for a previous production “This folk musical looked and sounded great on its rough-hewed set. If it had been a concert instead, the company couldn’t have done better, filling the house with richly layered strings and gorgeous vocals. The six musicians, who also make up the cast, were terrific...But the vitality that marks every musical moment evaporates between songs.” Full Review
for a previous production "Elliah Heifetz has given this historical fantasy an all-American sound with his rousing folk score...This stellar cast delivers every number with commitment and heart, leading us to gladly suspend our disbelief. Director Srda Vasiljevic employs them as actor-musicians in the style of John Doyle, making this not just the most talented cast of the festival, but also the best band. Just try not to get goosebumps." Full Review
for a previous production "It's definitely conflict-rich content, but for a short, taut one act. Stretching it across more than two hours makes it painfully repetitive and obvious early and often. It doesn't matter if the down-home songs are attractive or emotionally astute...With the exception of Hinkes, the cast members all do well at laying bare their characters' tortured souls. And the production is lively enough to keep you engaged. Not enough to keep you invested, however." Full Review
for a previous production "The book is solid, but could use some fleshing out. The music is totally along the country folk vein and two hours of it is too much for me, but seems to please the downtown younger set…This entire company plays extremely well and starts and end as a band of musicians…The direction by Srda Vasiljevic keeps the piece moving…I would get this show down to 90 minutes as it drags in places, but I can see 'Dust Can’t Kill Me' playing downtown and all around the country." Full Review
for a previous production "The cast is uniformly talented with remarkable vocal and acting skills as well as being accomplished instrumentalists and dancers...Elliah Heifetz’s music and lyrics are engaging and enchanting...There are still some difficulties with the book, especially in the second act...Still a work in progress and, having seen its 'incarnation' in 2014, this reviewer looks forward to seeing its grace-laden apotheosis in the very near future.” Full Review
for a previous production "Vasiljevic revitalized the story of lost souls wandering in the 1936 Dust Bowl by adding a John Doyle-esque framing device which sees the actors not only playing their own instruments, but also being hyper-aware of the fact they’re playing characters...Vasiljevic allows each of his actors to embody the traits that best identify their characters...It’s Kathryn Gallagher as Lily who gives the show’s most ferocious, unforgettable performance." Full Review
See it if exquisite folk singing, great musicians (unnecessarily) modern dancers. Special shout out to Garth Taylor (next stop broadway!)
Don't see it if if you don't like cabaret seating (long tables for 8) & 2-drink minimums
See it if Interested in Children of Eden meets Bright Star*. To support young, talented actor-musicians. *see Bright Star review.
Don't see it if Annoyed by a muddy sound mix that drowns out lyrics. Want songs that move a plot, not a plot mashed together to justify songs.
See it if you enjoy catchy folk songs performed by talented singers and musicians. Really great score! *Saw the concert version*
Don't see it if you prefer more classic show-tunes. This show has the potential to be heavily stylized. *Saw the concert version*
See it if you revel in exquisite folk music played with energy and emotion.
Don't see it if You need a complex plot; the plot appears to be there mostly to motivate the music.
See it if you like high octane folk music set in the Dustbowl 1930s with fantasy storyline, moshpit 'ography, & excellent performances,
Don't see it if you don't like folk/rock, need a realistic storyline, feel endangered by dancers popping out of audience, don't want 2 item food/bar/minimum
See it if you enjoy folk music or want to watch a show in the early stages of its development.
Don't see it if you're looking for something polished. Don't get me wrong, this show has a lot of potential. It's just not there yet.
See it if you like-Once-country/bluegrass/folk music-stories from the heartland-musical dramas-recital/concert format
Don't see it if you want-a lighthearted musical/play. don't like-actors playing instruments
See it if you like singer-songwriter type folk music (this is not twangy or bluegrass-y). You like stories that take you away.
Don't see it if You want very realistic stories (this feels like a folk tale in a really great way).
See it if you appreciate the finest in musical theater. Original and even though it isn't the kind of music I typically enjoy, I was overwhelmed.
Don't see it if You're adverse to seeing great shows before they appear on a stage like The Public Theatre. Clearly that's it's next stop.
See it if you like bluegrass music enough to overlook that this is a concept album that's yet to figure out a workable script or believable characters
Don't see it if you'll be bothered by a script that feels shoehorned around songs (some gorgeous, others forgettable) and that tells more than it shows
See it if you love country music. You'd like to see a diverse cast of "sinners" who were left out of shows like Bright Star. Fantastic score.
Don't see it if you hate actors playing instruments. The second act drags for plot reasons. Might work better with stronger, older actors. Abstract lyrics.
See it if you want to see a near-perfect and interesting musical with inventive staging and distinct and compelling songs and singing.
Don't see it if you do not like plots that mention religion, gay themes, or minimal sets. It converted me to liking bluegrass, and has memorable music.
See it if you like musicals that pull from other music genres and stray from a traditional Broadway feel
Don't see it if You don't like folk-type shows or slightly cliched story lines that feel more like a classic novel than a new-age musical
See it if Soaring bluegrass harmonies make your heart melt, nd if you're a fan of shows such as Bright Star.
Don't see it if You're looking for a clear, easy to follow plot.
See it if If you like folk/ bluegrass music, this is a must-see. The cast is incredibly talented and they all play their own instruments.
Don't see it if You don't like folk/bluegrass music and or you are uncomfortable with the following topics: death, homosexuality and mixed race couples.
See it if You like bluegrass music, multitalented actors/musicians (Kathryn and Elizabeth kill it), you want a unique theater going experience
Don't see it if you hate country music, there's a lot of it, and if you need a very clear/straightforward plot
See it if you love alternative theater. Folk inspired score with a great cast- Kathryn Gallagher is awesome. Original approach to Dust Bowl story.
Don't see it if you are turned off by actors playing instruments or folk musicals.
See it if You like intimate shows with gorgeous folk/Americana music, performed and sung by an impressive cast.
Don't see it if You want a little more meat on the bones of the plot. The story is okay, but it's really the music and singing that's memorable.