LGBT themes. Michael Urie is a gem & must-see.
Don't see it if you are not comfortable with LGBT themes, want something more contemporary than 70's-80's. Play is a smart, family drama w gay themes.
See it if You like musical revues, doo-wop, (mostly) familiar tunes, excellent singing & a fabulous cast with lots of spunk & energy.
Don't see it if You want a plot, dialogue. Singers perform familiar songs from 1950s-70s, so skip if that's not your thing.
See it if You like revue style shows. Little snippets of people discussing things they lost. Clever, compelling music. Funny.
Don't see it if Weak voices and slow. 75min felt much longer. No follow-through plot. Jumped around from snippet to snippet. Weakest of Encores! shows.
See it if You want to see a classic & can forgive the plot. Exquisite singing/dancing. Joshua Henry is a dream.
Don't see it if The idea of a man who beats his wife and never redeems himself bothers you. Jessie Mueller & Joshua Henry were great but lacked chemistry.
See it if You want to see a classic & a sexist story doesn't bother you. Set/production is beautiful. Most of the performers were extraordinary.
Don't see it if This show proves the classics have a shelf life. Misogynistic, sexist, classist. Lauren Ambrose is VERY underwhelming as Eliza.
See it if you have read/watched Harry Potter, are a fan, want to see mind-boggling special effects & want an excellent continuation of the HP universe
Don't see it if you have never read/watched HP or don't like the story. You don't want to devote an entire day for theater. You scare easily.
See it if You enjoy the movie, Tina Fey, snarky humor, high school antics, fun & belty singing.
Don't see it if You don't like the movie or Tina Fey's comedy styles, want something intellectual/gripping, don't like youth-focused shows.
See it if You have kids, especially fans of the book. Show is short and fast-paced. Fun and quirky.
Don't see it if Not a kid. Want more focused show. Not really Broadway caliber. More suited for off-Broadway. Music not memorable.
See it if Beautiful costumes, set, theater. Amazing dancing. Incredibly sexy. Mostly great performances. Fun night of theater. Ensemble is STELLAR.
Don't see it if You don't like jukebox musicals. It's VERY heavy-handed in jukebox. If you don't like overly sexy, scantily clad performers.
See it if Acting was superb. They were both compelling and interesting to watch and used the space in a great and realistic way.
Don't see it if I have no idea why this was a play or why it was so long. Coworkers sleep together and talk about life. Not that interesting a concept.
See it if You want to see great choreography/dancing, Kelli O'Hara sounds sublime, classic & familiar show tunes.
Don't see it if You want anything new in a revival. This was very middle-of-the-road & a bit slow. Kelli wasn't "shrew" enough. Confusing ending.
See it if You enjoy Encores productions, light fare, silly/fluffy plot, beautiful dancing. Vocal harmonies are stellar. Lots of funny moments.
Don't see it if You want a fully staged show, something w a meatier plot or a moral to the story. Pure silliness. A few ear worms but music isn’t memorable.
See it if you want a commercial Broadway show that checks all the boxes. You enjoyed the movie. Crazy sets, costumes, props. Kritzer steals the show.
Don't see it if you are a movie purist (plot changes made BJ a hero by the end), very theme park feeling, music all sounded the same. Not suitable for kids.
See it if The book is hilarious, acting is great. Santino & Andy G (roommate) are brilliant. Updated twist on classic movie. Fun comedy.
Don't see it if You are married to the movie- lots of changes. Music is forgettable/boring, choreography is unnecessarily complicated. Anticlimactic ending.
See it if You like Hammerstein's classics put to "jazzy" arrangements, you want to see an obvious passion project/cabaret given full staging.
Don't see it if Blasphemous arrangements, ridiculous & unnecessarily complicated set, over-acted/poorly acted, ego project by a cabaret singer.
See it if You like refreshing, new musicals. Music/set has a NOLA/Preservation Hall feel. Music, staging, set, & cast are gorgeous. Captivating.
Don't see it if You want something more traditional & old school. This is a contemporary show w dark undertones.
See it if You REALLY like the stars, short plays (95min), crude/gory comedy is appealing.
