Already closed

The Suitcase Under the Bed

Members say: Great acting, Entertaining, Dated, Absorbing, Great writing
76
Critics
75
23 reviews
Members
76
136 reviews
 

The Mint Theater Company presents four short plays (including three world premieres) by late Irish dramatist Teresa Deevy.

... Read more

Although Deevy is now recognized as a significant Irish playwright, her work was neglected for decades. Six of her plays were produced by the Abbey Theatre between 1930 and 1936, and then Deevy's theater career effectively ended. 'The Suitcase Under the Bed' is named for the place where all of her writing was stored for decades, prior to the launch of the Mint's 'Deevy Project.' Another name for this evening of playlets might be 'Three Proposals and a Break-up,' as these shorts cast an unsentimental eye on the idea of marriage.

 

Cast & Creatives (14)


Reviews (159)

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
75
Avg Score

80
The New York Times

'Birth' is perhaps more benign to its protagonist than any of the evening’s other plays, and given Adair’s sensible yet magnetic Sara, it seems only fair...In ‘Holiday House,’ the open-ended conclusion is unsettling...Deaver, impressive in her previous roles of the evening, soars in ‘King of Spain’s Daughter’...Varga's costumes and Shaw’s gentle sound design reflect a rich understanding of the era, as does Bank’s assured direction. He clearly adores Deevy, and ultimately so will the audience." Full Review

65
Theatermania

"While Bank didn't strike gold for the Mint with this particular discovery, there are some definite moments of luster...The first two pieces are charming, sentimental, and just a bit boring in that way mediocre Irish plays tend to be...'Holiday House' sparkles with wit and intrigue...'King of Spain's Daughter' leaves us unsettled and impressed...One of the Mint's goals is to highlight overlooked female playwrights, and with this somewhat sleepy and mismatched evening, it partially succeeds." Full Review

80
BroadwayWorld

“The evening starts strong, thanks to the spunky and endearing performance of Ellen Adair as Sara Meade, the central character of ‘Strange Birth’…As a collection, the plays of ‘The Suitcase Under the Bed’ reveals a community of stories that hide beneath the unremarkable façade of everyday life. The charming, well-acted evening makes one hope the Mint has even more from the Deevy collection to remove from storage.” Full Review

85
Lighting & Sound America

"A sterling quartet of one-acts...Deevy specializes in a kind of plainspoken poetry that packs plenty of feeling, mixed with barbed wit, into her characters' economical exchanges...Bank's staging is filled with little details that speak volumes...In a cast loaded with graceful performances, the biggest impression is arguably made by Deaver in a trio of roles...One is amazed that this fine playwright was allowed to slip into obscurity for so long." Full Review

60
Broadway Blog

“The slightest…is the first play, 'Strange Birth'...a pleasantly articulated sketch given several appealing performances…In 'In the Cellar of My Friend'…neither Bank's direction nor the actors' efforts can prevent the plot's development from seeming clumsy…'Holiday House' is a mild drawing-room comedy à la Noël Coward…Whatever…potential is present fails to ignite; almost as soon as we grasp the setup the play ends…'The King of Spain's Daughter' is perhaps the most serious of the plays.” Full Review

60
Time Out New York

"Director Jonathan Bank and his company shine in the collection’s dramatic installments...But the pace falters in 'Strange Birth,' a sweet but slight rom-com, and 'Holiday House,' a Noël Coward–esque comedy that droops where it should skip. In the Mint’s production, Deevy’s work feels old-fashioned in a way that is both comforting and a little sleepy. But she wrote with gently cutting wit and had a keen ear for dialogue." Full Review

80
The Huffington Post

"In selecting these pieces, Bank reports that he wanted to find continuity. It’s a wise approach, and one that seems to have led him to a profoundly universal theme: troubled love...If pressed to declare my favorite among them—not necessarily a crucial need—I’d say the first...With Davis supplying attractive sets and Varga finding the right costumes for the various across-the-strata characters, Deevy’s need to be recalled and honored is indisputably achieved." Full Review

80
Front Row Center

"Though the plays span several different working classes, from wealthy vacationers to hardscrabble laborers, there are consistencies to be found...In 'Strange Birth,' Costigan, as Mrs. Stims, shines the brightest...'In the Cellar of My Friend' is the weakest of the batch...A dark and meaty tragedy, 'The King of Spain’s Daughter,' closes out the night...Redmond, a powerhouse throughout the night, brings a palpable sense of danger to this role." Full Review

