"It could be said that 'Long Day’s Journey Into Night' is the absolute quintessential American play—the greatest of all 20th-century American plays...Manville seizes the opportunity to turn Mary into a tour de force of unmitigated anxiety. And appreciative nods to Irons—who looks like Eugene O’Neill (!)—for giving a typically generous on-the-mark performance. Is Eyre’s meeting with O’Neill perfect? It’s a close as anyone might want. Nothing seems missing." Full Review
"'Long Day's Journey into Night,' which has been called America's greatest play, has had two other major New York productions since 2003… However, that the play reveals so many different facets in each version tells you how great a play it is. Irons, Manville and company have a myriad of things to show us in this magnum opus… And in Manville's performances, she reaches the heights of the dramatic art: you never feel that she is acting for one moment but has become Mary Tyrone." Full Review
“Eyre’s deeply intimate staging of O’Neill’s autobiographical masterpiece...A stunning, slightly amended production...Howell’s set is staggeringly breathtaking...Eyre focuses on conversations between two characters, making it feel like we are invading their privacy, intruding on this dysfunctional family...The cast is exceptional, led by a brilliant performance by Manville...As dark as the play is, Eyre holds out just enough hope that this time things will turn around for the Tyrones.” Full Review
"Eyre’s production plays so grippingly that it's never a slog...Each repetition...rings true, and many of them prove comical...The crucial role in any production is Mary...Manville is superb, from her pitch-perfect American accent to the way she veers from worry to delight, to petulance, to any other emotion you’d care to name...This production induces a warmth and affection toward its characters, especially Manville’s Mary, that promise a memorable experience." Full Review
"A dreamy, vortex-like quality presides...extends beyond the physical production to the performances, especially Lesley Manville’s feverishly brilliant portrayal of Mary...Considering the nearly three-and-a-half-hour running time, director Eyre keeps scenes moving at a sprightly pace as characters lash out at one another and retreat to their respective corners...If there’s a reason to see this 'Long Day’s Journey,' it’s to watch Ms. Manville transform." Full Review
"Do we need another 'Long Day's Journey' just two years after Jonathan Kent's acclaimed Broadway revival with Jessica Lange and Gabriel Byrne? The answer is yes and the principal reason is Manville's complex, insightful interpretation of Mary...Hers is the least stagy, most convincing performance one is likely to see, with no concessions to vanity or interpretive innovation...The three men surrounding Manville tackle their roles from disparate and somewhat incompatible angles." Full Review
"I’ve never seen a more loving portrayal of Mary Tyrone than Manville’s...What’s most impressive about Manville’s performance—and it is an extremely impressive performance—is her ever-so-subtle transformation from fresh-from-the-sanatorium recovering addict into drug-dependent shell of a woman...Inevitably, the energy flags when Manville is off-stage. Though it’s undeniably fun listening to Irons do Tyrone’s foreign-authors rant." Full Review
"The scathing autobiographical honesty and desolation of the playwright’s masterpiece...Manville, especially, brings that heartbroken quality to the fore in a wrenching performance...A mesmerizing symphony of rambling, barely disguised resentments and outbursts of flashing anger...Irons matches her step-by-step, his terrific portrayal of James moving sure-footedly...In this production, only Keenan, as the drunken, brothel-going elder brother, falls short." Full Review
"Their performances brim with anguish and gritty realism, while Eyre's direction adds a dreamlike patina to this story...Irons's performance is notable for capturing the silent gestures buried in O'Neill's work that only a great actor could tease out...Though Eyre's direction keeps the action moving despite voluminous passages of dialogue, the play's second half sputters during the long scene between Edmund and James...Fortunately, this production does not drift." Full Review
"O’Neill’s domestic dance feels like a literal dance at times in this version...The distinctive touches of the production, some at variance with the playwright’s conception, don’t wind up seriously detracting from what most matters...The play is a powerful and insightful tragedy that painfully reveals the specific regrets, disappointments and self-loathing of a damaged family...For me the production at BAM suffers for coming just two years after that Broadway production starring Jessica Lange." Full Review
“A fervent depiction of a love-hate relationship among a family of four, a kind of intense ping-pong game for the production’s three-and-a-half hours on stage...The text of the play arguably compares to opera...The work presents an authentic human tragedy...Irons does a fine job as the family patriarch, against tough odds. Manville’s early scenes display an uncomfortable sing-song-y vocal pattern, but smooths out as the play ensues.” Full Review
