Already closed

The Dressmaker's Secret

Members say: Intelligent, Great acting, Absorbing, Thought-provoking, Intense
66
Critics
61
14 reviews
Members
81
6 reviews
 

The Simon Studio presents a drama set in '60s Romania about a teenager desperate to escape to the west and his mother who's harboring a life-changing secret.

... Read more

It's 1963. Nineteen-year-old Robi longs to escape communist Romania for the United States. However, the one person who can help Robi is a man his mother, Maria, is desperate to keep from him. During World War II, Maria was engaged to a Hungarian army officer, but fell in love with Zoli, a Jewish man whom she hid from the Nazis. The officer discovered Zoli, who was sent to Auschwitz, but spared the newly pregnant Maria’s life. Two decades later, the officer returns. Will the painful secrets of their past change the course of Robi’s future? 'The Dressmaker's Secret' is a heart-wrenching drama that examines the oppression of the police state, the defiant endurance of the human spirit, and the healing power of love.

 


Reviews (20)

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
61
Avg Score

45
Lighting & Sound America

"The bombshells come so thick and fast that the characters spend most of the play in a state of shock...If anything, Simon's direction emphasizes the clunky, portentous nature of the script; generally, the women fare better...'Secret' ends on a modestly touching note, but it could have been so much more; in any case, it is preceded by more than two hours of clanking dramatic machinery. It's a Cold War soap opera that trivializes some of the twentieth century's most traumatic events." Full Review

50
Theatre's Leiter Side

"This promising material is presented over a way-too-long two hours and 20 minutes in 15 dawdling scenes that shift back and forth between apartments, cafés, and restaurants. The play—perhaps because of its origins as a novel—is structurally flabby, spreading its multiple foci and many secrets too thin, creating only the most tenuous tension or suspense. Potentially thrilling emotional moments are buried under the expository lethargy, distancing us from the characters' dilemmas." Full Review

40
Theater In The Now

"No matter how the story shakes up, an incredible amount of cutting is greatly desired. There is a plethora of repeated information that bogs down the pacing...There was truth and sincerity in Roger Hendricks Simon’s direction. That being said, Simon’s passive direction forced the stakes to feel minimal...The quartet of actors tried their best to avoid becoming cookie-cutter characters despite the writing...'The Dressmaker’s Secret' is just bogged down by its length and its lack of stakes." Full Review

40
Theatre Reviews Limited

"'The Dressmaker’s Secret' suffers from the lack of a clear and convincing dramatic arc. There are too many things going on...Mr. Simon’s direction leaves the talented cast wandering around the stage instead of staying in place and having a realistic conversation...In short, an endearing story with potentially multilayered connections is lost in an overly long production encumbered by inconsistent staging." Full Review

55
Front Mezz Junkies

"The story is compelling in its simplicity but, in the telling of it, has become convoluted and overly complex...We become impatient for these fine actors, who are working so hard to flesh out these poor souls, to stop moving around and deliver us to the real emotional core of the secret and the scenario...It’s not that complicated, but the scope of the director and playwright casts too great a net...There is a compelling beautiful story lost somewhere in this theatre and it should be heard." Full Review

80
Talkin' Broadway

"On the face of it, 'The Dressmaker's Secret' sounds a bit like a soap opera, one that easily could turn into a mawkish weeper. But thanks to the solid performances and Roger Hendricks Simon's direction, the play shows surprising depths as its themes of love, loss, regret, shame, and reconciliation emerge over the course of the evening." Full Review

30
Woman Around Town

"Were Simon and Grunfeld’s play filled with experiential details, it would be an interesting story. It is not. Names, places, and events are too often colorless and without detail. A moment many of us felt was the fitting ending is bypassed for an unnecessary additional scene. Tracy Sallows is the only one onstage who consistently holds our attention and elicits sympathy...Director Simon consigns his company to caucus races much of the time, circling round and round the set without reason." Full Review

90
TheaterScene.net

"'The Dressmaker's Secret' is an important play that shines a light on the Holocaust, Eastern Europe's submission to Communist regimes, and the toll all this history has taken on a small corner of Europe." Full Review