80
Times Square Chronicles

"Well directed by Jonathan Bank with a stellar cast...This was a night of nostalgia and days gone by...The first of the four, 'Strange Birth,' was also the best...I have long been a fan of Shively’s work and this just reinforced it...For her time Deevy is to be admired...It is lovely to go back and see what shaped our world in a time when life was much simpler." Full Review

80
CurtainUp

"The production has been effectively organized...To help Mr. Bank achieve this fluidity, a big bravo to the seven fine actors who play 22 characters...'Strange Birth' makes for a lighthearted little romantic sketch...Though the tempest in this teapot won't come to a full boil, Deevy's 'Holiday House' script has the out-of-joint feelings simmering subtly with some very sharp and character-defining dialogue...A tastefully presented four-course menu." Full Review

60
TheaterScene.net

“Exquisitely produced by the Mint Theater, Jonathan Bank's direction is leisurely and slow, which undercuts the theatricality of all but the last and the most satisfying one, ‘The King of Spain's Daughter,’ originally given four separate stage productions at the Abbey from 1935-1939 and two in London in 1939...Two of the plays end too abruptly calling out for a more substantial length, while one of the plays seems to go on too long.” Full Review

65
Gotham Playgoer

"I did not find any of them fully satisfying...'Strange Birth' is little more than a brief character sketch…'In the Cellar of My Friend' was the most self-contained piece, but the characters were cliched and the situation unconvincing...'The King of Spain’s Daughter' is grittier than the others, but the relationships among the characters were confusing. The production is admirable. The cast of seven is strong...One of the main pleasures of the evening is to see them play multiple roles." Full Review

55
Woman Around Town

"'Strange Birth,' the most successful of the four, is a delicate play about the vicissitudes of love...‘Holiday House’ is a genteel drawing-room attempt that telegraphs future events early on...The piece seems like Act I of an unfinished play...Two well-performed entr’acte poems are recited in front of the curtain...Redmond breathes vibrant life into every character he inhabits...The evening is disappointing. Deevy had a reason to store these under her bed." Full Review

85
Wolf Entertainment Guide

"Deevy was very perceptive in creating her characters and placing them in environments that dictate challenges...All directed by Jonathan Bank with precise understanding of Deevy’s work...It is intriguing to see how the playwright pays special attention to the problems of women in the various settings...The plays are just long enough to hold our attention without overstaying their welcome...Bank’s cast members come through in grand form." Full Review

80
Theatre is Easy

"Bank smartly chose four pieces that play off each other well, forming a cohesive evening...Deevy's cynical viewpoints feel very modern...Bank takes his time, allowing Deevy's insightful dialogue to sink in, but this is somewhat of a liability in 'Holiday House,' which could move at a faster pace to bring out the comedy more. Still, kudos to Bank for bringing Deevy's work to New York audiences. The playwright was also deaf, which makes preserving her voice even more important." Full Review

60
TheaterScene.com

“It’s hard to believe Bank couldn’t come up with a more compelling curtain-raiser than the barely there ‘Strange Birth’…Happily, there’s more substance, and greater enjoyment, to be had in ‘Holiday House,’ the evening’s only out-and-out comedy…Banks’s direction is, to put it mildly, leisurely, with dialogue pauses in all four playlets that you could drive a lorry through…Whatever qualities the Mint perceives in Deevy’s oeuvre, these one-acts are a highly variable lot.” Full Review

70
Village Voice

"An illuminating program of four short plays...None are revealed as lost masterpieces, yet all reflect Deevy’s sensitive style of oblique realism and her substantially intriguing female characters...'The King of Spain’s Daughter'...is the strongest drama...Seven actors competently depict various characters...A playwright whose subtle stories about everyday people at times suggest Chekhov spoken with an Irish brogue." Full Review

85
Show Showdown

“Overall, the cast is excellent, and I imagine they must have a blast playing all their roles, particularly Deaver, who gets to play three distinctly different and fascinating women and does so beautifully. Also outstanding is Mace, who takes four relatively small parts and makes them distinct and textured and real…And Bank's direction pulled everything together expertly, giving us a wonderful sense of Deevy's great skill and compassion and a first-class evening in the theatre.” Full Review

