Cagney NYC Reviews and Tickets

85%
(501 Ratings)
Positive
94%
Mixed
6%
Negative
0%
Members say
Entertaining, Delightful, Great acting, Great singing, Clever

About the Show

'Cagney' follows the actor from his humble beginnings through his rise as a vaudeville song-and-dance man, to his superstardom in Hollywood.

Read more Show less

Show-Score Member Reviews (501)

Sort by:
  • Default
  • Standing in our community
  • Highest first
  • Lowest first
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Only positive
  • Only negative
  • Only mixed
64 Reviews | 11 Followers
95
Clever, Delightful, Funny, Refreshing, Entertaining

See it if You love good old fashioned tap dancing musicals!

Don't see it if You are looking for a deep, emotional, serious show.

52 Reviews | 10 Followers
95
Delightful, Enchanting, Entertaining

See it if ...you enjoy watching shows about past entertainers. I though I was seeing the real James Cagney!

Don't see it if ....music from the past is not your cup of tea.

82 Reviews | 16 Followers
95
Absorbing, Delightful, Funny, Great staging, Great dancing

See it if you like small shows with good dancing and period pieces. If you like based-on-a-true-story or the-little-guy-wins stories.

Don't see it if you want a big spectacle or you only like modern shows or you don't like tap-dancing.

127 Reviews | 24 Followers
95
Delightful, Entertaining, Great acting

See it if You want to see a wonderfully fun musical with plenty of tap dancing. You are a big fan of James Cagney.

Don't see it if You do not like musicals.

209 Reviews | 77 Followers
95
Absorbing, Entertaining, Great acting, Must see, Great singing

See it if You are a fan of Cagney, like old gangster films, want to find out more about Cagney, great performances.

Don't see it if You don't like musicals, don't want to be entertained. SEE THIS. Read more

61 Reviews | 53 Followers
95
Absorbing, Entertaining, Clever, Funny, Great dancing

See it if You enjoy learning about iconic personalities through song and dance, especially tap dancing... seeing the backstage events.

Don't see it if You want HUGE sets and casts with fancy costumes in your musicals... Are picky about the facts.

217 Reviews | 79 Followers
94
Delightful, Amazing dancing!, Entertaining

See it if you love dancing, you love Cagney, you love old movies

Don't see it if you don't like musicals

435 Reviews | 60 Followers
93
Clever, Delightful, Enchanting, Entertaining, Funny

See it if want to see a great talent in an entertaining role

Don't see it if you're dead

Critic Reviews (51)

T
April 4th, 2016

"A thoroughly entertaining evening of song and dance served by an outstanding ensemble of performers...Robert Creighton plays James Cagney, a role he was born to play...'Cagney' hits most of the highlights of the actor's ascent to stardom and his struggle with his image in an insightful musical journey with fancy choreography by Bergasse that features exciting tap numbers...Jeremy Benton has several dynamite tap numbers with Creighton that alone are worth the price of a ticket."
Read more

Motherhood Later
April 10th, 2016

"An exhilarating and heartfelt Off-Broadway musical…A natural, athletic hoofer with a feisty personality, Cagney is a beloved icon, and Robert Creighton does him justice and then some…Director Bill Castellino keeps things moving, and choreography by Joshua Bergasse is inspired…What a pleasure to see an Off-Broadway show deliver a full-out ensemble dance number that brings down the house, when so many Broadway musicals these days are lacking in that arena."
Read more

Labor Press
April 14th, 2016

"The rousing musical is full of song and tap dance which will excite audiences of all ages. Robert Creighton, who plays Cagney, also wrote the original music and lyrics along with Christopher McGovern, and is adeptly directed by Bill Castellino. Cagney could do it all; act, dance, sing and be the tough guy who portrays gangsters, sometimes with a heart. Creighton does an excellent job as Cagney."
Read more

Critics at Large
April 11th, 2016

"It’s not a great musical–Peter Colley’s book is serviceable and the new songs are mediocre. But it’s not bad. The modesty of the production works in its favor, and it does what few musicals manage to accomplish: it gets better as it goes along...Mostly it’s because of Robert Creighton, who can act as well as sing and dance, and whose fireplug frame and fireball presence make him ideal casting for the title role...He’s an excellent Cagney, and when he gets to dance...he’s a phenomenon."
Read more

I
November 3rd, 2016

"Lest you think all of Off-Broadway is bold new work, here’s a throwback: a straight-up show biz bio...There’s some fun tapping to be had and the cast is certainly game, but this musical tribute isn’t terribly interested in revealing anything more about the man than we know in the first few scenes."
Read more

Rock NYC
April 15th, 2016

"'Cagney' gets many things very wrong, the book and the music and lyrics among them, but what it gets right more than makes up for it...A scene of Cagney and troupe performing for soldiers in a USO show in 1942 was so magical, it may have been the best moment in a musical this season...It justified the entire evening in a heavenly song and dance of epic proportions...Creighton has brought an excellent cast to perform with him."
Read more

W42st Magazine
May 1st, 2016

"The story is beautifully created...The choreography recreates the magic of old Hollywood musicals. The style mirrors Cagney's and is astounding to watch...Robert Creighton as Cagney is unbelievable. There's not a moment in the production where you're not enthralled by his performance. He's mesmerizing and you truly believe you are watching James Cagney perform in front of you."
Read more

NY Theatre Guide
April 3rd, 2016

"Creighton plays Cagney and seems born for the role. A strong dancer and singer, he was a joy to watch...This cast of extremely strong dancers sure know how to work hard...Some of the strongest moments in 'Cagney' are the many dance numbers, with an emphasis on some really fun strong tap routines...This cast is truly in sync with the orchestra and has a seamless flow from song to song and scene to scene...If you like musical theater, film history and James Cagney, this is the show for you."
Read more