Already closed | 2h 0m | East Village

You And I

From 13 member  reviews
Members say: Great acting, Delightful, Intelligent, Entertaining, Absorbing

About the show

Metropolitan Playhouse presents a revival of the first Broadway hit by the author of "The Philadelphia Story," the story of a middle-aged man who is haunted by dreams of the artistic career he forswore at 20. More…

Matey White lives an enviable, secure, conventional life with his wife Nancy and their two children. When he determines to take a leave from business and pick up a paintbrush--just as gifted son Ricky determines to giving up his own ambitions so he may marry the girl next door,  a turn in the markets squeezes the family's resources. The Whites must face decisions they thought they'd put behind them—this time, without the naïve confidence of youth. 

Member Reviews (13)


Great acting, Delightful, Intelligent, Entertaining, Absorbing
Avg Score

Ambitious, Great writing, Great staging, Slow

See it if If you want a period piece that is classic in time. Conflict of two generations.

Don't see it if If you want a modern piece or a faster paced production.

Period costumes, Intimate set, Nice ensemble acting

See it if Love, work, income, property, family, passion, education, economic conditions, all in conflict for two generations living in the 1920s.

Don't see it if You prefer the fast pace of modern plays over the steady deliberateness of a classic drama.

Sweet / charming / intelligent / humorous banter / entertaining, Intimate theater / very creative set / good costumes, Classic / nicely written / well-performed (era-stylized)

See it if you'd like to see a somewhat enchanting early 20th century period-piece. Well-written, visually stylized (set, costumes) & well-performed.

Don't see it if you prefer an epic magnanimous boffo production. It's a lovely night out @ the theater, in a great old venue, listening to pretty dialogue.

Also The location adds to experience.... Read more Read less

Charming, Uplifting

See it if U enjoy this type of drawing room com/drama that doesn't dig too deep but entertains & uses a large cast to bring in some colorful character

Don't see it if You don't care for plays where everyone is nice and things all work out for the best.

Also There is something very comfortable about the Metropolitan Theater. I ... Read more Read less

Witty, Moving, Great acting, Romantic, Profound

See it if you enjoy classic American theater and a chance to see a rarely performed play by an unrelated playwright.

Don't see it if you prefer contemporary plays or lavish productions.

Also Considering the off-off-Broadway production, the acting is of a very h... Read more Read less

Tha actors shine & there are joys to be had in this rather run-of-the-mill play ...

See it if you want to experience this production's skillful rendering of gentle & heartfelt characters. This aspect of Barry's writing glows here.

Don't see it if seeing less than perfect plays would burden you.

Great acting, Great staging, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if Enjoy intimate performances in small theatre and great acting. Revival of early 20th century play but still relevant.

Don't see it if You prefer big broadway productions or musicals.

Absorbing, Masterful, Great acting

See it if It's an early 20th century family drama performed by amazing actors. A very, very good play with difficult characters.

Don't see it if Not interested to go to an Off Off Broadway theater which is in an old house that only adds to the feel of the play.

Sweet, Charming, Intelligent

See it if you like enchanting early 20th century period-pieces. It's well-written and well-performed.

Don't see it if seeing a work in progress burden you.

Clever, Delightful, Entertaining, Enchanting, Absorbing

See it if An early 20th century play, well acted and amusing, that asks whether you should give up art for love or vice versa and the consequences

Don't see it if Play is standard three-act drama so if you are looking for an edgy play this is not for you

Delightful, Great acting, Entertaining

See it if You enjoy lovingly-resurrected classics from another era. You appreciate thoughtful staging, witty dialogue, and acting with nuance & heart.

Don't see it if You prefer Broadway spectacles. Metropolitan is for those who can appreciate the magic of creative stagecraft executed on a limited budget.

Delightful, Great acting, Enchanting

See it if You like older shows, that still find relevance to contemporary audiences.

Don't see it if If you're looking for something flashy.

Also I went into the show assuming I wouldn't enjoy it, considering I prefe... Read more Read less

During previews
Entertaining, Great acting, Great writing, Intelligent, Delightful

See it if you enjoy a refreshing, clever, riveting, well-crafted play, in a very intimate theater where you feel you are in the room with the actors.

Don't see it if you only enjoy musicals or large productions.

Also This is one of the best plays produced by Alex Roe, Artistic Director ... Read more Read less

September 18th, 2018
“Under the skilled direction of Hardart, a cast with a solid understanding of period style captures the complex notes of Barry's style...Not a brilliant work, ‘You and I’ is nevertheless engaging throughout, and, in its ironic is surprisingly moving. It also stands on its own in its c...
read more
September 14th, 2018
"Under Hardart's uncertain direction, 'You and I' emerges as a footnote to a notable career, a good-natured but vapid drawing-room comedy whose chief interest lies in how Barry spun so many autobiographical threads into it...It's a sweet play; truly...Love and warmth permeate the stage, every cha...
read more
September 17th, 2018
"This would be fine if the artificial style of the play and the dated twenties slang did not seem arch and affected. And while director Michael Hardart's production is always stylish and graceful, he has not helped greatly with his casting or his mannered and theatrical approach to the material. ...
read more
September 14th, 2018
"Barry's play would need a far more polished and well-cast company…than presently assembled…to give its dated-sounding dialogue…stagy characters, and plot contrivances the fire they desperately require…Hardart has helped them convey some of their roles' shifting nuances but…they're unable to make...
read more

Related content