"The four lumber forward, each getting their moment in the spotlight to illuminate their pathetic and self-defeating mindsets, fluctuating between moments of tenderness and affection with resentments and outwardly hostile blame. The moments are staggering and generally authentically delivered, but the minutes start to feel like hours, and I can’t help but secretly hold my breath waiting for Mary to reenter and give her final monologue, signaling the end." Full Review
"If Eyre has guided Manville and Irons into giving performances that surely must rank among their best, he hasn't done as well by the younger generation of Tyrones...This is not the most accomplished production of 'Long Day's Journey Into Night' to come our way in recent years, but anyone who loves this piece -- one of American drama's very few masterpieces -- will be fascinated by the way Manville and Irons inhabit their characters' darkest corners." Full Review
"Eyre’s mixed bag of a revival, one alternately engrossing and overly wound up, and in any case, disappointingly, never a soul-shatterer. The absorbing aspects have mostly to do with the motivations and interactions of Irons’s James and Manville’s Mary...It rarely has been as clear as in the way Irons and Manville impress it upon us the depths of James’s and Mary’s narcissism, how their lifelong fixations on their own stunted childhoods have rendered them incapable of nurturing anyone else." Full Review
"This 'Journey' is often downright sprightly. That doesn’t mean that after three-and-half hours in the company of the Tyrones you don’t still feel numb with fatigue...For a while, it’s a gripping, oddly enjoyable approach...In the play’s second half...the action slows down to allow each character an aria of self-explanation. And it’s then you begin to sense that something’s off-kilter in this production. Could these people really be members of the same family, or even the same play?" Full Review
“Irons’ American accent is atrocious...The leading man’s shaky accent keeps pulling you out of the world of the play. It contributes to an overall tonal incoherence in this production, staged a bit too broadly...The ensemble members seem to be in different plays...Almost resembles a period sitcom, with members of a dysfunctional family sniping amusingly at each other...The one unambiguous triumph is Manville.” Full Review
"There are big-ticket plays that terrify their actors; famous stars who fluster their colleagues; massive sets that turn environments from living things into monuments. The Bristol Old Vic’s 'Long Day’s Journey Into Night' manages to have all three problems at once in the blustery, muddled production now at BAM, where the show’s three and half hours lumber very slowly by...Although Manville and Irons find wonderful moments, the play as a whole keeps staggering." Full Review
"Featuring underwhelming starring performances by Jeremy Irons and Lesley Manville...The show is startlingly lifeless, the majority of its potential tragic power sacrificed to mannered, unvaried performances that seldom make the dive into anything resembling emotional truth...It’s all breathtakingly pretty — and hugely distracting. Rather than a space in which an emotionally dropped-in story can play out, the set feels like an excited intellectual exercise." Full Review
for a previous production "Eyre’s revival...is shatteringly good. After three-and-half-hours...you emerge drained but in that state of elation to which only true tragedy, confronted searchingly and honesty, can bring you...Eyre conducts the piece with a masterly touch, its repetitions...coming across like the emotionally incremental recapitulations in a great piece of music...The production is wonderfully alert to the way that the characters swing on an axis between love and hate...An unmissable masterpiece." Full Review
for a previous production "I was in tears at the end of this astonishing production...That's partly because it is such a great play...Eyre has taken a classic, written in 1941, and treated it as a new play, stripping away all previous conceptions. Thanks to a quartet of magnificent performances led by Manville and Irons, it finds a freshness and directness that touches to the heart...Eyre makes the dialogue whip along. It has the thrust and speed of real family life. But he gives weight to words and meanings." Full Review
for a previous production "Though it is inexpressibly sad, Richard Eyre’s beautifully judged production also shows us how much love courses through this unsparing portrait of damaged, damaging people...At its heart is Mary...Manville is superb in the role, bringing exquisite detail and depth...Guilt, recrimination, remorse and self-defence roll around the stage, but as night wears on, flashes of truth and tender understanding pierce the gloom." Full Review
for a previous production "At three-and-a-half hours, it is a daunting prospect but Richard Eyre’s production ensures maximum engagement...Manville is magnificent, wandering around like a ghost or the Woman In White as she shuttles between unnatural sprightliness and despair at the downward spiral of her life...The family bonds of suffering, contempt and love are stretched, and strained almost to breaking point. Almost but not quite. If nothing else their codependency is unbreakable. A long night but a great one." Full Review
