New York | 1h 35m | Already closed

Lost Girls

From 17 critic and 38 member reviews
Members say: Absorbing, Great acting, Clever, Intense, Riveting

About the show

MCC presents a gritty drama about the reunion of a stressed-out retail clerk and her recovering alcoholic ex-husband after their teenage daughter goes missing, starring Piper Perabo. More…

When their seventeen-year-old daughter goes missing during a winter storm, Maggie and Lou - former high school sweethearts, now divorced - are forced to confront the legacy of their past decisions. 'Lost Girls' is a hard-hitting drama about a blue-collar family in New Hampshire struggling to rise above their limited prospects to prevent history from repeating itself.

1h 35m | Already closed | Lucille Lortel Theatre (West Village)

The Hollywood Reporter

"The play works well both as a tense family drama and a moving portrayal of burgeoning teenage romance, and is further elevated by a wickedly clever narrative twist that completely upends our perceptions...Under the excellent direction of Jo Bonney, the ensemble shines, with all the actors delivering memorably vivid performances. The technical elements are sharp, with Hoover's sets and Theresa Squire's costumes perfectly conveying the working-class milieu." Full Review

Time Out New York

"See enough plays and you might start to feel pretty smug about your ability to spot an impending plot twist, but this one is far from flagrant and, in any case, Pollono keeps us so hooked on the vectors of tension sparking between the various characters (Maggie and Lou, in particular, share a scarifyingly tragic history) that the big picture tends to recede—only to resurface resoundingly in the end." Full Review

As Her World Turns

"I fell hard for this play...The dialogue is spot-on; these are fully fleshed-out human beings (side note: I dig their Boston-area accents; the play is set in New Hampshire). And then we’re hit with a series of twists that are smartly worked into the narrative. This play runs through November 29th and I suspect it will have a life beyond this run, as it’s quite good with a very strong cast." Full Review

American Theater Web

"Pollono’s written a play that’s veers between caustic tartness and sweetness to terrific effect...The cumulative effect of the two stories proves not only moving but also thought-provoking...Under Bonney’s direction, the ensemble deliver immaculately crafted performances...The ensemble’s fine work means that all of characters are people for whom theatergoers begin to root early on." Full Review

Entertainment Hour Blog

"While some of the details were further from reality, almost everything else transports you instantly to Manchester, NH. Richard Hoover does an excellent job with the turntable set, complete with such subtle authentic touches like the framed picture of Tom Brady on the wall. The vernacular used, while some may find offensive, was truthful with raw honesty. John Pollono’s writing is modern, conversational and effortless; it is as if you are a fly on the wall in this New England home." Full Review

Lighting & Sound America

"John Pollono manages to run rings around the family drama formula, with results that are both touching and loaded with suspense... Pollono nimbly leaps between the two halves of his narrative, confidently manipulating our expectations even as he doles out a series of revelations that, in all likelihood, you won't see coming... For the sheer pleasure of storytelling, 'Lost Girls' is a fine place to get lost for an hour and a half." Full Review

Theatre's Leiter Side

"Mr. Pollono’s vulgarity-peppered, New England-accented dialogue crackles with sharp ripostes, and his characters—despite some exaggeration—are sharply enough defined to make them both entertaining and plausible. While the setup leading to the big reveal employs the kind of clever trick that seems increasingly contrived the more you think about it, 'Lost Girls' would probably be lost without it." Full Review


"'Lost Girls', like its predecessor, offers the snappy, colorful dialogue of troubled working class New Englanders with tight plotting and a clever twist...Perabo is solidly detailed playing a woman who, despite financial struggles, is determined for her daughter to have the kind of opportunities she never had. She leads a strong ensemble in an engaging, quick-moving play with a kicker of a finish." Full Review

Bob's Theater Blog

"I won’t reveal the outcome except to say that there is a tricky development near the end that I have mixed feelings about. Two of three theater-savvy friends who attended the same performance missed it, so I think director Jo Bonney needs to do something to make the ending clearer. I wish the actors didn't need to struggle so hard with the New England accent. Richard Hoover’s revolving set and Theresa Squire’s costumes capture the correct ambience. It’s consistently involving and entertaining." Full Review


