"Young is a charming, audience-friendly performer and singer, all right, but she decidedly isn't Julie Andrews. So don't go expecting something like one of those touring tribute bands that emulate the real thing. What defines her show is a complete eschewing of pretense as she shares biographical anecdotes and some familiar and some less familiar tunes from Ms. Andrews' songbook...Feel free to set aside your New York cynicism and do join in without embarrassment the audience sing-along."
Read more

"You needn’t be as big of a fan as Young—frankly, I don’t think anyone is—in order to appreciate her 110-minute musical tribute...Though she sings beautifully (her 'Feed the Birds' is gorgeous), Young doesn’t sing like Andrews and she doesn’t try; all she has is as an undying admiration for the star...Her enthusiasm carries 'Julie Madly Deeply'—and it’s genuine. If she’s backstage eating schnitzel with noodles after the show, I wouldn’t be one bit surprised."
Read more

"It is this modesty and good-humor that makes Young almost as attractive as the subject of her show...Young is also a gifted actress and mime. Her warmth establishes an almost immediate liaison with the audience. And 59e59's Theater B provides all the intimacy this show needs...She is such a natural that one suspects she needed little guidance from director Russell Lucas who keeps the show rolling along at a steady pace."
Read more

"Somewhere between a tribute and a cabaret show, 'Julie Madly Deeply' is a hardcore fan's presentation of songs made popular by Julie Andrews as well as anecdotes about Andrews' life. The charming Sarah-Louise Young isn't trying to impersonate Andrews--nor does she--as much as she becomes a fan personified."
Read more

"A cabaret show about Julie Andrews that needs more than a spoonful of sugar to make it go down…Young fills her hour and 55 minutes with familiar biographical facts, anecdotes, and songs. Occasionally, Young is joined in duets with Roulston, a fine baritone who stays on key more consistently than she…Young overdoes her physical business and gestures. Still, for fans of Andrews, even less than perfectly performed versions…are entertaining enough to help paste over the show's obvious cracks."
Read more

"If you adore Dame Julie Andrews, you must see the Brits Off Broadway offering in its US Premiere...Young’s talents with comedy, singing and movement, keep the production engaging and lively as she lovingly riffs on her favorite icon...Throughout, 'Julie Madly Deeply' remains ebullient and informative thanks to Young’s clever working of the material and interspersing the humorous bits with songs and anecdotes which Andrews’ fans will enjoy."
Read more

“Absolutely delightful...Even with the warmup music setting the mood, few could be prepared for the sheer over-the-top glee that was ahead for them in this superb musical comedy tribute to one of entertainment’s most beloved leading ladies...Young channeled our Ms. Andrews with supreme vocals and an energy level that never wavered throughout the show’s robust running time. Young also inserted her own smart, often laugh-out-loud humor throughout."
Read more

"A vital part of the show is the connection that Young works to establish with her audience...In a role that calls for part actress, part singer, and part host, Young is able to convey an infectious amiability and an unbridled awe in what Andrews has accomplished in her career...An enjoyable, if not all that deep, piece about a show-business legend and someone on whom that legend made a lasting impression."
Read more