for a previous production "The genius of the play, brought out with luminous wit and warmth in Richard Eyre’s production, is how so much fury is wrapped in so much fondness...Eyre ensures that this quartet have the mutual ease as well as the mutual enmity of a real family. They loathe each other, they love each other, then it’s dinnertime. It’s a long night, but an electrifying one." Full Review
for a previous production "A rhythm that allows us to feel that we are living, like the Tyrone family, through a day and a night of alternating hope and despair. What never ceases to astonish is the dizzying emotional contradiction of O’Neill’s characters...They bounce around like pinballs between reality and illusion...A play that if well done, as it is here, leaves you emotionally pulverised by the feeling that O’Neill, in providing an unsparing portrait of his family, is seeking their posthumous forgiveness." Full Review
for a previous production "Eyre’s deluxe revival of O’Neill’s immense, autobiographically rooted drama...Irons gives the impression of a forlorn, sniping, refined man about the house rather than a prowling, growling survivor of too many nights on the road...The most palpably searing emotional intensity is supplied by Lesley Manville...One of the 20th century’s defining dramas of American dreams and disappointments...O’Neill forges a deeper, tragic sense of handed-on misery, an inescapable inheritance." Full Review
See it if This play is an extraordinary intense experience delivered by four great actors who are able to portray the complex, three dimensional
Don't see it if you are not a fan of Eugene O'nell
Also characters to perfection.
See it if You want to be completely absorbed into a tragic family drama by a set of truly outstanding actors. Breathtaking
Don't see it if You saw some legendary production of LDJiN that can never be replicated. Or you can’t physically sit 3.5 hours. Although BAM seats are comfy
See it if you enjoy seriously great acting that appears totally natural, gets you interested in the dialogue, and makes time fly. Amazing.
Don't see it if you can't concentrate on anything that is longer than a twitter text...
See it if You've never seen this play. An absolute masterpiece of American theater very well-executed by this cast (especially Manville [& Irons])
Don't see it if Emotionally devastating family dramas aren't your jam.
See it if One of the great plays of American theater performed by a company of exemplary British actors. Not to be missed.
Don't see it if You want happy, comedy, music , or dance. ..and can't concentrate for over 3 hours.
See it if Class A actors including Irons and Manville. Great theater/venue. Interesting and ambitious, although potentially distracting, set design.
Don't see it if No reason not to, unless not an O'Neill fan. If Lange and Byrne production was enough.
See it if you want to see an exceptionally well done production (and see how the opioid epidemic hasn't changed much!).
Don't see it if you are a set purist - it isn't period accurate and if you are incapable of sitting fro long periods of time...
See it if You want to see this classic play, performed amazingly by a strong troupe of actors & like plays, that don’t seem staged but really real.
Don't see it if You want to see something happy or if conversations on addiction or a child’s death are triggers for you.
See it if you appreciate O'neill's morbid take on love, life, family, dreams, despair and disillusionment, delivered on stage by an outstanding cast.
Don't see it if you need faster pacing, have a hard time understanding Jeremy Iron's mumbling of lines, or just not ready to take a hard punch to the gut.
See it if you can handle both a brilliant performance and a couple of indulgent performances. The play shines through, even with spotty acting.
Don't see it if you demand a flawless production. I'm not sure it's possible to do this play. I saw Olivier and he missed it. But damn what a play!
See it if you're an O'Neill fan, enjoy great acting, for a clear understanding of a classic play, feel the New England setting & the caustic wit
Don't see it if 3 hrs, 20 mins seems too long for you, O'Neill bores you, hopelessness upsets you, don't like a lot of repetition for character development
See it if You want to see a solid production of this classical play with excellent actors, dynamic staging and strange scenic design.
Don't see it if You are not ready to listen to four members of Tyrone family torturing each other morally for more than 3 hours.
See it if You want to have a chance to enjoy Jeremy Irons & Leslie Manville together. Theater as it ought to be and once was. A great venue at BAM.
Don't see it if Cannot sit for 3 1/2 hours.
See it if A great staging with superb acting of Eugene O’Neill’s devastating portrait of an addicted mother and her alcoholic husband and sons.
Don't see it if Three hour show about a family crashing on the shoals (hear the waves approaching their beach house): you know how this ends..
Get alerts about your favorite artists and theater companies