See it if you enjoy shows based on historical events or appreciate musicals w/ a local theatre feel that are made by artists with a love of the craft.
Don't see it if you prefer large-scale, splashy productions. This is small and intimate.
See it if You appreciate low level production of a new musical. Almost like a workshop level.
Don't see it if You want a finished professional musical.
"The lyrics tend to be very thin and extremely repetitious. The uncredited set is actually that of another show with unnecessary portions covered over in brown cloth, giving the look of the show no atmosphere whatever. The uncredited costumes are mainly coordinated in bland brown and white which does not help set period one bit. Stone's choreography is extremely basic and not very decorative. If you sit on the left side of the theater, you are likely to be blinded periodically."
“While disaster tales can often be rich fodder for the stage, Pellegrino’s dramatization is nearly unwatchable. Pellegrino presents us with little more than a cookie-cutter, stereotypical Italian Immigrant family...Were this show a parody, it could have worked. The fact that it is played as a legitimate drama makes for an awkward and painful 90 minutes. The mixed caliber of talent makes the best of this burden...There have been finer junior high school productions mounted.”
"An amateurish new musical…Pellegrino, rather than getting into the weeds about the actual disaster and its consequences, chooses instead to tell a banal, clichéd, pre-spill, laugh-an-hour story about a stereotypical Italian-American family…You'll probably want to know more about this catastrophe, which is far more interesting than the show...A good show lies stuck somewhere in the story, struggling to get out, but 'Molasses in January' isn't it."
"At best this production can be described as amateurish...The 19 songs, if you can call them that, neither enhance the story or move the action forward...The songs also have no structure and sound like snippets of ditties, if they could have formed a coherent tune...The cast was like watching badly performed community theatre, with not a lot of talent. The vocals for the most part were thin, nasal and sounded out of tune...There is not a thing I can recommend about this production."