Already closed

Orwell In America

Members say: Great acting, Absorbing, Thought-provoking, Intelligent, Clever
79
Critics
77
20 reviews
Members
80
50 reviews
 

Northern Stage presents Joe Sutton's drama about what might have happened if celebrated 20th-century English author, George Orwell, had actually visited America.

... Read more

In this alternate history play set right after World War II, the author of 'Animal Farm' is chaperoned during an American book tour by a fetching young woman who must dissuade him from telling Americans why he is a proud socialist. 'Orwell in America' makes its New York premiere starring Jamie Horton (former leading actor of the Tony Award-winning Denver Center Theater Company) in the title role.

 

Cast & Creatives (11)



Reviews (70)

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
77
Avg Score

70
The New York Times

"The script of 'Orwell in America' has several shortcomings, all of them excusable once its lead actor, Jamie Horton, starts to speak. As the title character, Mr. Horton delivers perhaps the finest performance I’ve seen Off Broadway this year, and greatly raises the worth of this moderately interesting play...Joe Sutton’s script is light on drama, outside of moments manufactured to spark tension...Still, Mr. Horton is dynamic...While there’s scant spectacle, Mr. Horton remains transfixing." Full Review

90
BroadwayWorld

"Sutton has created a keen imagining of what might have occurred if Orwell had actually visited the United States on a book tour...The actors portray their roles with a passion that brings their characters to full life. Jamie Horton is excellent as George Orwell. You may believe you are in the company of the renowned writer who is tenacious, yet subtly charming...See 'Orwell in America' now while it is on the New York City stage. This theatrical jewel entertains and captivates its audience." Full Review

80
Lighting & Sound America

"It's fascinating that 'Orwell in America' aims to get at the truth of its title character through an entirely fictional set of incidents...Most the time 'Orwell in America' is a sympathetic portrait of a fierce, fearless thinker caught in the political crosscurrents of his time...Sutton makes real drama out this imaginary episode that accurately evokes the conflicts that roiled Orwell's life in its final chapter. And in Horton, he has an actor magnificently equipped to bring Orwell to life. " Full Review

80
Theatre's Leiter Side

“The play is...superbly acted. Horton bears a distinct resemblance to Orwell, has a flawless British accent, and brings intelligence, charm, and complete honesty to every line. De Waal, who brings Rachel Evan Wood to mind, matches him line for line with nuanced readings, squeezing the subtle truth out of every utterance...It makes for an engrossing experience of which it can be said that, if all plays were equal, some, like this one (despite its flaws), would be more equal than others.” Full Review

55
Theatre Reviews Limited

"'Orwell in America' though interesting and informative, is more 'scholarly' than it needs to be...Mr. Horton and Ms. De Wall do justice to Mr. Sutton’s script but there is not enough in that script to offer either actor opportunities to explore their characters with depth. Or perhaps director Peter Hackett has not explored the depths of the actors’ formidable crafts...There is not enough new material or remarkable conflicts to make the narrative move forward in a fresh way." Full Review

85
TheaterScene.net

"That Jamie Horton is an American actor employing an authentic sounding clipped British accent further substantiates his superb performance as the title role in the very enjoyable biographical fantasia…Ms. de Waal offers a lovely characterization conveying attractiveness and intelligence. De Waal and Horton have great chemistry together which is an integral part of the production’s success…Director Peter Hackett’s work with the actors achieves the desired sensitivity and passion." Full Review

85
Woman Around Town

"It’s neither necessary to know Orwell’s history nor to have read 'Animal Farm' in order to enjoy the play. In fact, this is probably the best, most comprehensible retelling of the latter you’re likely to hear...Jamie Horton is marvelous...Jeanna de Waal offers just the right balance of historically subjugated Vassar smarts, ambition, femininity, and youth...Director Peter Hackett gives us two such distinctly different characters we can almost see class, geography and history." Full Review

80
Wolf Entertainment Guide

"What Horton does exceedingly well is build a portrait of Orwell as a rigid man and thinker minus the gift of personal appeal needed to win people over to his ideas...Much praise is due his stage partner de Waal. She turns in a very impressive performance as Carlotta...Director Hackett manages the scenic flow tidily and keeps the focus where it should be at all times...At awards time attention should be paid to this major acting accomplishment by Horton." Full Review

80
Theatre is Easy

"Sutton’s writing as well as Horton’s portrayal certainly bring to life a vivid character...Soundbites of audience members' questions during Blair's talk become slightly off-putting because of the technical capacity of the space. However, it is apparent how they push the story forward. The actors command the stage with captivating grace, especially Horton, who creates a spot-on, complex George Orwell who is no longer merely a name on a dust jacket, but a multidimensional human." Full Review

90
Reviews Off Broadway

"A fascinating exercise and a wonderful show...Jamie Horton brings a cantankerous, funny and stubborn Orwell to life...What makes this show wonderful is the dynamic between the much older George Orwell and the much younger and beautiful Carlotta. It is in this personal dynamic that Ms. de Waal and Mr. Horton make the characters sing. Their banter is heartfelt and their growing friendship blooms organically...The show never feels forced or leaden. I loved it." Full Review

