Antlia Pneumatica

"'Antlia' has been directed with a mix of bright whimsy and dark portentousness by Ken Rus Schmoll and features a likable cast. It is definitely a downer to report that the play’s ghost story feels as leaden and unsurprising as its collective portrait of midlife doubts in the face of mortality...Washburn seems to have gotten lost between the traditional and experimental sides of her craft, never finding a comfortable voice that accommodates both." Full Review

"Anne Washburn writes weird plays, and 'Antlia Pneumatica' is no exception...Childhood friends who meet over a funeral feast waste considerable stage time catching up on other old friends we never meet...It sounds like an audience challenge, trying to identify the ghosts among the dreamers. But with the exception of Nina, the characters are so superficially drawn, there’s not enough substance to them to distinguish the living from the dead." Full Review

"A supernatural twist is introduced that upends our perceptions of everything that's come before. The revelation is jarring, not so much for its spookiness but rather for the perfunctory manner of the storytelling. The proceedings are tonally inconsistent and the plotting full of holes only adds to the overall frustration. That's a shame, because the play is enjoyable for long stretches, thanks to its witty dialogue and well-drawn characterizations. The actors deliver fine performances." Full Review

"Washburn does a fine job posing intriguing questions about the nature of relationships. But the play feels more like a series of intellectual musings than a fully immersive world...We need more than just an eloquent metaphor to keep us attached to this story. We never learn much about any of these people — who they are now or who they used to be. And the more they seem to disconnect from one another, the more we disconnect from them." Full Review

"Washburn is not your ordinary playwright. The pleasures of her work are fugitive, sidelong and slippery...The dialogue is often glib, funny and heartfelt, making 'Antlia' a sheer joy as a listening device...Washburn’s witty, surprising language makes you laugh in self-recognition...I think everyone should see Anne Washburn’s plays, but those who demand familiar forms and takeaway messages be warned: all that’s needed here are your ears." Full Review

"While 'Antlia' works well as a low-key naturalistic play and fairly successfully as a more stylized one, the production doesn’t yet unite the two modes in ways that seem purposeful. Some of the disappointment is in the finish, where Washburn sets up a terrific conflict where diverging realities suddenly collide. But just when the nightscape threatens to become wonderfully mystifying, the play ends." Full Review

"Characters recall events that they then dismiss as dreams. But the disorientation is not limited to the characters. Most scenes in the play occur on a stage that is lit too darkly to see clearly. In theory, this double disorientation of both characters and audience should be thought-provoking, the atmosphere intriguing. In practice, it comes off as vague...Washburn’s wit and ear for dialogue make attendance worthwhile even when she’s leaving you in the dark." Full Review

"In its sly, sideways manner, it has something - a haunting sense of the passage of time, a feeling of wonderment at the mysteries of the universe…Nothing really happens and yet, as a meditation on middle age, mortality, the passing and rekindling of desire, and the sheer mystery of existence, 'Antlia Pneumatica' casts a certain spell that I found beguiling. It helps that Schmoll has assembled a company notably skilled at expressing the unsaid. Annie Parisse is first-rate as Nina." Full Review

"It’s rather frustrating to know Washburn could meet the demands of a more traditional play but wouldn’t commit. 'Antlia Pneumatica' is certainly well acted, well directed and given a handsome production. For a seemingly conventional play, it’s also rather bold and interesting in its sound design...Yet even here 'Antlia Pneumatica' falls a little short...ultimately not adding up to much. Just like, I fear, the show itself." Full Review

"Washburn plays with our perceptions of reality as her script slowly ambles, or, I should say, rambles, along, offering behavior that's sometimes conventionally realistic...and sometimes magically realistic. This being a play in which things are not always what they seem to be, the situation, for all its seeming ordinariness, makes it hard to become fully engaged with these shadowy characters...‘Antlia Pneumatica’ could stand to have some dramatic air pumped into it." Full Review

"Washburn crafts an evening that's at once quiet and disquieting, as beautiful for what it contains as unsettling for what it doesn't. But Washburn has trouble gauging when she goes too far. Eventually she hints at supernatural forces driving the action in ways that defuse the sparks she ignites earlier on...The pacing is Ice Age glacial...The actors, they're all decent, if overblown in one way or another...Memorable though this play may be, it has too much to hang on to." Full Review

"Director Ken Rus Schmoll’s staging is as static as it is pretentious…Ms. Washburn has taken a perfectly good idea for a play and loaded on so much artifice that it collapses under its own weight…The performances offer a glimmer of hope, but there will be no happy ending, just one final return of the poetry zombies, singing a dirge, turning at odd angles from each other for no apparent reason." Full Review