"'Lost Girls' is always riveting as the revelations come thick and fast and twists continue to take us by surprise...'Lost Girls' is a play that you will think about long after you have left the theater." Full Review

The Huffington Post

"In contemporary writing for the theater, it can sometimes seem as if there's an undeclared competition to determine which playwright can produce the most dysfunctional American family play out of all the dysfunctional American family plays going...More than anything, 'Lost Girls,' which was originally produced by Los Angeles's Rogue Machine Theatre, is a study of volatile Maggie...Pollono's sympathy for all his characters is realized in every performance." Full Review


"A story that — when it doesn't take shortcuts paved with sugar — poetically blends the grit of reality with a haunting lust for the past...the conclusion is disappointingly neat. Teen pregnancy, financial hardship, and domestic abuse is often a self-perpetuating cycle. A momentary happy ending is not enough to mark a new beginning — but Pollono convinces us to swallow our pessimism and cheerfully take in his spoonful of sugar." Full Review

New York Theatre Guide

"The good news here is that Pollono’s storytelling hangs on well-developed characters engaged in a dark comedy...The deft hand of director Jo Bonney is everywhere—not least, in these well-crafted performances. What’s more, she juxtaposes scenes that seem to be simultaneous, playing with time and with us. She doesn’t so much tip her hand as she allows the audience to discover what’s up. Bonney and Pollono are comfortable collaborators. Lucky us." Full Review


"At the heart of Pollono's new and intriguing play is the steady decline and decimation of the working class... The actors are skilled at deploying New England-speak as they convey their character's determination to get at least one step beyond where each had been. It is funny to hear how proud they are that the women in their family have been slowly making progress by getting pregnant a little later than had great grandma at fifteen, then Linda at then sixteen, and Maggie at seventeen." Full Review

The New York Times

"Ambling and ultimately quite moving comic drama...Theatergoers can become impatient with expositional setups for reveals they may not know are coming. And the long opening scene is entertaining enough but hardly grips the attention...Nothing in Mr. Pollono’s script adds much that’s new to what became the default sensibility of naturalistic modern literature. But Mr. Pollono invests his characters with such affectionate observational detail that he makes us like them, too." Full Review

Talkin' Broadway

"Pollono has carved two compelling characters to occupy the heart of this not-always-compelling play...If the central four characters have been suavely, even movingly, executed, what surrounds them can sometimes feel excessive...For as good as the second half of Pollono's play is, when the ramifications of these tangled personal histories become unavoidable, the early scenes between the girl and boy on their road trip push their bubbly, youthful ardor a bit too far." Full Review

The Wrap

"'Lost Girls' is best experienced in retrospect. Two of John Pollono’s characters aren’t who we assume they are for most of the play’s 90 minutes. While 'Lost Girls' might be better appreciated knowing who’s who from the top, fear not: The twist will not be revealed here...Director Jo Bonney needs to lighten up their performances. An ex-husband and a boyfriend are so verbally battered and shat on by these women that they could qualify for FEMA." Full Review

Outstanding, Gritty, Great writing, Amazing acting, Must see

See it if you want an incredible cast performing a twisty story about loss and struggle. perfect balance between humor and darkness. JUST GO.

Don't see it if there is literally no reason not to see this. it was unbelievable. i didn't want it to be over, i was lost in the story. this is theater.

Absorbing, Clever, Intelligent, Refreshing, Riveting

See it if you love a good plot twist or if you want a new take on family dramas

Don't see it if you're offended by foul language or simulated sex on stage

Great acting, Thought-provoking, Must see

See it if you appreciate great performances, believable characters.

Don't see it if you are concerned about offensive language (e.g. use of the word "retarded" was both offensive and gratuitous, but it was used repeatedly).

Absorbing, Clever, Great acting, Original, Funny

See it if You like original, insightful drama.

Don't see it if You're looking for light, fluffy entertainment.

Absorbing, Clever, Hilarious, Intense, Riveting

See it if you love a good family drama, dark plot twists, aggressively working class ambiance, women who swear, sassy mothers, gritty dramas, suspense

Don't see it if you are offended by swearing, onstage sex, onstage teen sex, occasionally forced accent work, intensely dark and gritty backstories.

