Seth G

See it if you love a classic, old school musical, love great big dance numbers or Kelli O'Hara

Don't see it if you want to see something more contemporary on stage, or anything new-aged

See it if you like Nathan Lane and dick jokes

Don't see it if you want to see anything substantial. Plot is frail and script is confusing

See it if you love Motown and want to know the backstory on The Temps.

Don't see it if you want to see a show with all new original music, or a archetype that’s new, it’s in the same vein as other jukebox musicals

See it if you love comedy (and want to hear the most jokes told on Broadway per minute!) and want to hear the dynamic Santino Fontana kill it!

Don't see it if you don't have a open sense of humor or don't like fowl language (lots of curse words thrown around)

See it if you want a new take on a old classic. Beautiful set, voices and acting. Very imaginative and artsy

Don't see it if you don't have a creative imagination or want to be close (on in) the action

See it if you want a not so happy, happy ending and great singing

Don't see it if you want to be blown away by a story. Great arch but second half needs a bit tweaking.

See it if you like historical Irish plays. And enjoy incredible immersive sets.

Don't see it if you don't quite understand Irish accents or the long history of the Ireland

See it if you love songs that send the plot forward and are very Jewish and if you want to appreciate actors playing every instrument imaginable!

Don't see it if you want a large scale production or want anything of deep meaning

See it if you love the "overcoming against all odds" story, appreciate acceptance of others and incredible costumes!

Don't see it if you are uncomfortable with men in drag

See it if you want to experience the struggle of tradition versus modernity played out, want to empathize with the plight of being young and gay

Don't see it if you dislike LGBTQ plot lines, you don't like song in a serious dramatic play

Also Incredible show. Masterful writing, acting, singing. Jeremy Pope is a revelation. I just wish this wasn't a limited engagement. The plot is amazing and the blend of the actors voices is like sweet butter. Run to see Choir Boy!... Read more Read less

See it if you love stories of family dynamics and loyalty.

Don't see it if you don’t understand Irish accents and don’t like a little blood.

See it if you want to see a classic on stage, very cool how they give power to Eliza compared to the past, nice modern take

Don't see it if you want something fast paced and modern. Great show, but felt a bit laggy.

See it if You love the Donna Summer songbook and seeing a underdog story on the stage

Don't see it if You feel uncomfortable seeing stories about domestic abuse and women’s empowerment

See it if you want to see unbelievable pupeteering. King Kong himself steals the show!

Don't see it if you want to see something of substance. The music doesn’t fit the time period (rap and auto-tune), acting that is outshined by a puppet.

Also This show isn’t sustainable. See it once to see the puppet and there is no need to see it again.... Read more Read less

See it if you want to see true authenticity and time travel to the Old Country. You are Jewish, every Jew should see this show to see our history live

Don't see it if you don’t know the Fiddler on the Roof story since this production is in a different language.

See it if you like creative, Adam Sandler-esque plot, rock musicals. Super creative, funny and relevant. It's an ever-man's show.

Don't see it if you're easily offended by typical cultural stereotypes and if your'e over 70 or younger then 15.

Also Take a bit of Dodgeball, Grown Ups, and other comedy legends and you get this show. It can relate to anyone in any culture, young and old. One of the funniest musicals out on Broadway today. This will translate seamlessly to the Big Screen. Let's hope this show runs for a while!... Read more Read less

See it if you love the music and legacy of Carole King and want to know her backstory.

Don't see it if you don't like "oldies" music and/or don't know who Carole King is.

See it if you love a Broadway classic. This feels like a throwback compared to what's currently on Broadway. You like stories told through dance.

Don't see it if you aren't into to typical gender roles and don't like operatic style of singing.

See it if you love Disney and Frozen. Want to see strong leads and incredible lighting effects.

Don't see it if you want anything profound or moving. Want to see it keep to the exact movie plot, second half is almost completely different.

See it if you want to waste money and time, are an extreme fan of Jimmy Buffett.

Don't see it if you common sense and have any amount to spend on literally any other show.

Also Please, for your own sanity, skip this show!

Worst part is the Ushers encourage the audience to sing along. I did not pay to hear 70+ year old women screaming in my ear. Only redeeming quality the show has is the principal actors have nice voices. But that was ruined by the obnoxiousness of the audience.... Read more Read less

See it if you like John Lithgow. That's about it.

Don't see it if you like an action packed story with multiple people.

Also First half put me to sleep-it was SO slow. Second act picks up a little, but not much.... Read more Read less

See it if You love stories of togetherness, overcoming obstacles and a wide variety of music. This show has it all!

Don't see it if You want the mundane, run of the mill Broadway show or are sensitive to bright lights.

Also Growing up with Spongebob, this show hits home. It plays true to the cartoon characters while adding layers to them. Don't be afraid that this is billed as a "kids" show, it's not. Spongebob had everything one could want in a Broadway show, love, drama, show-stoppers. It's a must see!