"The plot you figure out almost instantaneously. The problem here is once you do, you don’t care...We get banal talk about the stars and our existence...Director Ken Rus Schmoll does not help make this piece any more palatable. The good news here is the actors all radiate warmth and a realness that makes this seem less like acting and more like peering through a slice of time." Full Review

"A work about friendship and the impersistence of memory that starts out plump with promise but steadily deflates...Washburn has perfect pitch here when it comes to dialogue...Under Ken Rus Schmoll’s direction, the cast clicks. But for all of the convincing conversation, plus impromptu singing, these characters have as much shape and interest as empty balloons. The dramatic enterprise falls flat." Full Review

"What we learn about the characters is too fragmentary to make us really care...Except for these occasionally engaging conversations, most of the table talk meanders along and leaves us wishing director Ken Rus Schmoll had trimmed it along with that interesting but overlong star-gazing scene in the dark. The actors' performances overall are fine. Too bad they're playing six characters in search of a play by Anne Washburn at her best." Full Review

"Rachel Hauck’s scenic design is the most outstanding feature of the interminable 'Antlia Pneumatica'...This play’s author Anne Washburn takes a proven dramatically fertile situation and renders it with pretentiousness and vagueness...Creating a work of basic resonance appears to be an anathema to her. The cast are all capable actors. However, with this material their performances uniformly consist of irritating tics and mannerisms." Full Review

"I did not have high hopes for Anne Washburn’s new play now at Playwrights Horizons. Alas, my low expectations were met...It has a major gimmick and a few minor ones, none of which worked for me...All this might have involved me more if the characters had been more interesting...Ken Rus Schmoll directs with a sure hand. Washburn is greatly admired by many in the theatrical community. I wish I could see what they see." Full Review

"Beware of plays with coy, obscure titles that are clumsily explained shortly before the final curtain...Washburn captures the awkward humor of people trying to play catch up with their collective past. She and her director, Ken Rus Schmoll, are effective when scenes feature the witty banter between Nina and the other female characters...A not insubstantial amount of 'Artlia' unfolds like a radio play with voices amplified and/or taped as the audience sits looking at a bare stage." Full Review

"Anne Washburn provides a realistic, disarming ghost tale, invigorated with ruminations about time and space, in her new play. A quietly unsettling production directed by Ken Rus Schmoll...'Antlia Pneumatica' is a tender examination of everyday concerns...Scenes of shared memories between the friends are effectively given ritualistic, elegiac treatments...Schmoll has satisfactorily overlaid the realism and ordinariness with an atmosphere of mystery." Full Review

"Perhaps because I've been wrestling with some of the issues that Washburn is trying to work out, I was willing to forgive the play's considerable shortcomings...The acting is uneven...Parisse anchors this production with a smart yet heartfelt performance...But the real problem is that the play's aims are murky…In some ways, 'Antlia Pneumatica' seems like a draft instead of a finished play. As the characters nattered on about one thing after another, the audience got more and more restless." Full Review

"Without basic narrative grist, the dramatic machinery risks grinding to a halt. There lies the problem with Anne Washburn’s new play 'Antlia Pneumatica'...The six characters just don’t have much to say to each other. And what they do say sounds scripted...'Antlia' evolves into a kind of ghost story — albeit one that never surprises us. Under Ken Rus Schmoll’s direction, the pacing remains glacial throughout." Full Review

"The performances were good but not exceptional...Washburn’s naturalistic dialog with overly long, sometimes uncomfortable pauses, made for moments when we no longer cared what a character would say, just so long as they’d get it over with...It’s too full of hot air that fills the space of something we not only can’t see, but also don’t care about." Full Review

"Washburn plays with time and memory so that even while we're watching 'Antlia Pneumatica', we are questioning what's real. As a theatrical experience, that's interesting...'Antlia Pneumatica' is a somewhat challenging play. As I was watching it, I didn't feel fully engrossed, but the more I think about it, the more I appreciate the experience..It's almost like you have to let this feast for your senses happen to you, and then let your memory take over." Full Review

"A meandering play...The scenes come off as a torturous radio show and may spur you to cancel your subscription to NPR...The conversations seem deliberately mundane and opaque, and although director Ken Rus Schmoll imparts a certain sporadic charge to them, the effect is frequently to leave the listener at a loss...Washburn has a following and her work is produced regularly, but she also has skeptics. Obscure and unsatisfying, 'Antlia Pneumatica' will give the latter plenty of reason to carp." Full Review

"Not a great deal happens as folks stand around chatting for an hour and 45 minutes...Director Ken Rus Schmoll manages to create an uncertain atmosphere that matches the questions we have about these folks...Not enough invested in the characters. It takes us a while to figure out who they are and what their relationships to each other are...'Antlia Pneumatica' makes us feel more like we showed up at the wrong house by mistake." Full Review