85
Theater Pizzazz

"Jamie Horton gives a delightful, virtuosic performance, engaging us with his humor and wit, while touching us with his neediness...Deftly directed by Peter Hackett, 'Orwell in America' is more than a fascinating study of a leading literary figure. It’s also a touching romance (Orwell is in his late 40s, Carlotta is in her early 20s). Moreover, it’s about historical context...Thanks to playwright Sutton’s passion and Jamie Horton’s performance, Orwell certainly has left an impression on us." Full Review

45
Let's Talk Off-Broadway

"It’s such a clear-cut premise it’s surprising that the play doesn’t have more intellectual and dramatic clarity...Jamie Horton is believable, at times touching and at other times monotonous...We do not, however, arrive at the sense of having in some important ways come to know the man or the author, or come to feel we’ve met him...Who, then, really, was George Orwell? You don’t find out in this play but you do learn something about his views...There are better ways." Full Review

80
New York Theatre Guide

"Award-winning playwright Joe Sutton not only captures the man of ideas but also places them in a setting where they, and he, are accessible even to those who know nothing at all of Orwell...They explore his work, socialism, the Spanish Civil War, Britain’s class system, and sexual politics – which I know sounds about as exciting as listening to a chess match on the radio, but Sutton and Horton have managed to make these discussions that we might have in our daily lives." Full Review

90
Stage Buddy

"I suspect that even fans of Orwell and those who are particularly well informed about this period in history will find a new level of understanding about this era...Director Peter Hackett makes some wonderful choices, both in utilization of the stage space and in the way his actors express themselves through body language and physicality. A well-rounded production that oozes charm and celebrates humor, 'Orwell in America' is an absolute treat and not to be missed." Full Review

60
Plays to See

"Gratefully, I did leave this show feeling I had spent an evening in the presence of Orwell...Jamie Horton as Orwell makes his remarkable New York City debut as a mature actor here...The play itself is a rather slight dramatic vehicle designed to bring Orwell to us, tracing a fictionalized relationship between him and a young female publicist...We don’t learn much more about Orwell’s life than is commonly known...De Waal does a wonderful job with the fairly thin material comprising her role." Full Review

60
New York Theatre Review

"Orwell is played by Jamie Horton in a note-perfect portrayal...Orwell was indeed brilliant, and throughout the play we’re given a window into the history of his long and storied relationship with the written word...While all this might be interesting for this English major, the problem here is that it’s not much of a play...Director Peter Hackett does what he can to dramatize these lectures, but at the end of the day the majority of the piece is restricted to situations of one man talking." Full Review

70
Indianapolis Business Journal

"George Orwell—as portrayed here by Jamie Horton—is a fascinating figure...But Joe Sutton’s play isn’t a one-man show. His Orwell is on a book tour shepherded by a young publicist and the device feels, well, like a device. But some clunkiness is worth it when the central character is this interesting." Full Review

85
Berkshire Fine Arts

"Director Peter Hackett brings off this complicated but always engaging man with subtlety and charm...Jamie Horton is magnificent in the role. Orwell’s discomfort, loneliness, humor and passion are all developed before us in language that is very much the author’s. It is lively as well as precise...The moves from deep despair to subtle wit and humor are accomplished easily both in gestures by Horton and the words of the playwright." Full Review

90
Seven Days

for a previous production "Sutton's thorough research and masterful dialogue illuminate his work's relevance to contemporary politics…The ensemble work of Horton and White in the lead roles is riveting…When Horton steps on stage, he inhabits the role of the Eton-educated Orwell, putting the audience solidly in his corner…Hackett has worked with Sutton on several previous productions…With ‘Orwell in America,’ the collaboration of these longtime colleagues gives rise to a polished, intelligent production." Full Review

90
Times Argus

for a previous production "A riveting production of this intimate play with infinite scope, that is quite entertaining as well as potent…A fascinating portrait of a great but flawed man, revealing a deep personal drama. Sutton has crafted a taut script that gives insight into Orwell without ever becoming pedantic…Horton, despite occasionally overdramatizing, felt totally authentic as this frustrated upper-crust Englishman playing the populist…Sutton’s 'Orwell' is compelling history — and compelling entertainment." Full Review

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
80
Avg Score

72
Intelligent, Relevant, Disappointing, Slow, Too long

See it if you want to see great acting by Jamie Horton; you are interested in politics then and now; you don't mind George Orwell remaining a mystery.

Don't see it if wordy plays centering on the politics of Animal Farm are not interesting to you; you want to see a well edited story with the fat cut out.

79
Clever, Great acting, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Slow

See it if you want to see a story about George Orwell's political views in an imagined book tour of usa.

