“The show consists of Wes learning valuable lessons about gay and lesbian history, as well as the importance of connecting in real life…The show, directed by Scott Ebersold, becomes bogged down in heavy-handed lecturing toward the end, and favors quips over plot. But Mr. Vernon’s score, which draws from the period’s disco, soft rock and glam sounds, is solid — which is important, since the evening essentially consists of ‘all about me’ songs by the staff and patrons." Full Review
"Vernon is egalitarian in his songwriting, giving everyone a number (although not all are of equal quality)...As fun and informative as these songs are, we can never quite escape the sense the playwright-composer is desperately trying to get us to learn something from this experience, making the whole enterprise feel like a gay after-school special...Despite its flaws, 'The View UpStairs' is mostly enjoyable and carries with it a timely and important message." Full Review
"A lot of disparate characters to pack into a one-act musical, which may be why they're painted and (mostly) played in such broad strokes under Ebersold's unsubtle direction...Clearly a passion project for book writer, composer and lyricist Vernon. He's definitely got talent: His eclectic '70s-style tunes are catchy...It's commendable that Vernon wants to celebrate the gays who came (out) before but...the result feels as derivative as a drag queen doing Cher." Full Review
"Never unpleasant, and often quite amusing, 'The View UpStairs' suffers from confusion about its intentions...Mostly, the hey there, good times atmosphere holds until the end...By this point, the characters have begun indulging in so much inspirational speechmaking that what has been a moderately entertaining evening turns just a wee bit tedious...Nevertheless, Vernon's songs are usually easy to take...The cast, under Scott Ebersold's lively direction, is ready to rock." Full Review
"Vernon relies heavily on clichés in the show, creating a queer 'Cheers'...Despite the stock characters and situations, Vernon’s work with Scott Ebersold’s direction and the cast’s performances do stir emotions...Simply put, 'The View UpStairs' is not a perfect show. Yet, with this piece, Vernon shows potential and promise...In these successful moments, the musical proves itself to be timely and relevant. In the moments when the show falls flat, the audience is at least entertained." Full Review
"There's Vernon's well-greased knack with writing this sort of pastiche material from the era's musical forms...The performing company is a trip, too...It just doesn't add up to much other than a sort of vampy, revamped 'A Chorus Line'...For all its flash and filigree, the writing never transcends its basic subject matter to become about something bigger...'The View UpStairs' would have a greater impact if Vernon were more interested in learning from history than in merely repeating it." Full Review
"Vernon’s music is infectious and I dare you to see this show without dancing in your seats...The script, though a fairy tale of sorts, hits home...Director Scott Ebersold keeps this show sparkling and though we cry, we are not called on to be maudlin, but are brought to the point where we cannot forget...The cast is energetic and each individual has moments of shinning bright and making their mark...'The View UpStairs' is an uplifting reminder of our past." Full Review
“There’s a lovely sweet and sour story enmeshed in ‘The View UpStairs’…Sadly, it is lost somewhere behind the heavy-handed book by Vernon and the over-the-top direction by Scott Ebersold…In general, the new group of actors haven’t found their groove yet as a unit. The larger, full-cast numbers were not harmonious or united but cumbersome, and everyone was far too over-the-top…I hope over time they come together and raise this show up again.” Full Review
"Initially, the conceit...is cute. But the gimmick soon wears thin...The play is not without value. Just don't expect nuance. And at one hour forty-five minutes and no intermission, it's a tough slog. Out of sixteen musical numbers, only a handful are musically compelling...Still, though uneven and often heavy-handed, 'The View UpStairs' has some nice moments. Given the important subject matter, one just wishes it worked better as a piece of art." Full Review
"Max Vernon’s musical is an engaging amalgam of magical realism and surrealism that allows the audience to see two histories counterpoint one another and inform each other 'from a distance'...Each of Mr. Vernon’s characters is well developed and represents both a unique character and a 'stock' character from the 1970s gay scene – a remarkable accomplishment for the musical’s creator and director Scott Ebersold...This is a musical with a matrix of authentic and engaging themes." Full Review
"Max Vernon has scripted an exceptional story…The libretto has some holes. But some of these dramaturgical things can easily be patched up…The characters that Vernon has crafted are vibrant, leaping off the page…It’s the personal relationships that are formed that keep this musical afloat…‘The View UpStairs’ is a great work but what sets this musical apart is the magnificent production design…This incarnation of 'The View UpStairs' is not perfect. But it’s absolutely a must see.” Full Review
"As memorable as the cast is, they’re backed up by Max Vernon’s catchy and moving songs. Everyone gets a turn, which is admirable, but certain songs land better than others...Jason Sherwood’s set design, aided by Andrew Diaz's props and set dressing, is outstanding...Just as Wes gets woke by the end, the production’s intent is clearly to have audiences not just walk out humming, but to fight back." Full Review
