New York | 1h 0m | Already closed


From 21 critic and 10 member reviews
Members say: Absorbing, Great acting, Thought-provoking, Great writing, Intelligent

About the show

Henry Naylor's play juxtaposes the parallel stories of two women born 175 years apart: a Victorian pioneer off to wed in the British colonies, and an Islamist British schoolgirl who joins the Jihad in Syria. More…

Part of the Brits Off Broadway fest and presented as a pair of intercut monologues, 'Echoes' showcases the stories of two different women. One is a student Jihadist from England. The other is a Victorian member of the Fishing Fleet, women who traveled to East Asia to wed the men setting up the Empire. Both are idealists: intelligent adventurers, with strong religious beliefs. And both travel to foreign lands with a mission to impose a system of government upon an unwilling people.


"See this emotive two-hander that will take your breath away. Wonderfully staged and superbly acted, it is a haunting, poignant show...Houlbrooke and Braganca are extraordinary in their roles...They master their characters with complete authenticity. You will be spellbound by their performances...Don't miss 'Echoes'. It is an important piece of theater, wonderfully crafted and brilliantly executed." Full Review

Stage Buddy

“The actresses are utterly riveting in their portrayals...Both Houlbrooke and Braganca have strong voices, like two different instruments alternating in a hauntingly similar melody...This is obviously no comedy, but Naylor has used his comic gifts to create two very funny and observant characters. There is a surprising amount of laughs in the play...It is presented in minimalist style...With writing so fine and acting so powerful, nothing else is needed.” Full Review


"Both actresses very skillfully perform as those central characters as well as their husbands and an assortment of people they encounter...This work is not groundbreaking but it does very effectively depict the two women and their plights with shrewdly imparted historical and cultural details...The direction by Emma Butler and Naylor crisply presents the action and emotions...It’s a grand and moving small-scale theatrical showcase for its duo of marvelous performers." Full Review

Talkin' Broadway

"The writing and the portrayals are so thoroughly compelling that we are pulled immediately into Tillie and Samira's worlds...Despite its brevity (under an hour), and using only the alternating stories offered up by two very talented performers, 'Echoes', co-directed by the playwright and Emma Butler, packs a wallop as it serves as a sad reminder that history repeats itself, with only subtle variations, generation after generation." Full Review


"The actresses carry the hour-long production, which is spare of sets and other dramatic spectacle…Nothing distracts from the measured and intense performances. We are captivated by the women’s stark journeys and empathize as we watch both women move toward the abyss…On a global level Naylor’s themes roundly resonate." Full Review

Front Row Center

"It’s a captivating compare-and-contrast of religious fervor...The downside to this call-and-response approach, though, is that while we certainly feel the shock and awe of the girls’ suffering, we might have found even greater compassion if they had presented their tales one at a time...Both actors turn in strong performances...Co-directors Naylor and Buttler make sure that their actors are static only when the words call for it, generating a vibrant pas de deux." Full Review

The Komisar Scoop

“A powerful and intense play...Houlbrooke and Braganca are excellent in displaying the young women’s growing awareness of what they have bought into, with their hope and calm turning into anger and rebellion. Under the cinematic direction of Naylor and Emma Buttler, they persuade the audience that the subjects and the actors of their monologues really exist, move, react.” Full Review

Theatre's Leiter Side

"Houlbrooke and Braganca give committed, intelligent performances, ably changing their voices and attitudes to characterize the various people they reference. I wish I could have been more enthusiastic about the play itself, but it’s only fair to note that, as we left the theatre, my companion disagreed with me about it, and was echoed by another theatregoer who’d heard us talking. Echoes encourages conversation, and, for that reason alone, you may find it worth a visit." Full Review

Ethan Kanfer: New York Theater Reviews

"Both Houlbrooke and Bragança turn in solid, vibrant performances. Naylor and Buttler give the 60-minute show a brisk pace and keep the intertwining stories from becoming confusing. Ultimately, though, the show stops being about the characters and becomes a sermon on the Worldwide Perpetual Martyrdom of Women. Naylor should trust his more humanistic instincts, and allow the audience more room interpret what the story means." Full Review

Show Showdown

"Earnest and well-acted…Despite being full of incident, the play never quite gels as theatre, and the politics are heavy-handed. Both husbands are one-dimensional creations; both women's situations come across as Women's Oppression 101 rather than the lived experiences of real individuals. Not to say that the stories aren't convincing, but they're not presented theatrically. The situations are effectively awful, but as lectures not a play." Full Review

A Seat on the Aisle

"Felicity Houlbrooke and Filipa Braganca both deliver truly spectacular performances in 'Echoes.' But, sad to say, their talents are largely squandered on this play which is little more than a superficial diatribe...In dueling monologues, Tillie and Samira expound on their ordeals and ultimate disillusionments but without ever really acknowledging any responsibility for their own actions...The play really is nothing more than an extreme feminist and far left polemic." Full Review

Fringe Review (UK)

for a previous production "The writing of this piece is just superb. At times witty and amusing, at times bitter and emotional...Houlbrooke and Braganca hold the audience through every second of the play...An astonishingly powerful play on an utterly contemporary theme which still carries resonances of history. Culturally and politically important, I cannot recommend it highly enough. It simply requires thought of its audience and the audience leaves changed by it: emotionally and spiritually." Full Review

The Barefoot Review

for a previous production "Naylor's script is utterly elegant both in his turns of phrase and the sophistication of his thoughts…Felicity Houlbrook and Filipa Braganca are absolutely up to the mark in delivering the language, both with beautifully modulated voices and exquisite enunciation...Each compels with a gamut of emotions. Theirs are wonderful performances of a wonderful play. It is enlightening, frank, balanced, and terrifyingly relevant. It is a five-star must-see." Full Review