UPDATE: I've seen this show 6 times since writing the review. It is better each time!... Read more Read less

See it if You love to laugh at relational and sexual humor, enjoy creative writing and masterful comedic acting.

Don't see it if You don't find the absord funny, if you're easily confused by a non- linear plot.

Also The whole cast shines. Each brings something different and hilarious to the production.... Read more Read less

See it if you want to laugh and cry while experiencing one of the most amazing true stories to come to Broadway.

Don't see it if you don't like Celtic music, and are easily confused by character changes.

See it if you want an play that plays on the abstract and shows you the power of connections and want to see a strong performance by the billed leads

Don't see it if you dislike nudity, undertones of homosexuality or are a child

See it if you want to be challenged to think differently, to think more about our future as a country

Don't see it if you are not open to different ideas or more contemporary thought. If you are conservative leaning, this isn't the show for you...

See it if an incredible story by masterful actors, an intense plot

Don't see it if you don't like long shows (runs about 2:45) or you're a kid, this is for adults

See it if you want to see a Broadway adaptation of the movie. Parts of the plot changed to fit on the stage. More hilarious than the film IMO

Don't see it if you want the exact movie or any real moving plot. You want something that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

See it if you love an epic love story that takes you from high to low to high and back.

Don't see it if you want the perfectly gift-wrapped ending.

See it if you are in High School or love sci-fi. Great singing specifically from George Salazar.

Don't see it if you want to see anything profound or mature. It’s oddly similar to Little Shop..

See it if you want to hear some great voices and see cool set with fun movie posters

Don't see it if you want anything of substance specifically a plot, script and acting. The use of movie quotes takes away from the whole show

See it if you like Sondheim and his style of work

Don't see it if you are easily confused by a plot working itself backwards.

See it if you want to see the iconic story revisioned and revisited, you appreciate the incredible acting of Daniels

Don't see it if you can't handle the truth of our society and justice system, and believe things work out as they should.

See it if you love Cher's songbook and over the top costumes or want to see epic performances by Block and Spector.

Don't see it if you are expecting a great book, the script falls short. If you want to see a deep and meaningful show.

See it if you love the movie or are a fan of Andy Karl or Samantha Barks. It stays true to the film.

Don't see it if you want anything spectacular. Barks shines, but nothing else really stands out about the show. Great plot, but it's the same as the movie.

See it if you love Mike Birbiglia's comedy, want to hear about the pros and cons of fatherhood. Very authentic and relatable. Incredible story teller!

Don't see it if you want a typical Broadway show. This is a one-man, nothing more. No crazy set or dance number.

See it if you want to see an authentic LGBTQ narrative on stage, a true mix of classic and modern theater.

Don't see it if you are homophobic, or not liberal to be honest

See it if you like small, up close and personal shows

Don't see it if you’re easily confused by an actor constantly changing characters

See it if you want to see a masterful performance by Michael Urie, you love the ups and downs of relationships in ones life.

Don't see it if you dislike LGBTQ+ narratives

See it if you love 'oldies' music and want to see it sung in a very modern setting

Don't see it if you dislike do-wop or want to see a show with a plot running through it.

See it if you love the Wild West, Shakespeare and comedy! All three are mixed together in a beautiful blend that is so unique.

Don't see it if you aren't in the mood to laugh and want to see really serious theater. You need to have a serious funny bone to appreciate this show.

See it if you want to see the next generation of Broadway hits. Mix of the classics and new age.

Don't see it if you are close minded about the wave of commercial shows on Broadway and want a very traditional set.

See it if you love rock music and loud music

Don't see it if you don't like bright lights, loud sound and gimmicky/hoaxy staging. Odd transitions between end of rock song to new classical piece.

See it if you want to see the command of a masterful actor that is Denzel Washington. And want to see the human experience live and raw.

Don't see it if you are afraid to face the realities of life and the good and bad/ugly of ones life goals and dreams.

See it if you want to be taken away to the islands and wrapped up in song and dance that take your breathe away!

Don't see it if you get confused with a story within a story.

Also Alex Newell is like no other..incredible!

See it if You love middle eastern music, the search for love and enjoy minimalism. Just so pure.

Don't see it if You want to see big dance numbers or sets or under 13 years old.

Also Just pure beauty. From the music that flows from the stage, to the silence that takes you over. Definetly an adults show, would go right over a kids head.... Read more Read less

See it if You're looking for a inclusive, family friendly show that preaches kindness and acceptance.

Don't see it if You hate puppets or looking for a more sophisticated show.

See it if You like Clive Owen and are open to exploring sexuality on stage.

Don't see it if You don't want to see full nudity, laugh at jokes that don't match the rythm of the play and don't mind the 4th wall broken.

See it if you love musicals that move you and make you feel through music and masterful acting. Very relatable to nuances of family and modern day

Don't see it if you aren't open to topics of mental illness and suicide. Want a big show stopping dance number.

See it if you believe in the power of art and how it intertwines lives.

Don't see it if you don't understand Jewish quirks and nuances.