Don't see it if Crass humor, gross/gory comedy, lots of bodily function jokes aren't your thing. They lay it on thick & only some of the gags work.
See it if You like Shakespeare, Jackson is fantastic as Lear. Inclusive & diverse cast. Great acting. 3.5hrs flew by.
Don't see it if You don't like Shakespeare, long shows, tragedies, loud noises, gunshots. Onstage musicians sometimes overpowered actors.
See it if You like Encores! productions, seeing old, rarely revived shows, like a lot of dancing. Light fare, not a lot of brain-power needed.
Don't see it if You don't have a sense of humor, like fully staged productions, don't like dance, want a solid plot. No memorable songs. VERY dated.
See it if You are a fan of Alice in Wonderland, Duncan Sheik's music, new works. Creative take on Alice. Talented cast.
Don't see it if You don't like shows still in the creative phase. Book needs a lot of work. Some actors overacted. Must read character insert to follow.
See it if You love Encores! shows, Carmen Cusak, great singing/dancing. Encores! productions are always charming & fun. Political but still relevant.
Don't see it if You want a fully staged show. Show is dated but has a current feel. A bit sexist, old-fashioned, cliched, & cookie-cutter/predictable.
See it if You love the movie and Bryan Adams' music. Iconic costumes, iconic scenes, iconic lines. A good "date" show-- even guys can get behind it.
Don't see it if It was a soggy piece of white bread. So bland and boring. Music was forgettable. Iconic lines weren't delivered correctly.
See it if You like unconventional plays with the tendency to be off the cuff and changing on the fly. Different guest star every night.
Don't see it if You run the risk of getting a dud of a guest star. Stay away if you want a linear play, a set, and a rehearsed piece.
See it if To see Kong! The puppetry is absolutely amazing. It's the only reason to see the show. And the set was cool when not overrun by LED screens.
Don't see it if You want strong leads & decent score. Music couldn't pick a genre & blatantly ripped off well-known songs. Lead characters/actors were weak.
See it if Interesting & fascinating look at importance of skin tone & status in an African girls school in 80s. Much better than I expected.
Don't see it if You want a play longer than 75min, don't care about Africa in the 80's/race & status themes. Some of the actors couldn't hold the accent.
See it if Female empowerment, queer themes interest you. You don't shy away from the use of "p*ssy". Twisted comedy, intimate setting, fun use of set.
Don't see it if You're offended by the word "p*ssy", don't want a queer/lesbian centered show or women finding empowerment. Leans towards crass.
See it if You want a funny, cheesy show riddled with cliches (on purpose; it adds to the humor). New musicals with no source materials are rare.
Don't see it if You want a drama or something epic/emotional. This is silly comedy, plain & simple. Voices aren't stellar & everything is over-the-top.
See it if You want to see Condola Rashad, enjoy long dramas, like the story of Joan of Arc, like religious-based plays. Great cast. Interesting set.
Don't see it if Long-winded, "talky" play. Lots of references to God & religion. It's long & slow. Great production but I kept falling asleep.
See it if You want a masterclass in acting. Cast is AMAZING. Play about being gay/having AIDS in the 80's feel very relevant.
Don't see it if You can't invest the time in a two-part, 8-hr play (but it's worth it), don't want to see a drama/play. Don't like LGBTQ themes, nudity.
See it if You like witty, silly shows with catchy & singable songs. Christian Borle is fantastic. Dancing was fun.
Don't see it if Comedy isn't your thing. You don't like British fare. You want a fully staged production. Encores is a costumed/choreographed concert.
See it if You are a fan of Donna Summer & want more of a concert of her greatest hits. All 3 Donnas are superb. Great vocals/dancing/female ensemble.
Don't see it if You want a strong book/want to know more about her life; they brushed over a lot. More of a concert than a musical.
See it if You are a fan of Joshua Jackson, want to explore deaf activism. Lauren Ridloff is intriguing & gives great performance.
Don't see it if You don't like super-titles/signing. Some deaf speakers are hard to understand. Joshua Jackson & Anthony Edwards give meh performances.