Melanie Votaw

Melanie Votaw is a critic with BroadwayWorld. This account has been auto-generated, and does not indicate that this person is an active member of Show-Score.com. That said, if you "follow" this member, you will automatically be updated whenever s/he writes a new review.

If you are this critic, please see the instructions on how to add reviews, update your profile, or make changes to your excerpts and scores.

Reviews (11)
God is a Woman
Soho/Tribeca
BroadwayWorld

"Luisa Omielan Will Make You Laugh and Cry in Her American Debut 'GOD IS A WOMAN'" Full Review

BroadwayWorld

"There's a lot to like about this show, but it isn't wholly successful for a variety of reasons. First of all, in my opinion, 90-minute musicals rarely work. It's a tall order to develop characters, as well as relationships...While partially due to the short duration of the show, part of that is also due to the writers' decision to include some of the dialogue within the songs like recitative...That said, the actors hold the musical together nicely." Full Review

The Migration
Midtown W
BroadwayWorld

"The show provides a visceral history that covers the gamut of emotions from deep sorry to joyous celebration...On lead vocals, Smith took us to church with her stirring and soaring voice as the group performed traditional African-American spirituals...A history in dance and music that honors past generations of Africans and African-Americans, as well as the artistry of Jacob Lawrence, while providing audiences with a thrilling show." Full Review

Terezin
Midtown W
BroadwayWorld

"The tragic story of the people at Terezin is certainly a worthwhile subject, and Tolkien's play has merit. However, it needs further development. The staging is somewhat stylized, which only distanced me from creating an emotional connection with the characters...Least effective is the use of actors playing ghosts at various times throughout the play...For the most part, the actors do a good job with the material given and with their difficult accents." Full Review

Turning Page
Lower E Side
BroadwayWorld

“In the one-woman show 'Turning Page,' Angelica Page takes on perhaps the role of her career—that of her real-life mother, Geraldine Page...It's an interesting device learning about Angelica's atypical childhood through her mother's voice…As directed by Wilson Milam, Angelica's writing comes alive in a true tour-de-force performance—a valentine to a mother, a woman, and a seminal actress that we all lost too soon.” Full Review

BroadwayWorld

"Gethard is part stand-up comic and part poignant storyteller, moving seamlessly between self-deprecating jokes and heart-wrenching moments...While suicide attempts, alcoholic blackouts, and graphic stories about pharmaceutical side effects don't seem like fodder for comedy, Gethard skillfully makes them funny without ever losing sight of the seriousness of his subject matter. He pulls this off partly because he's talking about his own life, but also because he is unflinchingly honest." Full Review

BroadwayWorld

"NOVENAS FOR A LOST HOSPITAL is a Moving Tribute to a New York Institution" Full Review

BroadwayWorld

“80 minutes of classic gay snark...Droege is hilarious as Gerry, causing the audience to laugh loudly and often at the character's antics, which include a number of popular culture references...While the section in which Gerry lets down his guard is needed in a play that would otherwise be too superficial, this portion dragged a bit and could have been shorter. Nevertheless, 'Bright Colors' is an entertaining character sketch. It might not get you thinking very much, but it will keep you laug... Full Review

BroadwayWorld

"While the new musical isn't of Broadway caliber, there's a lot to like about both the book and the score...The greed and money woes in the scenes are predictable, and there's nothing particularly enlightening about what Franklin or the other characters say. But it's entertaining to watch the founding father try to navigate through the modern world...Three of the cast members, including Byers, have appeared on Broadway, and they all do a respectable job with the material." Full Review

Angry Young Man
Chelsea
BroadwayWorld

"Both entertaining and puzzling...The play veered off into directions that failed to provide a satisfying plot...The play is done in such a clowning, vaudevillian manner that whatever the playwright hoped to communicate is lost...The frivolous comedy is uncomfortable. I suppose I expected a comedy with more serious overtones considering the subject matter. That said, all four actors pull off a very difficult piece, as they seamlessly switch roles and change accents throughout." Full Review

BroadwayWorld

"This satirical play is timely as we watch the historic battle of the sexes between presidential candidates Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton...Rebeck's writing, Mamet-esque and tack-sharp, is a pleasure to behold. This production, directed by Lorca Peress, is well done with standouts in the cast, Lesley McBurney as Eliza and Ean Sheehy as her smart but cowardly colleague, Ben." Full Review