Southern Promises NYC Reviews and Tickets

“Bradshaw blurs the line between deliberate artlessness and accidental ineptness to such a degree that it’s hard to tell if the dialogue is meant to be as bland and clunky as it often is...He isn’t interested in complex psychologizing, and the people onstage often make no sense...The actors are ill-equipped to handle the play’s tricky tone...But Mr. Bradshaw’s flatness is also free of judgment, which does not give characters or the audience any easy way out."
Read more

“There are still elements of brutality in this revival, but they are mitigated by director Smith's inert production...The Bats are a company of young volunteer performers, and Smith has not been able to curtail the overacting that comes naturally with such a troupe...Smith's staging is surprisingly sluggish considering how Bradshaw writes in short, staccato scenes...The completely changed ending is also stronger in how it portrays the persistent allure of exploitation."
Read more

"Set in the antebellum on a slave plantation, the lines between masters and slaves should be clearly defined in Bradshaw's melodrama in which rape, infanticide, murder, torture and lynching all play a part in the highly charged events. In Smith's production, one has to keep reminding one's self who the white and black characters are meant to be which turns the play into a sort of PC charade. Visually we are not seeing what we are told we are witnessing."
Read more

“Bradshaw’s play is provocative and upsetting...The way that Bradshaw details slavery's horror makes it utterly hopeless...The production is relentless. Every actor in this ensemble is fearless and unapologetic as they tell a story that is obviously very personal to them...Smith brilliantly creates a Brechtian sensibility to remind us that what we are watching is just a play...Bradshaw’s script is so dark and hopeless...And yet...Deep down, I understand that it is necessary.”
Read more

"The show does not let up. There is no intermission and no mercy...The text of the show points out that many of us have heritages that are all mixed up – African and European ancestors decorate most of our trees simultaneously. Our pasts are not blameless. The cast of this show is only people of color to drive the point further to your marrow...Go see this show. It will open your heart to a conversation that should be had out loud."
Read more

“The Bats and Niegel Smith the director have altered the script and for the most part the play is better, however the moments of over acting and the plodding staging makes this play dull. With rape, miscegenation, infanticide, lynching and complete human mistreatment this play should have grabbed our attention...What is smart is Jason Sherwood’s set...Oddly Smith and sound designer have set each scene to classic rock, in which the actors dance to.”
Read more

“It’s unsettling to watch the play...This revised version of ‘Southern Promises’ is like a mini-'Roots,' going beyond the systemic racism that has been America’s shame for four hundred years to reveal how the concept of race and its power corrupts even the seemingly most well meaning of people. The night I attended, an awkward, uneasy moment at the curtain call uncovered society’s continuing pain...This country still has a lot of work to do.”
Read more

“I’m not convinced that ‘Southern Promises’ is a revival that accomplishes anything more than theatrical shocks...This play speaks frankly and roughly throughout...There are moments that are memorable. There are definitely scenes that are shocking, as intended. Without a consistent tone, the subject matter gets diluted and grinds to an anticlimactic finish. This revival does not make a case for the play as important as the troubled history it wants us to aggressively confront.”
Read more