The Iceman Cometh (Broadway) NYC Reviews and Tickets
Show-Score Member Reviews (253)
See it if you enjoy O'Neill's spiraling, depressive world-view executed with great finesse.
Don't see it if you cannot sit through a heavy, deeply dramatic, four hour non-musical.
See it if Denzel and a cast of consummate actors. O'Neill pathos in black and white.
Don't see it if Long, and sometime difficult to understand spoken words.
See it if you want to see a uniformly outstanding cast breath vibrant life into an American classic
Don't see it if you can't sit still for four hours. This sucker is loooooooooong.
See it if You love O’Neill, a tight ensemble working well together, Denzel, Colm Meaney, David Morse.
Don't see it if Wolfe finds more humor in the play than past productions, so if you need a traditional take...this is probably not your cup of tea.
See it if You want to see an all-star cast blend seamlesslessly into an ensemble. This is a long show, that demands attention, but is worth it. Great.
Don't see it if You’re looking for a short show, a fun show, or something light and breezy. This show shows it’s age, but does not feel dated. Spectacular.
See it if you want to see excellent acting in an American classic play.
Don't see it if you don't like long plays. This one is just about four hours long. Read more
See it if You are a fan of Eugene O’Neill and/or appreciate great acting. The cast, led by Denzel Washington, was outstanding.
Don't see it if You don’t enjoy plays about troubled drunks.
See it if You want to see this classic brought to life with beautiful staging and A+ acting. Denzel was phenomenal along with the rest of the cast.
Don't see it if You cannot commit to 4 hours of a play with 3 intermissions. Act 1 is very slow moving but crucial to understand these characters.
Critic Reviews (43)
"A desultory revival that occasionally sparks into life but that ultimately sinks under the weight of its own stasis. Not even the presence of a generally first-rate cast headed up by superstar Denzel Washington can do much to break things out of a repetitive loop...Director George C. Wolfe has helped each of the actors 'find' his or her character to the extent that we certainly can tell them apart. Yet none is developed beyond the bit of shtick that makes them recognizable."
Read more
"Give Washington kudos for his extraordinary performance, his dedication, and the opportunity he presents to his marvelous castmates...What lifts this production, though, is the handling of the other 14 characters...Wolfe sees to it that all remain intensely present...'The Iceman Cometh' has always been a difficult evening of theater. Wolfe and Washington and a marvelous cast demonstrate that the play is indeed a monumental piece of theater."
Read more
"More stylized than dramatically stirring in Wolfe’s arty staging, the latest Broadway production of this great and gloomy work is noteworthy for the mottled gallery of misfits and riff-raff created by actors in supporting roles rather than its leading performance by Denzel Washington...It is a challenging work to produce effectively. The rendition of the drama currently at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre does not achieve the requisite life and death significance of O’Neill’s somber vision."
Read more
"I was not bored for a second...This version moves...There’s a sure foot on the accelerator...Done right, 'Iceman Cometh' is cumulatively invigorating, if not outright electrifying. Wolfe and his cherry-picked cast, happily, bring the electricity. This is one of the finest ensembles I’ve seen in a long time maybe ever...Washington rattles off O’Neill’s fulsome lines with a sassy panache and brio, while giving full scope to Hickey’s underlying self-hatred and disgust."
Read more
"Shatteringly good Broadway revival...A great production of Eugene O’Neill’s monumental drama requires a towering performance in the crucial role of Hickey, and Washington memorably delivers one...Happily, the cast assembled by the veteran director George C. Wolfe is almost without a weak link...This is the first 'Iceman' I’ve seen in which the surface Hickey...truly seems to have moved beyond the trap of his life into another darker trap of madness."
Read more
"Denzel Washington, the raison d'être of this production (coming way too soon after several recent stagings), gives a boisterous, almost pleasant performance as Theodore Hickman, aka Hickey, who is the 'Godot' of 'Iceman,' in whom the godforsaken characters put too much faith, a faith that, by the end of the play, is shown to be clearly misplaced. There is absolutely no foreboding in his interpretation. He takes the glad-handing aspect of Hickey too literally..."
Read more
"With Washington at its center, this production qualifies as a star revival. But the star is supported by 18 unusually able actors; and the proceedings are directed by George C. Wolfe with compassionate attention to details of characterization. It's a high velocity 'Iceman'...Washington's Hickey doesn't fit snugly in the otherwise balanced ensemble...Washington's performance is nonetheless engrossing and believable on its own, separate terms."
Read more
"Blessed with a sprawling cast of stage veterans, director George C. Wolfe constructs fantastic tableaus...Blessed with a sprawling cast of stage veterans, director George C. Wolfe constructs fantastic tableaus...But in presenting an African-American Hickey, O’Neill’s commentary about race gets scrambled...It’s an awkward problem that casts a shadow of confusion over this otherwise self-assured production."
Read more