In The Monsters: A Sibling Love Story, a young woman named Lil unexpectedly returns to the life of her estranged brother Big, a fading but locally famous MMA fighter. Having long followed his career from a distance, Lil arrives at his doorstep unannounced, stirring old memories, buried tensions, and unresolved questions. As the siblings grapple with their shared history and opposing paths, the play delves into themes of identity, rivalry, and the ties that endure between family members, even when love is complicated.

This world premiere is written and directed by Ngozi Anyanwu, known for Good Grief, The Homecoming Queen, and The Last of the Love Letters. Her work often explores familial bonds and cultural identity with emotional nuance and clarity. The two-hander features Aigner Mizzelle as Lil and Okieriete Onaodowan (Hamilton, Station 19) as Big, bringing intense performances to the intimate dynamic at the story’s core.

Presented by Manhattan Theatre Club in collaboration with Two River Theater, this production is staged Off-Broadway at New York City Center – Stage II as part of MTC’s 2025–26 season. Continuing the company’s tradition of championing new voices in American theatre, The Monsters marks another milestone in Ngozi Anyanwu’s growing body of work.