"Ultimately, Vernon’s musical adds up to a series of character portraits. Some are more lovingly detailed than others, just as some numbers are more memorable, but each character has their own distinct place in this time capsule of queer experience, and a story worth telling...Though the production ambles then pivots perhaps a bit too sharply under Scott Ebersold’s direction, one would be hard-pressed not to feel the force of the tragedy." Full Review
"Thoroughly thoughtful and entertaining...Graham is a stunning performer. His work in this piece is a master class in the art of acting...Vernon is mostly wise to utilize the vocal talents of his cast...The score is terrific, but I wish that Vernon had showcased Davis a bit more...'The View UpStairs,' smartly directed by Scott Ebersold, is an important retrospective of the gay community: where we’ve been, where we are, and who we could—and should—be." Full Review
“On the fourth anniversary of the Stonewall uprising in 1973, an arsonist set fire to a gay bar in New Orleans, killing 32 people. This tragic yet forgotten episode in gay history is not only part of a Harvey Fierstein monologue in ‘Gently Down the Stream’ - currently playing at the Public Theater--but also the subject of ‘The View UpStairs,’ a new Off Broadway musical that has a lot of spark, but ultimately not enough fire.” Full Review
"A phenomenal cast carries a powerful and moving experience...There are a few occasions where the out-of-time elements clash with the smoothness of the play as a whole...A tightening of these details would help drive the authenticity of the play even further. Minor specificity issues aside, 'The View UpStairs' is a poignant, exuberant, touching musical that explores a dark day in LGBTQIA history. This play is a special experience, and shows promise for a bright and successful future." Full Review
"'The View UpStairs' sags at times. A few minor characters’ forgettable songs could easily have been cut, ideally to make room for more of the absolutely scene-stealing, uproarious bits from 'old queen' Willie...Still, the show swells with heart, and its characters and the history they represent should rightly be celebrated and remembered. 'The View UpStairs' is ultimately a moving homage to LGBT culture, past and present." Full Review
"'The View UpStairs' is a quintessential star-spangled civil rights kiss-off; it may also be the first great post-Trump musical of the 21st century...The show is revelatory...This production is not perfect...Some jokes also do not land...There are moments where the audience has to wait too long for the build up...Make no mistake however, as a show, 'The View UpStairs' has all of the ingredients for an iconic cult phenomenon." Full Review
“An imaginative, powerful, beautifully performed theater piece…The diverse cast is uniformly strong, in their acting, singing and dancing. The brunt of the performing, however, is borne by dynamic Jeremy Pope as Wes…The show has had an interesting journey so far. Developed in part at Rhinebeck Writers Retreat and at New York Stage and Film & Vassar at the Powerhouse Theater, it deserves further travel—to an uptown house." Full Review
“It is fascinating to witness the clash of different eras and attitudes not only through the always witty and often ingenious lyrics by the show’s creator Max Vernon, but also to have the divide made visible in the choreography by Al Blackstone, who juxtaposes '70s groove and 2017 posing in hilarious ways…While moving the show along at a swift pace, director Scott Ebersold manages to make us truly care about its characters…A most original piece of musical theater that is not to be missed." Full Review
"Vernon’s musical uses the tragedies of the past to highlight the mistakes of the future...Scott Ebersold has directed this production to feel intimate, ensuring each of the characters have their time to shine and connect with the audience...Drama, music and lyrics are combined to create a thrilling experience...'The View UpStairs' is a magical, moving production that provokes important debates and a feeling of camaraderie." Full Review
"Fun, fresh, and super exciting. This is the kind of music you can't wait to hear again as soon as you walk out of the theater. Aside from such an emotional story told by an extremely good composer, this show is brimming with talent. Enter Nathan Lee Graham, whose vocals are so good you might want to consider bringing something to fan yourself with. The glorious set is also a highlight of this show as you can see in the photos...Go enjoy this very fun night at the theater!" Full Review
"In the midst of its heavy subject matter, the tear-jerking and thought-provoking moments, 'The View UpStairs' is filled with humor...Vernon has succeeded in creating a musical that is authentic, funny, and deeply resonant. No one can leave the theatre untouched. Along with its vibrant and emotional tones, it is a show that sparks discussion about unsung heroes, queer history, and LGBTQ movements...A genius musical that gives us an opportunity to utilize the past in creating our future." Full Review
"Vernon expresses social insight well beyond his years...Vernon’s forte is his score which illuminates both the vibrancy and nuance of the spectrum in his character’s lives and emotions. A similar finesse would serve his book well also, raising its sometimes heavy-handed catch phrases and preachy dialogue up to the same level...What could easily veer into stereotypes and 'been there, seen that' is thoughtfully guided under the sensitive direction of Scott Ebersold." Full Review
"This fast-moving and highly engaging one-act musical turns history into fantasy and then brings it all back to reality in a meaningful way...The score is exceptional...but the cast is equally good and the storytelling is vivid and not at all preachy or didactic. As far as star turns go, you’d have to travel a long way before you find a performance to equal that of Nathan Lee Graham." Full Review
See it if great songs from a promising new musical writer, w/ some great over-the-top performances in a story that reveals some important gay history.