Glam Adelaide

for a previous production "'Echoes' is a beautiful piece of writing, marvellously performed by Felicity Houlbrooke and Filipa Branganca...The script is descriptive and graphic, but with nice touches of political humour...Naylor’s well-researched script cleverly intertwines the two stories...Both Houlbrooke and Branganca are gifted actresses and entrance the audience with their power and directness...'Echoes' is thought-provoking and, quite simply, a brilliant piece of theatre." Full Review

Entertainment Hive

for a previous production "Naylor’s mastery of the written word is superb...Houlbrooke and Branganca hold the audience’s attention for every second of the play with both giving passionate, nuanced and mind-blowing performances. Every move simply added to the weight of this play, every word counted and the two actresses performed with every fibre of their being...This is an eye-opening, thought-provoking piece of relevant theatre which shows the plight of women across time and religion." Full Review

The Advertiser

for a previous production "You will not see two more fully fleshed out, beautifully realized performances than those delivered by Felicity Houlbrooke and Filipa Branganca: They seem to inhabit every cell of their skin, and control every flick and fall of their hair and robes...'Echoes' is variously heartbreaking, hilarious, empowering and provocative, with an almost poetic elegance where not a word is wasted or left wanting." Full Review

INDAILY (Australia)

for a previous production "A modern-day Jihadi bride and a Victorian 'bluestocking' seem an unlikely pair, but this gripping play exposes parallels between the two that are surprising and confronting…As the barbarities of their new lives are revealed – through taut narrative and convincing performances – the play becomes much more intense. It packs a powerful punch…It’s hard-hitting, highly topical and a must-see for those who enjoy serious and intelligent theatre." Full Review

Great Scott!

for a previous production "The performances of Houlbrooke and Branganca are rich and nuanced, particularly through portrayals of rape and betrayal...These are not easy stories to hear, but Naylor’s vivid and often poignant dialogue, woven with a subtle but crucial humour, effectively reminds us why reflecting on how the past recurs is so important...This is timely, necessary, and compelling theatre." Full Review

The Clothesline

for a previous production "Braganca and Holbrooke play their parts with such strength and nuance that we are immediately drawn into their separate worlds. It is the surprising similarity between their situations that is profoundly explored in 'Echoes'...Henry Naylor also has comedy credentials and manages to lighten the proceedings just enough with some well-placed humour. The end result is compelling and thoughtful rather than light entertainment but well worth the price of a ticket." Full Review

Krytzoff RAW

for a previous production "Rather than being pushed one way or the other to defend one belief system over the other, the audience gets to feel the truth in the old adage that history is destined to repeat itself...Both women give compelling performances; their control of nuance and inflection, both moving and powerful as well as a delight to witness. One wished they would have continued to entertain us for longer." Full Review

Rip It Up (Australia)

for a previous production "This play is offered stripped back, with nothing on stage but two actors and two chairs. But the stories are vividly made real through the vocal inventiveness of the cast, whose depictions of cruelty and horror are delivered with searing emotion...This reliance on story-telling to bring scenes to life means 'Echoes' necessarily flies close to hammy-ness at times, which may be grating for some, but the overall effect is impactful, and well worth a look." Full Review

Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Relevant, Enchanting

See it if / to witness superb actors storytell cleanly and succinctly. With zero bells and whistles, you get on the ride. What theater is about.

Don't see it if you want splashy, or do not like 1-person shows (this is basically two 1-person shows in one). Everything is well done, though, so go.

Ambitious, Absorbing, Great acting, Great writing, Thought-provoking

See it if you like thoughtful plays, great acting, shows that try to help audiences understand what's going on in the Middle East.

Don't see it if you're looking for something light & fluffy. It's funny, but not lighthearted.

Clever, Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Profound

See it if Dramatic writing and outstanding acting is a must for you to enjoy a play. Small venue that enhances the moments👍

Don't see it if Serious dialogue about women's empowerment is not your thing.

Absorbing, Great acting, Great writing, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if the same prejudice two centuries apart, two idealistic women from two different religions - well told, well acted parallel stories.

Don't see it if you don't like material that makes you angry or hopeless that things aren't as different as we'd like

Absorbing, Great acting, Thought-provoking

See it if brings you quickly to empathize with the two characters, one of whom you might think you're pre-disposed to dislike! But tragedy awaits...

Don't see it if you don't want your mind opened and your heart broken.

Absorbing, Well written, Ambitious, Funny, Great acting

See it if you want to spent a taut 50 minutes being introduced to two incredible young actresses and an ambitious, socially conscious playwright.

Don't see it if you are triggered by rape or violence against women (mostly narrated). You are an MRA. You don't like long monologues.

Absorbing, Thought-provoking, Riveting, Great staging, Great writing

See it if a show that is pure, simply staged and thought provoking.

Don't see it if you want to be challenged

Absorbing, Great acting, Great writing, Intelligent, Intense

See it if You want to see excellent acting in a very intense play. If you like short plays (it's only about 50 minutes).

Don't see it if You don't want to see two actors play about 10 different parts. You don't want to see something serious.

Absorbing, Thought-provoking, Profound, Great writing, Great acting

See it if You want to be totally absorbed and leave with real food for thought

Don't see it if Can't concentrate for an hour- it's quite intense and is just 2 actors with minimal props/scenery

During previews

See it if You are dying, and want 50 minutes to feel like 2 hours, or you need to be disabused of a notion that any man can write female characters.

Don't see it if You don't like ham handed political theater with its story turned up to eleven presuming you are too stupid to get the point otherwise.

Cast & Creatives (7)