80
Theater Pizzazz

"Four short plays, each a miniature masterpiece of character, and each performed with insight by a skillful ensemble cast...Deevy’s dialog is taut and efficient, yet remains lyrical, covering the full emotional range of the human condition. Her plotting is often deceptively simple, but it’s Deevy’s insights into the Irish character that are the most telling...The ensemble cast of six actors earnestly cover the gamut, excelling in character differentiation, with mostly successful results." Full Review

90
The Clyde Fitch Report

"A delectable and delicate vaudeville...Six performers stretch their acting, singing and wig-wearing chops...But Mace’s work in this evening of repertory constitutes the spine of the evening...It’s resonant stagecraft without being domineering; it’s a study in evoking full characterizations with small moves and distinct dialect work...The wonder of the evening also comes from the fact that these gems do deserve to live in the light of day...Whatever you do, go see this production." Full Review

90
Philadelphia Inquirer

"Four lovely one-acts...An evening rich in human nature: love and longing and desperation and danger and disappointment, all embodied in these delicate vignettes, so charming, so full of surprises and of insight. Like a quick-sketch artist, Deevy creates character right before our eyes...We are helped in our imaginings by this pitch-perfect cast, who can shift from role to role and become nearly unrecognizable from play to play." Full Review

85
Off Off Online

"Deevy offers brief snapshots into colorful lives, and the playwright fleshes out her characters and the complex crossroads they find themselves at clearly and succinctly within each play’s pleasurably quick running time...The pared-down production is aided by its aesthetics...The versatile cast, too, helps to infuse life into Deevy’s gentle works...Ultimately, however, it’s Deevy’s words that take center stage...These long-unseen plays deserve their chance to shine." Full Review

80
Talkin' Broadway

"These seven actors play a total of 22 roles during the course of evening, each performance beautifully etched and well delineated...Deevy's writing consistently displays a wonderful facility for dialogue and an ability to get under the skin of her characters, along with the intermittent liability that some of her plot devices and situations strain credulity...Bank has helped the actors achieve jewel-like performances, and his blocking is skillfully economic." Full Review

See: Critics' Reviews | Members' Reviews
76
Avg Score

73
Subtle, Gentile, Chariming

See it if you like very old plays re-staged. Four short plays portray life in a bygone era. Very good acting a plus.

Don't see it if don't like subtle love stories.

78
Absorbing, Ambitious, Thought-provoking, Disappointing, Entertaining

See it if you like to explore the lost plays of the past; generally if you like shows at the Mint you will probably be interested in anything they do

Don't see it if you need all the acting to reach the same level; or if you only want to see revivals of masterpieces

Also Not all of the performances were up to the quality I'm used to here; s... Read more Read less

75
Absorbing, Great acting, Quirky, Dated

See it if you like short plays with interesting characters in various unusual situations and relationships.

Don't see it if you prefer a well developed story with characters who you come to know slowly throughout the show.

100
Absorbing, Clever, Enchanting, Great acting, Great writing

See it if you are a fan of the unexpected twist> The mint's selection of plays, as always, is right on the mark. Love it

Don't see it if you aren't interested by at least one of the following topics: love; relationships; Irish culture; old plays; Mint productions

70
Mixed, four short plays

See it if You like short plays. Two out of four are good (the first two). Well staged, interesting, thought provoking. The Mint always does well.

Don't see it if If you want one story.

Also Support The Mint. They produce forgotten plays that are worth reviving... Read more Read less

71
Intelligent, Quirky, Overrated, Entertaining

See it if You like Irish playwrights and themes, enjoy one acts and light Chekhovian sketches of characters and ensemble acting.in obscure material.

Don't see it if You want sustained narrative or complete plays as opposed to character sketches.

73
Slow, Dated, Fluffy

See it if you care to see the forgotten works of a 20th century female Irish playwright.

Don't see it if you're impatient or easily bored.

77
Absorbing, Great acting, Lovely, Quaint, Sleepy

See it if you enjoy slow moving cryptic interesting shorts

Don't see it if you want your questions answered or are looking for resolution

75
Great acting, Charming, well written, enjoyable

See it if you want to see world premiers of short stories by the forgotten playwright Teresa Deevy about the positive and negative effects of love.

Don't see it if you don't like multi short plays performed in one evening about love as told through the eyes of a 1930's Irish woman's prospective.

