If/Then (Gallery Players) NYC Reviews and Tickets

See it if you would like to hear a powerhouse lead vocalist or to see a show about how little choices can have a big impact on your life.

Don't see it if you have hearing issues — the live band overpowers the un-mic'd actors. Some jokes are outdated, especially those about bisexuality.

See it if Interesting, unusual premise, tuneful music, outstanding leading lady. Chance to see a rarely performed show.

Don't see it if A little repetitive and doesn't gather dramatic momentum.

See it if Clever and inventive book which considers the choices and possibilities one has in life

Don't see it if Show can be confusing and needs a good cast to pull off the turns that occur in story.

See it if You would like to see a show with a complex premise. The acting was great, and the story was interesting.

Don't see it if The music isn't memorable and its hard to keep track of which "What if" the lead is in. The nature of the structure lead to some repetition

See it if You like small minimalist musical productions about the paths not taken and limitless possibilities among a group of 40 yr old friends

Don't see it if 2-1/2 hrs is too long to sit , the sound quality was so poor you miss a lot of the words . It doesn’t quite nail it like Next to Normal

See it if Enjoyable community theatre of this big musical with some iconic shoes to fill. Kudos to Megan Hasse in the lead role of Elizabeth.

Don't see it if While this was an ambitious musical to take on, few in the cast stood out…but hats off to this local company for attempting. Read more

See it if you like new musicals set in the present that explore relations among friends & the different directions that they can go. Good cast effort.

Don't see it if you need perfection-this is a tough show for community theater with many scene changes. Cast needed to have microphones or more projection.

See it if With a cast of 12 actors n 4 musicians there were a lot things happening and the music overpowered the singing. The original music was good.

Don't see it if U were looking to compare the original casts, with the trying, it’s not there. Yes, we all had the moments of the choices we made thru lifes