Don't see it if an annoying framing structure that inserts a modern twist into the more interesting gay historical part of the story is bothersome to you.
See it if You want to see a great set and see a couple of good performances (in an ill-conceived show)
Don't see it if You need a realistic (or even remotely believable) plot. Also, several of the performers were really disappointing.
See it if You’d like a glimpse of gay bars and life in a pre-AIDS world; wit, camp & community contrasting with our isolated smart phone present.
Don't see it if You're completely homophobic can't suspend disbelief, don't like smart musicals sparkly lights or camp with serious intent under the glitter
See it if You will appreciate an awesome set, true stories about the LGBT experience, performed with well written songs, by characters with heart.
Don't see it if LGBT themed shows aren't of interest & 1 hr 40 minutes without an intermission isn't your cup of tea, for today, because it is closing 5/21.
See it if You want to be entertained for two hours and have your own jaded modern sensibility torn away for a bit.
Don't see it if You can't overlook the message being pushed a bit too hard. You have floor seating and don't like being interacted with.
See it if you are a fan of LGBT history. They weave a modern story with historical fiction. The songs are great.
Don't see it if you are not in the mood for something thought provoking or fun. Because this show combines drama and comedy.
See it if you're into LGBTQ themes, gay history (stories inspired by real events), and immersive theatre.
Don't see it if you can't stand it when a theme bludgeons you over the head. The writing is super heavy-handed. No subtlety. Loud and proud, I guess.
See it if you don't mind some seriously boring lectures with your fun drag show.
Don't see it if you're looking for a coherent or moving gay fantasia. The cast is wildly uneven, songs are forgettable, story is muddled. Swing and a miss.
See it if you like gay history with a musical flair. A talented cast brings an overlooked tragedy to light with humor and pathos. Original & winning.
Don't see it if you believe in conversion therapy.
See it if you have to see every LGBT-related show playing in the city. However this one is not worth seeing.
Don't see it if just don't waste your time. There is nothing really enjoyable about this show except a cool set. Book and singing are poor.
See it if you want a little show that can. When its on target, it explodes with wit and enchantment. Serious at times.Nathan Lee Graham is amazing.
Don't see it if don't like in your face, Literally in your face, shows about the gay life with many cliched characters.
See it if you like imaginative set design & lighting effects. Compared to the Public Theater's 'Gently Down the Stream' this is a real disappointment.
Don't see it if you don't have comp tickets.
See it if A tribute to lives lost in New Orleans Upstairs Lounge fire, Orlando Pulse massacre, and recent Oakland Ghost Ship fire is in your heart.
Don't see it if A portrayal of true to life characters just before lives were lost is too poignant.
See it if you are interested in a community of LGBT people who are funny, brave, and full of life, despite the horrors they experience with a tragedy.
Don't see it if are uncomfortable with LGBT issues. Yet, as a human being, you can certainly relate to the joys/csorrows the LGBT characters experience.GO!
See it if Campy humor, gay history, energetic. Fun-house set and a few polished performers.
Don't see it if A revue of second-rate songs about the gay community with an unconvincing story and cliche characters to hold it together.
See it if you want to see a new off-Broadway musical. This show is worth seeing for the fabulous set design and talented actors.
Don't see it if you don't like shows that try too hard or take the easy way out. This show uses "funny" quips to avoid facing the uncomfortable.
See it if you enjoy musical theatre that is on the amateurish level. The actors work hard, but they are let down by an awful book.
Don't see it if you like a strong book and strong songs to carry the evening. This show does not have either.
See it if fun music, campy comedy, deeply-touching & historical scripts touch your heart. Teared-up 5x w/reminders of long-gone friends & loved-ones.
Don't see it if you want perfection & you don't have a feeling-bone in your body. It's not perfect, the 4th wall's obliterated, but it gives you a huge hug.
Get alerts about your favorite artists and theater companies