Already closed

Informed Consent

Members say: Thought-provoking, Intelligent, Relevant, Ambitious, Resonant
77
Critics
77
24 reviews
Members
77
13 reviews
 

A geneticist is hired to figure out why a Native American tribe is being devastated by diabetes, but her research threatens to destroy the tribe's most sacred traditions.

... Read more

With genomic breakthroughs happening at breakneck speed, we can learn more about what our futures may hold than ever before. But how much should we know? And who gets to decide? 'Informed Consent' - a co-production between Ensemble Studio Theatre and Primary Stages - is a drama about one woman’s quest to answer the mysteries of science in her career as well as in her home life. The play was inspired by a landmark court case between the Havasupai tribe and Arizona State University.

 

Cast & Creatives (14)


Reviews (37)

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
77
Avg Score

85
The New York Times

"A thoughtful and engrossing play...The director and excellent cast smoothly handle the play’s complex structure...'Informed Consent' has some speechy moments. But it raises provocative questions about the potential conflicts between scientific discovery and religious beliefs." Full Review

89
Theatermania

"Deborah Zoe Laufer's probing and thoughtful 'Informed Consent' explores what happens when trust is violated...Liesl Tommy deftly directs this balancing act, marshalling the five-person cast to strikingly detailed performances for a play in which roles and locations seem to shift with the wind...Laufer pays respect to the technical without getting too bogged down in it. She knows her audience and how to challenge them to reexamine their preciously held beliefs." Full Review

80
New York Post

"There’s a big battle in 'Informed Consent' and it’s an oldie but goodie: science vs. beliefs. Nothing new under the sun here, but Deborah Zoe Laufer’s play trots along at a steady pace, carefully presenting the pros and cons of both sides with welcome flashes of humor." Full Review

85
BroadwayWorld

"Under Liesl Tommy's direction, the story is told with light humor and without dense scientific terminology that might alienate the less-scientific among us. A solidly-written play that is sure to provoke discussion." Full Review

55
Lighting & Sound America

"There's nothing more painful than seeing a playwright tackle tough, thorny issues without the skill to bring their complexities to dramatic life. That's that sad case with 'Informed Consent...' Laufer isn't too particular about how she keeps the pot boiling, resulting in all sorts of implausibilities." Full Review

60
New York Theater

"It is a dramatization in equal parts admirable and troubling...For all the fascination inherent in the subject, Laufer and director Liesl Tommy’s approach undermines the story...The bombardment of multiple themes and theatrical noodling is surely meant to keep the audience engaged, but ultimately has the opposite effect." Full Review

65
Talkin' Broadway

"Jillian and Arella's battle of wills, and the terrifying places it leads both of them, is a fascinating subject, and it's well handled by everyone while Laufer keeps her focus tight...But Laufer has so much to say that this energizing core does not get the consistent airing it should. It gets off track easily,..Only if it were honed to an excess-free state would this captivate you without making more of an appeal to your heart than your head; Laufer just seems more interested in the latter." Full Review

80
New York Daily News

"Deborah Zoe Laufer’s thoughtful and theatrical play is all the better for her main character’s thorny and complicated nature...While it moves smoothly, it is at times jarringly jokey. And having adult actors play kids who speak in a wittle baby voice is never a good idea. The same goes for a script that invokes the phrase 'Once upon a time' so much...In the end, the storybook phrase underscores that real life — mysterious and challenging — doesn’t come with happily ever afters." Full Review

85
Theatre Reviews Limited

"Under Liesl Tommy’s exquisite direction, the ensemble cast moves through time and space changes with ease and both narrate and perform this important story...'Informed Consent' raises significant questions...there is no right or no wrong here, just enduring and rich questions some of which are morally ambiguous." Full Review

60
NY1

"The science is quite fascinating and the conflicts exceedingly relevant; but as written and directed, the production over-reaches, with too many threads that seem to tie themselves in dramatic knots. The non-traditional cast is saddled with multiple roles requiring herculean stretches – not always successful...Lots to think about here, but in combining fact with fiction Ms. Laufer has bitten off more than she can chew." Full Review

