New York | 1h 30m | Already closed


From 18 critic and 263 member reviews
Members say: Thought-provoking, Relevant, Great acting, Absorbing, Edgy

About the show

Midnight Theatricals presents the world premiere of this drama that explores the complexities of polyamory. More…

Josh and Alex, a married couple in an open relationship, invite Darius to share their bed one night. When a new intimate connection begins to form, all three men must come to terms with their individual definitions of love, loyalty, and trust as futures are questioned, relationships are shaken, and commitments are challenged.


"Insightful, highly theatrical and fiercely acted...Mr. Gelman’s scenario and plot developments are well observed and true to life in their predictability. Gelman’s dialogue is realistic and perfectly crafted with flavorful simplicity...Despite the inevitability of its finale, 'Afterglow' is quite engrossing. Its dazzling production elements magnify its achievements...The actors all give bold, brave and intense performances that transcend stereotypes." Full Review

Off Off Online

"What makes 'Afterglow' fresh and riveting is the hand of the director, Gelman himself, and the performances his actors deliver...Gelman has cast well. The players fit the bill physically: his three leads appear to be in a race to stamp out body fat. But it’s just as important that they make the decency and good intentions of their characters apparent...Gelman is nuanced as both a director and a writer...An impressive calling card from a gifted new playwright and director." Full Review

The Modernist Beat

“An innovative work that represents a new chapter in the American LGBTQ theatrical tradition...By placing the erotic moment at the beginning of the play, Gelman acknowledges the history of his sub-genre and moves beyond...Ultimately, the play, while having special appeal and resonance to a gay audience, speaks to all...All three members of the cast portray their flawed characters simply and honestly.” Full Review

Theater Pizzazz

“A substantial drama with believable characters whose emotions are real and tug at the heart...Gelman skillfully creates three real people whose strengths and weaknesses make it difficult to judge their actions…Gelman leaves a great deal up in the air, just as such a situation would end in real life…Gelman directed his play to give each character his full worth. All the emotional ups and downs are clearly communicated. The play moves along with increasing speed to its finale.” Full Review


"An insightful new play...While the characters approach these questions from very different angles, it’s easy to identify with each one. All three actors embody recognizable perspectives...Through candid emotional dialogue, Gelman demonstrates a nuanced understanding of the stakes in gay dating and relationships...It’s vivid and honest depictions like these that foster a greater understanding of the way we live now." Full Review

Reviews Off Broadway

“‘Afterglow’ is the bittersweet story of a polyamorous relationship that ultimately brings emotional problems to the couple at the core. Beautifully acted by Brandon Haagenson, Robbie Simpson and Patrick Reilly, the play may be too slow or have too much nudity for some audiences—but it is well worth it. The cast brings honesty to the proceedings. You can fully feel the growing bonds between all three of these men, which gives audiences a real stake in the outcome.” Full Review

Plays to See

"The play looks honestly at gay intimacy, and asks if a committed marriage truly be open...Patrick Reilly as Darius is flawless, his character articulating the complexities of gay culture without descending into caricature. Robbie Simpson, as the more mature partner in the marriage, is a standout...I took off a star for the play’s last sequences, which drew out uncomfortably with long pauses of moody silence and brings the play’s brilliant momentum to a grinding halt." Full Review

Front Mezz Junkies

"Although their are numerous scenarios that feel unnecessary and hard to believe, Gelman with his cast of three very beautiful and talented men know how to keep our attention...They play out their overly long and slightly melodramatic tale that delivers few surprises in story line and character development...The three actors are impressive though, turning the material into something that feels honest and heartfelt, even as it drags out the romanticism of the doomed pair." Full Review

Beauty News NYC

“Gelman brings to the stage the very personal story of a threesome with heart, grit and a non-gratuitous exploration of the complex theme…Kudos to the cast…While the first act runs over an hour and is intriguingly constructed with solid writing, the second act fumbles a bit with too many repetitive topics and dramatics bordering on melodramas seen on Netflix…However, the actors, staging and even the lighting design save the production…A probing story for all sexes.” Full Review


"The playwright, who also directs, has painted no obvious villains here, just, perhaps, a portrait of immaturity and poor judgment. If we feel for anyone, it is the unborn baby...The production benefits from Ann Beyersdorfer's cleverly constructed set...The play does not necessarily add to our growing understanding about gay relationships, except to point out how they are not necessarily any different from heterosexual ones." Full Review

