Already closed | Midtown E

Company (St. Bart's Players)

From 33 member  reviews
Members say: Disappointing, Entertaining, Slow, Ambitious, Great writing

About the show

St. Bart's Players presents Stephen Sondheim's Tony-winning musical about a habitually single man contemplating the state of his life on the evening of 35th birthday. More…

Through a series of memories and daydreams, Robert's quirky married and engaged friends share the pros and cons of settling down. The single Robert is forced to look at his own life and question what "being alive" really means.

Member Reviews (33)


Disappointing, Entertaining, Slow, Ambitious, Great writing
Avg Score

Disappointing, Interesting staging, Quirky, Slow, Ambitious

See it if You want to support community theater or know someone in the cast. Or really love the play.

Don't see it if You want to be able to HEAR anything, the acoustics were terrible. The play was slow and at times stilted.

Low energy & pace, Community theatre, Inaudible at times, Some excellent voices, Seems actors costumed themselves

See it if you want a community theatre level [talent, design, intention] of a Sondheim classic, sound & lyrics elude the proceedings at times

Don't see it if you need your Sondheim well produced, cast & directed, or if you don't like Sondheim or musicals

Also The barn of St Barts makes the production & direction of sound & thrus... Read more Read less

Community theater, mixed results

See it if you care to support a dedicated community theater troupe. Spotty performances, some quite good. At times, hard to hear in such a large space

Don't see it if you want a polished production of a Sondheim classic.

Nostalgic, Cliched, Dated, Great singing, Disappointing

See it if you appreciate legendary Sondheim scores, including numbers popular today, or are nostalgic about your middle age single life in NYC

Don't see it if you dislike long musicals with minimal sets or stereotyping an attractive single white and white collar NYC male unable to commit to a woman

Enjoyable, fun, great music

See it if you want to see a production of a great musical given it's all by a decent cast who work hard to perform with limited resources.

Don't see it if you are looking for a Broadway style production performed by semi professionals who do a decent job in a difficult environment.

Entertaining, Great score, Slow, Ambitious, Great staging

See it if you've never seen a live version and/or enjoy community theatre, offbeat theatre locales or have never been inside St Bart's Church.

Don't see it if you're expecting a full-blown production, have trouble hearing or don't like echoing church acoustics or concert vesrsions of shows

Also In all fairness, any review of a first preview or final dress is trick... Read more Read less

Uneven, Relevant, Great writing

See it if you are willing to give an off-off Broadway production a chance. The material is great but the execution is inconsistent.

Don't see it if you don't like Sondheim's work or want a Broadway caliber show. There are some standout performances in the cast.

Entertaining, Quirky, Fluffy, Ambitious

See it if you're open to well-intentioned community theater & talent mix of hits & misses— Bobby & Marta are hits, & are (like me) a Sondheim newbie.

Don't see it if need excellent acoustics (faulty mics made actors unintelligible at times) & visibility, or demand uniformly strong performances.

Delightful, Great singing, Great staging

See it if Nice stage and great setting in St. BART'S CHURCH a good orchestra in rear helped

Don't see it if Tired of a popular Sondheim classic.

Entertaining, Great writing, Great staging, Thought-provoking

See it if If you want to see a very good yet amateur production of a classic show with an incredible Bobby and Joanne with great directing.

Don't see it if If you want to see a professional show. This is a strong community theatre production. Or if you want to understand what's being said.

Also This show takes place in a church sanctuary. So the echo is overwhelmi... Read more Read less

Slow, Dated, Excruciating

See it if For the music to this show is quite amazing. the book falls quite flat.

Don't see it if The sound bounces around so much I'm wa surprised the actors could keep on the beat. Very exhausting to listen to.. Talent had its moments

Disappointing, Fluffy, Great writing, Indulgent, Quirky

See it if you'll see anything Sondheim or if you want to see what community theater looks like in NYC.

Don't see it if you want good singers that can handle the lyrics (the one exception is the actress playing Amy) or want actors that are properly miked.

Also They perform in a large cavernous church, so not even sure if proper m... Read more Read less

Entertaining, Slow, Enjoyable

See it if You like Sondheim, you like Company, you don't mind seeing an amateur (but solid) production where the singing/acting is uneven at times

Don't see it if You are looking for a big musical with a gripping plot. You don't like uneven acting/singing. Bad acoustics are a deal breaker.

Entertaining, Clever, Ambitious, Dated

See it if You haven't seen Company performed live. If you like Sondheim. If you don't mind an ambitious show in a church.

Don't see it if You want a traditionally staged show. This, although well choreographed, has a community theatre feel, prob bc it's in a church and dated.

Ambitious, Slow, Disappointing, Refreshing

See it if Attended Dress Rehearsal. See it if you want to support a community theater ambitiously taking on this beautiful but difficult piece.

Don't see it if you expect professional actors or production values of Broadway -- But I only saw the open dress rehearsal, so it probably has improved.

Bad acoustics

See it if you're a big 'Company' fan and would like to support a community theater

Don't see it if you have a very low patience for bad acoustics. You can barely hear anything (and neither can the band).

Great writing, Quirky, Indulgent, Disappointing, Problematic

See it if you LOVE the show Company and appreciate cool old churches.

Don't see it if you are hard of hearing or can't sit through mediocre at best performers making their way through Sondheim. Bobby was the strongest.

Entertaining, Great writing, Bad acoustics

See it if you really really love the show

Don't see it if the church doesn't lend itself well to housing a musical; the acoustics are bad and even a few pews back it was impossible to hear it all.

Disappointing, Bad sound design, Community theatre, Mixed cast, Funny

See it if you like community theater; you're ok with a mixed-ability cast performing a score that occasionally seems beyond them (Amy was fabulous).

Don't see it if technical issues with sound design and near-constant balance problems between singers and orchestra would frustrate, you want a star cast.

Absorbing, Entertaining, Great singing, Great acting, Great staging

See it if You're a Sondheim fan interested in a great staging of a wonderful show

Don't see it if You're hoping for elaborate sets/staging (not that this show ever really features that... )

Absorbing, Funny, Refreshing, Alright but not great, Amateurish

See it if You love Sondheim and want to see one of his best works.

Don't see it if You don't like fractured, concept musicals that explore the intricacies of relationships

Great writing, Great staging, Slow, Relevant, Ambitious

See it if You like classic Sondheim musicals.

Don't see it if You are looking for a high budget production.


See it if You want to support local theater and actors.

Don't see it if You're not familiar with the musical.

Disappointing, Cliched, Slow, Overrated

See it if you want to see a really amature production of this sow

Don't see it if you are expecting a really off Broadway production

Disappointing, Great score, Lighthearted, Resonant, Off

See it if This was a dress rehearsal, so not in final shape. Still, far from the best version of this classic.

Don't see it if You don't like Sondheim, or you don't know Sondheim or if you're looking for a linear story with big production values.

Also Tough call, because this is a favorite of mine, and it was a work in p... Read more Read less

“Company (St. Bart's Players)” hasn't been reviewed by any Critics (yet!)

Related content