Scott 31

See it if If you want to see something original that is unlike anything you have ever seen before!

Don't see it if You are a blithering idiot!

Also When the show ended I said something to the person next to me that I had never said before in 30 something years of theatre going, "I want them to start it over again! Hardcore theatre goers know the dynamo known as Jenn Collela but I think after this show everyone will! There were three numbers that stopped the show! The only negative thing is the book gives a little too much time to uninteresting characters! Go tickets soon before it sells out for the next year!... Read more Read less

See it if You watched all your friends get married before you

Don't see it if If you watched all your friends get married before you

See it if You like to see good actors in bad plays

Don't see it if You want to remember when Matthew Broderick was good.

Also The show began with a monologue by Matthew Broderick that he barely was able to remember and his trouble with his lines continued for the entire performance. The show was intentionally vaugue and people were trying to figure out the mystery but I believe that you were not meant to understand it! Michael Tucker was exceptional as was Annapurna Sriram. John Epperson, Larr Pine and Claudua Shear did the best they could with underwritten parts! I would consider seeing it again when Matthew Broderick has his lines memorized but I don't think it would make a difference. By the way the gentleman who was loudly snoring during most of the second half of the show told me he thought it was excellent!... Read more Read less

See it if You want to see a musical that loves musicals and if you are a huge musical fan who will get all the in jokes.

Don't see it if You don't like musicals, you wont get it

See it if One of the bests shows I've ever seen

Don't see it if your a moron

See it if You want to see three brilliant actresses hamming it up

Don't see it if You like your theatre a little meatier

See it if If you think Nina Arianda is the second coming

Don't see it if If you think Sam Sheppard is overrated

See it if You like excellent acting.

Don't see it if you don't want to go to the theatre to watch an episode of a basic cable show.

See it if You want to see 4 young actors giving beautiful performances

Don't see it if You are disturbed by underage girls in sexual situations

Also A well acted, well written and perfectly staged show! Three if the actors are well known from tv and movies but I believe you will start seeing them in the stage more due to the fire they bring to their performances! My only negative is that the show is set in the 1980's and there really is no purpose to it!... Read more Read less

See it if You enjoy seeing a musical that's a little different

Don't see it if You have a deep seated fear of subways

Also There was a joke in the producers where Max Bialystock says he invented theatre in the square where no one has a good seat. That joke is kind of true here. The way they configured the theatre, I would say at least half the audience had blocked views. Erin Mackey pretty much stole the show, though most of the cast was excellent. One other note, its a little early in the run to have two of the leads out and understudies performing. I miss the days when a slip in the playbill was a rarity and not an everyday occurance!... Read more Read less

See it if You want a fun silly evening out and so you can brag to friends in 20 years how you saw the legendary Annaleigh Ashford play a dog

Don't see it if You hate dogs and matthew broderick

See it if You want to see a tired shadow of a great show

Don't see it if You want the show to close so we can get something fresh into that theatre

See it if You want to participate in discussions about the worst shows in the history of theatre

Don't see it if you have any items in your possession you can throw at the stage

See it if you're alive

Don't see it if Your too stupid to realize your watching genius at work

See it if If you want to see a fun silly show.

Don't see it if You don't want to lose your theatre snob card