40
BlogCritics.org

"The plot, conflicts, and themes of 'The Dressmaker’s Secret' are meaningful. However, the way they are delivered, primarily through exposition and explanation, is static. Also, some scenes appear extraneous because they further the play’s development only at a snail’s pace. Bits of dialogue may have been truncated to create more of the vibrance of reality. As a result acute action is sporadic, the audience engagement is hampered, the direction appears lethargic." Full Review

85
Theater Pizzazz

"A gripping new play...Maria is sensitively embodied by Tracy Swallows; Irma is enchantingly portrayed by Carolyn Koziowski; exuberant Robert, the most complex of the characters, is peeled until fully exposed in a splendid performance by Robert S. Gregory...Bryan Burton wrenchingly extracts every drop of pathos...The work is superbly directed by Roger Hendricks Simon, who turns the small space into an advantage." Full Review

80
Stage Buddy

"Skillful playwrights Sarah Levine Simon and Mihai Grunfeld allow these scenarios to unfold with such finesse that one is easily transported to another time and place. Director Roger Simon uses his experienced hand to gently maneuver his actors along in this well-executed story, and expertly peels off each intriguing layer with perfect timing and pace, keeping the audience intrigued from start to finish...'The Dressmaker’s Secret' is one secret you’ll want to share." Full Review

75
ZEALnyc

"'The Dressmaker’s Secret' has cottoned on to something and could find a receptive audience...Burton does a solid job as mop-topped Robi, Sallows dispenses some effective zingers from her Singer and the second-half arrival of Gregory injects much-needed energy after a somewhat sluggish first half. For sustained excellence, Kozlowski is the show’s standout performer...The actress brings poignancy and pathos to her role, aided by the saddest smile I’ve ever seen." Full Review

80
Plays to See

“Overall, ‘The Dressmaker’s Secret’ is a commendable play. The conflicts between the characters are skillfully developed, and the plot unfolds intriguingly...The acting is generally sound. Still, at times the actor’s movements seem awkward, and Bryan Burton tends to yell out lines for no apparent reason. And while the script is compelling, the dialogue seems to drag from time to time. Otherwise, the plot is weighty and the performance is satisfying." Full Review

85
Theatermania

"Despite such elements of artificiality, Grunfeld and Simon have written something poignant...The vividness of these characters is matched by the vividness of the production itself...Roger Hendricks Simon's direction shares both the efficiency of the set and the evocativeness of the costumes. What he and his cast and crew have fashioned with 'The Dressmaker's Secret' isn't just a work of art — it's a work of humanity." Full Review

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
81
Avg Score

79
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Intense, Relevant

See it if you are interested in the history of Communism in Hungary, how the war affected the lives of real people; how secrets can impact lives.

Don't see it if you expect a tightly written show with extensive staging; this is in a tiny black box with minimalist sets; you dislike intimacy with actors

Also I saw the first preview of this show; it kept my interest and the acti... Read more Read less

90
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking, Great writing

See it if riveting dramatic pay represents the subject matter truthfully is the opinion of someone who has who has lived under an oppressive regime

Don't see it if you do not like to be in small spaces, where the actors are practically 1-3 ft. away from you.

78
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if Enjoy a story that takes time to unfold, intimate theatre spaces, and post-WWII topics; I was engrossed throughout

Don't see it if You want a fast paced play; large or traditional precenium stage, and modern topic; it's a little long at 2+ hours

70
Relevant, Resonant, Cliched

See it if you are moved by stories of the Holocaust. This is another touching tale. Best efforts by talent and an enjoyable evening.

Don't see it if You expect Broadway quality. This felt a bit amateur.

73
Clever, Great acting, Raunchy, Dated, Entertaining

See it if The themes would be very meaningful to young marrieds who are making their way in the complex world of being a couple and being parents.

Don't see it if If you were a young adult in the 70's and 80's because you will know this story. Open marriages, alternate lifestyles and drugs are old hat.

Also There is some nudiity and explicit sexual references.

90
During previews
Absorbing, Intelligent, Intense, Thought-provoking, Riveting

See it if You like plays with a powerful theme and intensity.

Don't see it if You don't have patience for a slowly-building intensity.

Also We saw the show last night and it was memorable.