New York | 1h 55m | Already closed

Alice in Black and White

From 12 critic and 6 member reviews
Members say: Absorbing, Enchanting, Intelligent, Entertaining, Clever

About the show

Looking for Lilith Theatre Company presents Robin Rice's period-hopping bio-play about Alice Austen, a groundbreaking female street photographer of Victorian-era NYC. More…

'Alice in Black and White' traces Austen's love affair with photography and with her partner, Gertrude Tate, at the turn of the 20th century, to her fall into poverty and obscurity by the 1950s. Originally produced in Louisville, KY, the production comes to Austen's native New York City in honor of the 150th anniversary of her birth. 


"Beautifully written, splendidly directed, and featuring an excellent cast, this is one to see…Jennifer Thalman Kepler is superb as Alice Austen…’Alice in Black and White’ is an extraordinary testimony to Alice Austen's work, her lifestyle and her legacy. The intimate setting of 59E59 Theaters is ideal for the show's presentation. This is a very important, brilliantly conceived show that shares the ideals of one woman, ideals that have timeless significance." Full Review

NY Theatre Guide

"There were some truly wonderful scenes in this piece that highlighted the naïve innocence of the 19th century...Director Kathi E.B. Ellis has accomplished something truly exciting as she has cobbled together all of the sentiments of this piece into a powerfully directed evening of theatre...'Alice in Black and White' will make you laugh, wonder, and want to know more about the elusive and powerful Alice Austen." Full Review


"'Alice In Black and White' is an intimate portrayal of Alice Austen—an unconventional, daring, slice-of-life photographer who focused on 'Street Types of New York' for over 40 years. Robin Rice’s play is structurally uneven and confusing which detracts from a meaningful perspective of Austen’s complicated life choices and what sacrifices she made becoming America’s first female photo-journalist." Full Review

Stage Buddy

“Alice Austen was a woman ahead of her time. Born during an era and in a society when there were not many options for women besides becoming a wife and mother, Alice was an unmarried, childless lesbian who lived with her girlfriend Gertrude Tate...Lovingly captured in ‘Alice in Black and White' by playwright Robin Rice, director Kathi E.B. Ellis and members of the Looking for Lilith Theatre Company, Alice was a true pioneer; a feminist decades before anybody started using that term.” Full Review

Woman Around Town

"Rice reveals Austen’s history one piece at a time, separating the years with another story...This secondary storyline is an odd fit for the play...'Alice in Black and White' works well as commentary on the evolution of women’s rights in America, from Victorian times through the 1950s. It also makes a moving point about the women of Austen’s generation, who were brought up being told they were worth only what their wombs could produce." Full Review

The New York Times

"The appealingly modest 'Alice in Black and White' straightforwardly tracks the life of this double pioneer...The show is at its best when it follows Austen at work and in love, especially since Kepler and Ellis have an affectionate rapport. Rice and the director lose their grounding when they turn to Jensen’s efforts to track down Austen’s photos, and the attempts at humor there are strained. You can only impatiently wait for Austen to come back in focus." Full Review

Theater Pizzazz

“Although awkward and obvious in moments, Rice’s play is an important tribute to a great artist. If ‘Alice’ inspires visits to the Alice Austen House in Staten Island it will have served an important benefit...Directed by Kathi E.B. Ellis, some of the acting, particularly at the beginning of the play, might have been more earthbound and realistic, but Ellis wisely picked up the tempo and found breathless hope in the face of life’s tragic circumstances.” Full Review

Plays to See

“In this production smartly directed by Kathi E. B. Ellis, Alice’s life from age 11 to 84 is compacted effectively into just under two hours...At heart this play is a historical recap of Alice’s life. Frequently, family members and those who present social strictures and expectations are sketchy characterizations whom Alice easily defeats with her wit and intelligence. They are never serious obstacles...We are grateful to Ms. Rice and Ms. Ellis for presenting this life to us.” Full Review


“It all comes off more like an outline for would probably work better as a filmed documentary than this play. Unfortunately, the interspersed scenes that try to add a bit of suspense...are more intrusive than smoothly or interestingly integrated...In fairness to director Kathi E. B. Ellis, it's challenging to move actors and props on and off this tiny stage...While ‘Alice’ is a flawed play, it does introduce us to a little-known game changer.” Full Review

Theatre's Leiter Side

"While Rice’s play fails to bring her subject to life, the same is true of the production, which uses seven actors to play 16 characters, although no one has the requisite versatility to play multiple roles. There are several moments when it’s anyone’s guess as to who some people are. The greatest challenge is faced by Kepler, who has to age incrementally throughout and who can do little more than depend on embarrassingly hoary stage clichés in doing so." Full Review


for a previous production "Kepler plays the free-spirited Alice Austen. With joy and wonder, she portrays a woman who was ahead of her time, independent and strong…Paired against Ted Lesley as her loving Transcendentalist grandfather, these actors display an affectionate chemistry…Truly, I could not look away the entire show. Whether it was Austen’s pictures, the stripped-down staging or Kepler as an artist ahead of her time, 'Alice in Black and White' has everything you need for a great night of theatre." Full Review

Theatre Louisville

for a previous production "Sentimental without being mushy, lovely without being contrived, funny at times, heartbreaking at others...The first act felt more connected to a forward-moving story with drive…The second act focuses mostly on Alice’s decline and it’s a tough journey to take...The final scene of the play is quite breathtaking and I found myself choking back tears as past and future converged in the present…The ensemble of actors did an expert job with the material and I enjoyed them all immensely." Full Review

Exquisite, Funny, Great acting

See it if You love classics. Remodeled

Don't see it if No reason

Absorbing, Enchanting, Great acting, Great writing, Intelligent

See it if you love NY history, photography, love stories, theatrical staging and intelligent story-telling.

Don't see it if you want fluff.

Enchanting, Educational, Delightful, Intelligent, Relevant

See it if You want to feel connected to a wonderful artist you probably never heard of. She will reach out of the past and touch you.

Don't see it if You are not interested in history. You want a more intense, fast paced experience.

Absorbing, Clever, Great singing, Edgy, Entertaining

See it if you enjoy story telling with your music. Jomama is a wonderful raconteur as well as a mesmerizing chanteuse. And can quickly change outfits.

Don't see it if you don't like cabaret or story telling with your music.

Absorbing, Entertaining, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Relevant

See it if you are interested in historical plays about mostly unknown people; this play will entice you to find out more about Alice and her work.

Don't see it if you dislike historical plays; you dislike slightly less than top professional productions with minimal scenery, good but not great acting.

Absorbing, Clever, Delightful, Enchanting, Entertaining

See it if See it if you can

Don't see it if You should see it