90
Theater Pizzazz

"This very appealing 21st century story offers a peek into science’s right to challenge cultures, customs and the intricate stories and tales that are passed down from generation to generation...The story weaves easily in and through Jillian’s personal challenges as the very authentic Ms. Benko must deal with her own family and colleagues and the greater questions that need to be answered scientifically...Director Liesl Tommy moves her players around with swift aplomb holding the audience’s c... Full Review

95
CurtainUp

"Laufer has created a disquieting but also invigorating play as well as a supposition: That the results of scientific research may be as stunningly indeterminate and inconclusive as is the belief and dependence we have on our eternal myths to validate who and what we are. This theme pervades throughout this thought-provoking play." Full Review

60
Financial Times (UK)

"Laufer’s play sets out to challenge conventional ideas about science and storytelling, yet the dramaturgy can be as tangled as the four double-helix staircases that anchor Wilson Chin’s nifty set. The story appears initially to revolve around Jillian’s attempt to help the tribe find the cause of its alarmingly high rate of diabetes, but it veers towards the issue of informed consent and becomes didactic." Full Review

70
American Theater Web

"It’s the battle of religion versus science, and in Deborah Zoe Laufer’s thoughtful script, it receives an intriguing 21st century spin...Despite Liesl Tommy’s fleet direction, the production becomes a static and wearing affair...The result is a handsome package for this play that has at its core an important and timely debate. It’s rough, though, to not wish that the piece’s central question was explored in a more diverse manner." Full Review

80
Epoch Times

"Laufer and director Liesl Tommy do a great job blending all these elements into the show’s relatively short running time without making any of the scenes feel rushed. They’re even able to add some moments of levity, such as when Jillian and Graham meet for the first time...'Informed Consent' takes a hard look at a tough ethical issue and is not found wanting in what it presents." Full Review

75
As Her World Turns

"In August I saw one more show I’d like to add to this post — a new play called 'Informed Consent' which was written as part of an arts science grant. It follows the real-life events of a white professor at Arizona State University who took blood samples from members of the Havasupai tribe with the intent of studying their genes to find an explanation for the high rate of diabetes in their community." Full Review

90
Stage Buddy

"Though the play has moments of tragedy, it is ultimately played with warmth, levity, and self-awareness, driven in part by the terrific physical performances of a refreshingly diverse cast...The character switching is abrupt and occasionally absurd, but it is never once confusing thanks to the subtle mastery of the characters and caricatures from the simplest facial adjustment or gesture." Full Review

80
The Scientist

'Informed Consent; brims with color and life...Not everything in the play lands, however. While the cast is without exception talented and enjoyable to watch, the play’s young children are portrayed by adults, an exercise that never fails to induce cringing in this reviewer. And an epiphany experienced by Jillian at the end of the play seems a product less of character than of a desire for a tidy resolution. These minor flaws aside, “Informed Consent” is a compelling work." Full Review

90
BroadwayWorld

for a previous production "Sound like a downer? Not with the fertile imagination of Laufer. The audience finds themselves in a conundrum of whether to laugh or cry, often doing both...The ninety-minute play, presented without an intermission, holds the audience with excellent pacing and allows the fine writing to develop both the drama and the comedy." Full Review

90
Cleveland Jewish News

for a previous production "This has the potential of resembling a yawn-inducing, fact-saturated Discovery Channel report or a melodramatic Lifetime expose. Fortunately..., the playwright and director squeeze all the simultaneously disclosed science, personal crisis and philosophical debate into a beautifully woven, cleverly conceived and highly entertaining tapestry of storytelling." Full Review

95
Cleveland.com

for a previous production "The best thing about 'Informed Consent' is the way the moral and ethical ground of the play constantly shifts beneath your feet. Watching it is like trying to balance on a fault line. One moment, all is quiet; the next, you're sent sprawling...The play is both cerebral and theatrical, making its case to head and heart: It is steeped in cutting-edge and forward-looking science yet grounded by the Old World comforts of religion and family and tales of love at first sight." Full Review