Great acting, Riveting, Entertaining, Must see, Intense

See it if You like Off Broadway theatre

Don't see it if You are offended by strong language.

Clever, Edgy, Great writing, Must see, Refreshing

See it if you want to think, guess and be on the edge of your seat. Lots of great eye opening moments that you don't expect.

Don't see it if you don't like dramas and having to think, they play will challenge you and you will like it

Great acting, Edgy, Profound, Relevant, Resonant

See it if Looking for a little darker of a show. It starts off nice but gets much darker in the end

Don't see it if you are unable to handle difficult subjects especially concerning young children.

Absorbing, Edgy, Intense

See it if you like edgy, intense shows with great acting

Don't see it if you're uncomfortable with strong language/situations, addiction issues

Great acting, Absorbing, Intelligent, Poignant

See it if you enjoy shows about families having problems.

Don't see it if you prefer upbeat shows about likable characters.

Surprising, Fun, Great acting, Clever, Endearing

See it if you like a great plot twist, characters written in a way you will recognize them in your life. Believable story.

Don't see it if Can't think why not like it.

Resonant, Great acting, Absorbing, Slice-of-life, Small-town american

See it if enjoy realistic dramas (with deftly leavening humor) about family life amid modern stress. Spiky-yet-sympathetic characters, neat plot twist

Don't see it if You are offended by f-bombs sprinkled realistically by every character, sexual simulations, but nothing you wouldn't get on HBO.

Absorbing, Great acting, Delightful

See it if You like plays with an unexpected twist, great acting and family dramas.

Don't see it if You are offended by curse words, don't like too much exposition or some overwritten dialogue. At time a one act that felt stretched.

Absorbing, Surprising, Intelligent, Intense, Original

See it if you like funny, smart dramas about struggling (emotionally and financially) families. Strong writing, acting and direction. A solid evening.

Don't see it if you're put off by strong language. This play has a delightful punchline which took me by surprise.

Absorbing, Clever, Entertaining, Intelligent, Refreshing

See it if you want a surprise ending.

Don't see it if you don;'t like family dynamics.

Absorbing, Great acting, Intelligent, Thought-provoking

See it if you enjoy family dramas. Great performances especially by Piper Perabo, Meghann Fahy and Ebon Moss-Bachrach.

Don't see it if you're not ready to engage in this family drama

Absorbing, Edgy, Resonant

See it if you like serious stories about messed up families that also incorporate humor. monologues are very resonant!

Don't see it if you are uncomfortable with nudity/sex/excessive profanity.

Funny, Edgy, Intense, Quirky, Relevant

See it if you want to see realistic people in a thought provoking story that makes you feel for the characters.

Don't see it if you are uncomfortable with sex on stage.

Profound, Relevant, Resonant, Riveting, Thought-provoking

See it if You get the chance, it was good and had great characters who are very relatable.

Don't see it if You don't like profanity, otherwise no other reason.

Also I saw it in October of 2015. I enjoyed it and thought it was very well... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Great acting, Funny, Resonant, Intense

See it if You enjoy gritty family dramas that seem just a little too real and stories that have plot twists you will never see coming

Don't see it if you are offended by foul language and/or simulated sex/nudity onstage


See it if you like family dramas.

Don't see it if your ear bleeds at the sound of New Hampshire accents.

Cliched, Indulgent, Eh, Banal

See it if you like stories about families and relationships.

Don't see it if you're in the mood for something original.

Clever, Moving, Great acting, Thought-provoking, Funny

See it if great story and acting. Funny and moving.

Don't see it if you don't like smaller sets.

Great acting, Great writing, Hilarious, Riveting, Original

See it if You love original, gritty, real plays.

Don't see it if you're a theater pussy.

Masterful, Profound, Thought-provoking

See it if you enjoy a drama that encapsulates real family emotions and the turbulence of relationships. It is raw and rebellious.

Don't see it if you want to stay in your pretty fantasy world of illusion.

Cast & Creatives (12)