The Gay & Lesbian Review

"The superficial pleasures of watching randy eye candy evolved into a sobering exploration of the pitted emotional terrain of a gay marriage...The acting is at a high level, especially notable given that the three characters are not always fully fleshed out...However, unexamined elements of real life, as opposed to theatrical life, risk leaving the play less than the sum of its engaging parts...A worthy first effort that gives three actors the chance to display their chops." Full Review

Queer Voices

“Though ‘Afterglow’ is definitively part of this new gay canon and does in fact explore modern gay issues, it is certainly the least successful, significant, and wide-reaching of the bunch. Overall the show is a bit too melodramtic, oversimplified, and erotic to make any claims at having serious commentary on queerness…‘Afterglow’ is not necessarily a bad show, but it’s biggest faults are its lack of nuance and its lack of impact.” Full Review

Gay City News

“This is Gelman’s first effort as a playwright and it shows. Although the plot is compelling, the occasionally insightful dialogue can turn wooden or preachy…'Afterglow' flirts with melodrama throughout...The actors do a solid job tackling demanding roles...Gelman’s dynamic staging helps mask the script’s limitations…Flaws aside, if the goal was to shine a brief light on the potential joys and pitfalls of queer polyamory, the overly ambitious ‘Afterglow’ succeeds as it titillates.” Full Review

Boy Culture

"What it offers, on the down side, is some vapid talk from adult gay men who at times express themselves like teenage girls, and, on the up side, eventual emotional payoff when everyone stops pretending and says exactly how they feel...The acting is uniformly fine here, with each performer pouring heart and soul into lines that don't always deserve it...Definitely provoked thought on the topics of sex, relationships and family as seen through a contemporary gay lens." Full Review

The New York Times

"The frequent nudity is so willfully carefree that it ends up looking forced...Gay domesticity is turning out to be tough to dramatize, as evidenced by such flawed shows as...‘Dada Woof Papa Hot’ and ‘Steve'...The soap-operatic 'Afterglow' doesn’t even reach their level...It has funny moments, albeit of the inadvertent kind...The best joke of all, intended or not, may be the sly jab at the cult of youth among some gay men: Josh is having a midlife crisis — at the ripe age of 30." Full Review

Lighting & Sound America

"The playwright, S. Asher Gelman, lets everyone speak his piece, exhaustively, with no cliché left unturned...If 'Afterglow' had been written with a modicum of wit, it might have made for a passable entertainment, but there isn't a single really amusing line over the course of two hours...What keeps 'Afterglow' passably watchable is the three talented young actors who -- very occasionally -- manage to endow these paper figures with something that passes for flesh and blood." Full Review


"Initially stimulating but ultimately flaccid...The story becomes as predictable as a headache after a bender...Haagenson, Reilly, and Simpson do their best to rise above the limitations of the script, but they can't overcome the fact that none of these characters is particularly interesting...The most disappointing thing is that it seems to promise and then fails to deliver a thoughtful discussion of polyamory...In the end, the play leaves us not so much with an afterglow as an anticlimax." Full Review

Theatre is Easy

"Certainly Gelman has staged the play well...And the design is first-rate...Unfortunately, we end up with three people who are all kind of the same...Certainly the actors do what they can to add dimension...If at times the actors veer too quickly into heightened emotion, this is largely the result of Gelman’s script...The insularity and entitlement of all this is not only astonishingly tone-deaf, given contemporary conversations about privilege, but also makes for a weaker play." Full Review

Absorbing, Great acting, Masterful

See it if want to see a "gay" story that is well-acted and real. Stirs up so many emotions, heart-breaking!

Don't see it if you don't expect the characters to effect you. These guys are each terrific!

Edgy, Intense, Must see, Profound, Absorbing

See it if you want to experience an absorbing production that brings to light the struggles of being in an open relationship.

Don't see it if LGBT stories are not your cup of tea.

Must see, Thought-provoking, Great acting, Masterful, Resonant

See it if IF you want to see the dynamics of what an open relationship for gay men can do to relationships, even if you think it can't happen to you.

Don't see it if Homophobic, don't enjoy deep stories about gay lives

Entertaining, Clever, Absorbing, Great writing, Great acting

See it if You would like to be captivated by something true.

Don't see it if You are not going to pay attention

Intelligent, Great writing, Thought-provoking, Must see, Great acting

See it if Searching for a show that will make you think & provoke conversation amongst your group be it part of the LGBTQ+ community or not.

Don't see it if adverse to gay themes or full nudity. Also, not for those under 15 years of age.