80
Democrat & Chronicle

for a previous production "'Informed Consent' raises myriad questions on the complex intersection of modern science and the culture of indigenous peoples. In this gripping drama, playwright Deborah Zoe Laufer taps into the 2010 court case, Havasupai Tribe v. Arizona State University Board of Regents, and delves into a thought-provoking question: Does the potential benefit of biomedical research trump the value of individual human rights?" Full Review

75
The MS Press

for a previous production "It seems as though Laufer attempts to add comic relief to the script; however, it is misplaced and hardly receives any laughs from the audience. Lightheartedness is out of place when addressing such a sensitive topic based on true events...Though momentarily shocked, I was pleased with this experience for the play aims to make individuals realize the importance of respecting differences in opinions and beliefs." Full Review

85
Rochester City Newspaper

for a previous production "The play instantly goes from being interesting and engaging to emotionally wrenching, and it stays there until the end." Full Review

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
77
Avg Score

60
Ambitious, Thought-provoking, Disappointing, Unsuccessful

See it if you are fascinated by health issues (here, diabetes). Unfortunately, this piece lacks focus. It goes off the rails.

Don't see it if you want coherent story-telling. I felt frustrated by IC's rambling plot.

82
Intelligent, Intense, Thought-provoking, Resonant, Entertaining

See it if You like shows about issues. You like dramatic plays that make you think about things. You appreciate good casting. You like the director.

Don't see it if You'd rather see a joyful comedy instead of a more serious drama with tension, betrayal, and fighting. You need to like all the characters.

72
Preachy, Original, Entertaining, Scientific

See it if you don't mind scientific based plays.

Don't see it if you don't like preachy plays.

80
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Intense, Thought-provoking

See it if You would enjoy a true story about the clash between scientific research/ambition and respect for native american cultural heritage.

Don't see it if You wouldn't consider cultural beliefs and ancestral heritage to be a valid reason to limit science.

77
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Profound, Great writing

See it if Tells a true story, has a definite point of view. Moving performances.

Don't see it if You don't like issue plays.

90
Clever, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Resonant, Great writing

See it if you're interested in truly interesting story-telling about identity, from race to cultural heritage to hereditary illness.

Don't see it if you don't want to think about the issue of identity.

75
Intelligent, Relevant, Fluidly staged, Competent, Twee

See it if a writer's clever connections between scientific, social, & personal issues presented with clarity and theatricality excites you.

Don't see it if story theatre conventions seem childish and information you could read in an essay is less important to you than live-wire bonds btw actors.

75
Original, Ambitious, Thought-provoking, Resonant, Dull staging

See it if you like science, sociological ideas, strong female leads, multi-cultural casts, family drama

Don't see it if you are looking for pure escapism

80
Ambitious, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Great writing

See it if you like spirited post-show discussions.

Don't see it if you don't mix your ethics with theater.

80
Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Relevant

See it if You enjoy some education with your entertainment

Don't see it if You are in the mood for froth.

82
Ambitious, Clever, Intelligent, Strident, Too preachy

See it if questions of race, genetic destiny or Native American stories or good acting and ambitious new plays that don't totally make it interest you

Don't see it if Big ideas/science bore you. Thought-provoking entertainment isn't your jam. Human drama mixed with politics/race issues aren't your thing.

86
Original, Thought-provoking, Profound, Relevant, Resonant

See it if You enjoy thought provoking, world view challenging material.

Don't see it if You are restless with dialogue that is not tightly written.

72
During previews
Intelligent, Inventive, Relevant, Too preachy

See it if You enjoy debating "Would you want to find out if you have a bad gene?" and sprightly staging of an unusual topic for a play

Don't see it if You dislike fourth-wall-breaking, preachy explanations - the lead scientist says "we're all [genetic] cousins!!" way too many times.