70
Ambitious, Banal, Dated

See it if You have a fondness for Irish drama and want to discover an almost unremembered dramatist

Don't see it if If you expect any of the four plays to be more than character sketches

80
Dated, Entertaining, Great staging

See it if You enjoy seeing productions of seldom-seen works that have fallen into obscurity but deserve to be better known.

Don't see it if You have low tolerance for shows that are slightly dated

75
Mixed bag. unfinished. quirky. good acting. worth seeing.

See it if You are interested in Deevy's work and the Mint Theatre's mission. You want to see some good performances by actors playing multiple roles.

Don't see it if You want satisfying, complete plays, all of which work.

Also I am a fan of the Mint's mission. I know Deevy is one of their major r... Read more Read less

60
Banal, Disappointing, Slow, Dated

See it if you can look beyond the amateur feel of this, the accents, the wigs, the stories...

Don't see it if you want a witty, moving Irish play. These short plays are slow and boring. Way too much standing and staring, didn't seem real at all

Also I think there was a reason these were in a suitcase under a bed.

85
Funny, Delightful, Great writing, Dated

See it if You enjoy one-act plays and exploring works of little-known playwrights.

Don't see it if You don't enjoy period pieces or Irish humor.

50
Indulgent, Banal, Cliched, Insipid, Dated

See it if you love old-fashioned, dated theater. Want to see something with a box set at a community theater level.

Don't see it if you want to see something interesting, daring or thought provoking.

Also I was so hopeful that I would love this. From all the marketing materi... Read more Read less

94
Absorbing, Delightful, Great acting, Refreshing, Great writing

See it if You are excited about the discovery of a "lost" playwright. If you are a fan of Chekhov, Ireland & intimate, funny, heart-breaking moments.

Don't see it if You are expecting "Cats". Or if you have a TV attention span. (though, these are 4 1-act plays, so something new every 1/2 hour!)

Also The actors really get to shine here and show their versatility, since ... Read more Read less

90
Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Masterful, Great staging

See it if you enjoy great acting, and period dramas... an evening of subtle beauty.

Don't see it if you can't appreciate a world that moved on a much slower pace.

85
Funny, Clever, Quirky, Great writing, Dated

See it if You are in the mod for short pieces that are both funny and sad, you are keen on seeing little hidden gems, you like to see the woman's POV

Don't see it if You like only contemporary works and themes, you prefer a single story line in your evening of theater

Also So typical of Irish playwrights, these 4 one-act plays are funny and s... Read more Read less

80
Great acting, Romantic, Great writing

See it if You enjoy Irish plays, short plays and ensemble acting.

Don't see it if You don't like revivals of old plays, or period dramas.

Also This is my introduction to Theresa Deevy and the Mint Theater. The fou... Read more Read less

80
Clever, Entertaining, Nostalgic, Great realism, Substantial

See it if If you like stories linked to the same theme, playing different characters at different times. Someone is coming, leaving and moving.

Don't see it if You don't like the period dramas.

73
Absorbing, Clever, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Entertaining

See it if would have liked longer versions of each play.

Don't see it if you don't like irish plays

92
Absorbing, Thought-provoking, Profound, Relevant

See it if You want to see what life was like in Ireland for a woman in the '30s. Four absorbing one act plays that are fodder for after show talk

Don't see it if you think you'd find it dated or talky.

Also Unpublished. Discovered in a suitcase under a bed after the writer's d... Read more Read less

91
Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Entertaining

See it if you like great acting, sets etc by the ever reliable Mint Theater This was our 2nd viewing and we liked it even more.

Don't see it if you only like full length plays. Each of the 4 are well done but do not match the writer's other 3 full length works done by the Mint

75
Insightful, Ambitious, Interesting, Slight, Worthwhile

See it if You like obscure plays that you have never seen a production of, and probably won't have another opportunity to do so.

Don't see it if You like earth-shaking theatre rather than quiet and incisive theatre.

75
During previews
Ambitious, Thought-provoking, Entertaining, Slow at times

See it if you enjoy plays that provide interesting slices of Irish life; some themes were more eye-opening than pleasant, yet ring true.

Don't see it if you don't enjoy one-act plays that can may seem like fragments without a clear start or end; or you prefer more action

Also I found this set of plays mostly enjoyable (the second act was my leas... Read more Read less