You And I
84

You And I NYC Reviews and Tickets

84%
(13 Reviews)
Positive
100%
Mixed
0%
Negative
0%
Members say
Great acting, Delightful, Intelligent, Entertaining, Absorbing

About the Show

Metropolitan Playhouse presents a revival of the first Broadway hit by the author of "The Philadelphia Story," the story of a middle-aged man who is haunted by dreams of the artistic career he forswore at 20.

Read more Show less

Member Reviews (13)

Sort by:
  • Default
  • Standing in our community
  • Highest first
  • Lowest first
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Only positive
  • Only negative
  • Only mixed
983 Reviews | 229 Followers
76
Ambitious, Great writing, Great staging, Slow

See it if If you want a period piece that is classic in time. Conflict of two generations.

Don't see it if If you want a modern piece or a faster paced production.

411 Reviews | 72 Followers
76
Period costumes, Intimate set, Nice ensemble acting

See it if Love, work, income, property, family, passion, education, economic conditions, all in conflict for two generations living in the 1920s.

Don't see it if You prefer the fast pace of modern plays over the steady deliberateness of a classic drama.

297 Reviews | 78 Followers
75
Sweet / charming / intelligent / humorous banter / entertaining, Intimate theater / very creative set / good costumes, Classic / nicely written / well-performed (era-stylized)

See it if you'd like to see a somewhat enchanting early 20th century period-piece. Well-written, visually stylized (set, costumes) & well-performed.

Don't see it if you prefer an epic magnanimous boffo production. It's a lovely night out @ the theater, in a great old venue, listening to pretty dialogue. Read more

285 Reviews | 55 Followers
84
Charming, Uplifting

See it if U enjoy this type of drawing room com/drama that doesn't dig too deep but entertains & uses a large cast to bring in some colorful character

Don't see it if You don't care for plays where everyone is nice and things all work out for the best. Read more

119 Reviews | 30 Followers
90
Witty, Moving, Great acting, Romantic, Profound

See it if you enjoy classic American theater and a chance to see a rarely performed play by an unrelated playwright.

Don't see it if you prefer contemporary plays or lavish productions. Read more

74 Reviews | 18 Followers
79
Tha actors shine & there are joys to be had in this rather run-of-the-mill play ...

See it if you want to experience this production's skillful rendering of gentle & heartfelt characters. This aspect of Barry's writing glows here.

Don't see it if seeing less than perfect plays would burden you.

62 Reviews | 4 Followers
81
Great acting, Great staging, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if Enjoy intimate performances in small theatre and great acting. Revival of early 20th century play but still relevant.

Don't see it if You prefer big broadway productions or musicals.

42 Reviews | 35 Followers
94
Absorbing, Masterful, Great acting

See it if It's an early 20th century family drama performed by amazing actors. A very, very good play with difficult characters.

Don't see it if Not interested to go to an Off Off Broadway theater which is in an old house that only adds to the feel of the play.

Critic Reviews (5)

Lighting & Sound America
September 18th, 2018

“Under the skilled direction of Hardart, a cast with a solid understanding of period style captures the complex notes of Barry's style...Not a brilliant work, ‘You and I’ is nevertheless engaging throughout, and, in its ironic finale...it is surprisingly moving. It also stands on its own in its consideration of the soul-wearying effects of the American culture of business...And, even in this early work, Barry's philosophy is clearly stated.”
Read more

Talkin' Broadway
September 14th, 2018

"Under Hardart's uncertain direction, 'You and I' emerges as a footnote to a notable career, a good-natured but vapid drawing-room comedy whose chief interest lies in how Barry spun so many autobiographical threads into it...It's a sweet play; truly...Love and warmth permeate the stage, every character is well-intentioned...We're not convinced, however, that 'You and I' can still arrestingly hold a stage, or that its themes aren't better stated in other works."
Read more

TheaterScene.net
September 17th, 2018

"This would be fine if the artificial style of the play and the dated twenties slang did not seem arch and affected. And while director Michael Hardart's production is always stylish and graceful, he has not helped greatly with his casting or his mannered and theatrical approach to the material. The characters talk in an elevated, literate language but … are basically very simple people, not the kind who sit around tossing off bon mots. Here they speak Barry's realistic lines as though they do."
Read more

T
September 14th, 2018

"Barry's play would need a far more polished and well-cast company…than presently assembled…to give its dated-sounding dialogue…stagy characters, and plot contrivances the fire they desperately require…Hardart has helped them convey some of their roles' shifting nuances but…they're unable to make Barry's old-fashioned, 'darling'-sprinkled, upper-class locutions sound natural...Hardart's direction succeeds merely in making the two hour and 15-minute running time seem longer."
Read more

Off Off Online
September 26th, 2018

“A vibrant script, insightful where human nature is concerned, witty and, in the end, heartrending...Hardart’s accomplished staging features a balanced ensemble cast of endearing players, with three leads who lend just the right buoyancy to Barry’s witty dialogue. But what’s best is how they capture the poignancy of the playwright’s subtext, as well as of his text...If only such graceful, stylish talk could be heard more often nowadays—onstage and off!”
Read more