Clever, Edgy, Great staging, Raunchy

See it if You enjoy a new, interesting, unique style of staging. You are looking for a deep story of love and trust and betrayal.

Don't see it if You don't want nudity. You are looking for a large scale play. You don't care for a gay storyline.

Great writing, Intense, Romantic, Clever, Ambitious

See it if you are in a relationship that complicates things such as your ideals and perception.

Don't see it if you don’t like sad endings. 😥

Absorbing, Entertaining, Great staging, Refreshing, Relevant

See it if You want an interesting story and staging about an issue not often explored.

Don't see it if Nudity makes you uncomfortable.

Riveting, Thought-provoking, Intense, Intelligent, Absorbing

See it if you enjoy relationship stories that aren't wrapped up with a bow. you want to have paradigms challenged.

Don't see it if you are uncomfortable with nudity and adult themes

Absorbing, Great acting, Edgy, Intense, Thought-provoking

See it if You’re open to full nudity in a few scenes, and to the subject of Gay Polyamory with superb acting!!

Don't see it if You’re not open to the above

Absorbing, Raunchy, Sexy, Relevant, Great staging

See it if You like complicated romantic stories and discussion of issues applicable to both same-sex and hetero relationships. You like sexy staging.

Don't see it if You have a problem with same-sex relationships or threesomes. You don't like nudity. You don't like relationship dramas.

Enchanting, Great staging, Edgy, Absorbing, Thought-provoking

See it if You like plays that move quickly through a plot but raise more questions than they answer and leave the ending ambiguous.

Don't see it if You don’t like to see full-on nudity on stage that is not entirely necessary.

Erotic, Intelligent, Relevant, Thought-provoking, Absorbing

See it if You are looking for a challenging evening of theatre that explores both the physical as well as the emotional sides of a gay relationship.

Don't see it if You are uncomfortable with graphic gay male themes and full frontal nudity.

Also The show promotes itself as an erotic work with two of the three cast ... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Clever, Insightful

See it if Insight in to sex and relationships.

Don't see it if you don't want to explore the gay world of sex

Great acting, Interesting

See it if You want to see some great acting from a most of the cast and clever staging that supports a gripping story.

Don't see it if You're bothered by uneven acting from one cast member and a script that still has occasional kinks left to be ironed out.

Thought-provoking, Relevant, Resonant

See it if you're interested in seeing a realistic well-enough written and staged play about an open relationship

Don't see it if nudity is a hangup for you

Absorbing, Intense, Raunchy, Riveting, Thought-provoking

See it if you enjoy gay theatre or theatre with intense, human themes. Good if you want something engaging that will leave you thinking and talking.

Don't see it if you are uncomfortable with nudity on stage. It is provocative, yet emotionally powerful.

Great acting, Intelligent, Masterful, Relevant, Must see

See it if You want to experience An intimate type of show with great acting and story

Don't see it if You don't like men to men sexual act in a show

Refreshing, Timely, Relatable, Intimate, Cliché

See it if you’re a gay man who wants to see an aspect of gay relationships that isn’t discussed with much honestly played out onstage.

Don't see it if you have zero interest or experience in polyamory.

Absorbing, Great acting, Great staging, Great writing, Resonant

See it if you would enjoy a provocative emotional rollercoaster ride through a love triangle.

Don't see it if you are not open to full frontal male nudity and strong sexual themes.

Also This is an excellent play that might appeal to a wider audience withou... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Great acting, Intense, Creative staging, Intelligent

See it if you want to be absorbed in a heart-wrenching, well-acted play about love triangles in an open relationship. The raw emotion is riveting.

Don't see it if you can't deal with full male nudity, occasional vulgar language, homosexuality, and raw emotion.

Also One of my barometers for a good play is that I feel intensely for the ... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Edgy, Great staging, Intelligent

See it if You like shows about love triangles

Don't see it if You dislike portrayal of gay relationships, male nudity, foul language, strobe lights and non judgemental treatment of drug use and drinkin

Absorbing, Edgy, Great staging, Romantic

See it if You want to see a gorgeously staged take on the complications of modern love.

Don't see it if You are uncomfortable with full nudity in an intimate setting.

Great acting, Absorbing, Relevant, Great writing

See it if You want to see a play that is very relateble. Great acting - really great. You want to see true/raw emotion on the stage

Don't see it if You might be offended by full male nudity and simulated sex.

Absorbing, Profound, Refreshing, Raunchy, Intense

See it if you like love triangles and want your perceptions to be challenged.

Don't see it if you can't stand nudity or unconventional relationships.

Cast & Creatives (13)