Don't see it if don't have any interest in George Orwell's politics

85
Absorbing, Clever, Enchanting

See it if Are interested in a well written, and acted play about George Orwell which relates to our current political climate .

Don't see it if If you only prefer light and not complex social and political issues

80
Absorbing, Relevant

See it if Orwell's Animal Farm and discussion of Communism versus Socialism interests you. Relevant to present day.

Don't see it if you like faster paced, bigger production.

Also felt the addition of a side-plot of possible romantic tension was supe... Read more Read less

80
Great acting, Thought-provoking, Great writing, Too long

See it if you are a fan of Orwell and want a very talky show about socialism. Two strong characters. Great acting.

Don't see it if Not a fan of Orwell. Want a show with more action.

77
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Entertaining

See it if you enjoy plays involving one-on-one dialogue and not much else. Explores the developing relationship between Orwell and his publicist.

Don't see it if Plays with little "action" bore you. You are totally disinterested in Orwell's philosophy or personality. You prefer musicals.

97
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Great writing

See it if You like an intelligent play between 2 character, one being George Orwell. If you like strong personalities and learning about Animal Farm.

Don't see it if You want a classic drama or comedy. If you don't want to think or learn or form opinions or care to find out more about Orwells books.

89
Clever, Great acting, Intelligent, Resonant, Great writing

See it if U r an Orwell fan, can appreciate v interesting discourse on Socialism, intelligent relationship between 2 people w/strong wills & history~

Don't see it if This type of literary play bores you, you're looking for an easy show or would find a play with a lot of dialogue & not much action tiring.

81
Absorbing, Thought-provoking

See it if Thought-provoking two-person play with an outstanding performance by Jamie Horton as George Orwell explicating his writings and philosophy.

Don't see it if Not an outstanding play but well directed and worthwhile nevertheless

90
Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Intelligent

See it if You are interested in the issue of Communism vs Socialism...and appreciate fine acting

Don't see it if Socio-political issues such as this do not interest you.

Also The lead actor was superb!

75
Funny, Relevant, Entertaining

See it if You're interested in how socialism can be a dirty word

Don't see it if There wasn't much to take away and I left a little disappointed

82
Absorbing, Great acting, Thought-provoking

See it if You are a fan of Orwell. You are interested in challenging your perceptions of socio-economic systems.

Don't see it if You don't like plays that make you think.

50
Disappointing, Slow, Too long

See it if you want to see a shallow story. A fictional visit to the U.S. Mostly about Orwell's lecherous interest in his 28 yr old publicist.

Don't see it if you prefer more insightful biographical shows

85
Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Great writing, Entertaining

See it if you are interested in the complexities of George Orwell politics and how they are still relevant today.

Don't see it if you have no interest in George Orwell.

90
Absorbing, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Relevant

See it if enjoy political discussions that are intelligent and unusual. Along with some nice chemistry in the leads.

Don't see it if you are looking for a deep drama.

82
Absorbing, Ambitious, Delightful, Great acting, Entertaining

See it if you're impressed with historic figures and politics.

Don't see it if you're bored by content and prefer disfunctional- family fare.

87
Absorbing, Clever, Delightful, Great acting, Intelligent

See it if you'd like to know more about great author

Don't see it if you are not interested in politics

92
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Riveting

See it if you are interested in George Orwell and appreciate great acting!

Don't see it if ... you are not!

84
Funny, Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Entertaining

See it if You are a fan of George Orwell. You are interested in politics.

Don't see it if You are unable to distinguish between socialism and communism.

92
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Must see

See it if You like fascinating drama and superb acting.

Don't see it if You prefer predictable fluff.

95
Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Entertaining, Great staging

See it if you are interested in Orwell, post-WW2 and the political confusion of the world during that time. See it if you want an intelligent play.

Don't see it if you are looking for constant laughter and just a relaxing show with lot's of comedy.

82
During previews
Absorbing, Great acting, Thought-provoking, Great writing, Slow

See it if you appreciate great acting (Jamie Horton as Orwell is remarkable), thoughtful characterizations, and literate theater

Don't see it if you expect a large flashy production or if you dislike dialogue-heavy plays without much action

100
During previews
Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if You are interested in a different point of view at contemporary politics; you are interested in Orwell's works and understanding him better

Don't see it if You don't like or don't care about Orwell's work; you have difficulties drawing parallels between the past the the present

88
During previews
Absorbing, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Confusing

See it if You are interested in an exploration of human complexity - ideals vs. character, like plays dealing with political ideologies still relevant

Don't see it if You can't appreciate excellent acting by Jamie Horton in a flawed play that deals in part with America's phobia about "The Red Menace".

Also This play really made me think about Post-World War ll politics, and t... Read more Read less

83
During previews
Ambitious, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Quirky

See it if you'll enjoy a play about a historical figure in an imaginary situation.The lead did a good job channeling Orwell; it's really a 1 man show.

Don't see it if you prefer shows with action and a plot.This show is almost all dialog and very little happens. You dislike plays which are a bit pedantic.