Monte Cristo (The York Theatre Company 2026)

New reviews are being saved, but they are not currently displaying on this page. We are upgrading our system, so while your feedback is secure, it won't appear publicly until our updates are complete.

This show has not been reviewed yet

Positive

Mixed

Negative

Members say

Be the first to review

About the Show

Wrongfully jailed, a man returns to seek revenge—but love may alter his course.

This sweeping musical brings Alexandre Dumas’ timeless tale to life in an epic story of betrayal, transformation, and retribution. Wrongfully imprisoned, a man returns with newfound wealth and resolve, determined to exact revenge—but as his plan takes shape, he’s forced to ask whether justice alone can fill the void left by lost love. Developed through The York’s New2NY series, the production reunites the Drama Desk-winning creator of Desperate Measures with the team behind Penelope for a gripping journey of vengeance, redemption, and enduring passion.

Critic Reviews (7)

"Tweak the story to fit the stage if you must, but don’t lose its spirit."
Read more

"It's not that The Count of Monte Cristo is a sacred text that must be protected from vulgarians; in fact, it's a potboiler, if an exceptionally entertaining one. The trouble is, it is entirely unsuited to the jolly, old-fashioned approach favored by Kellogg and Weiner."
Read more

An adaptation of the Dumas novel, one of the most accomplished musical productions to be seen currently in NYC.
Read more

In this leaden and stubbornly old-fashioned adaptation, Adam Jacobs proves a stolid and somewhat wooden Edmond, flashing more determination to get through the intricacies of the plot than to convey any individual emotions.
Read more

"Monte Cristo could rightfully be accused of being recherché; its refined characters swanning about the streets of Paris and Marseilles may look passé and, to use another out-of-fashion word, corny to some contemporary audiences."
Read more

This modest musical version turns out to have many charms and emotional highs.
Read more

This adaptation of The Count of Monte Cristo hits familiar beats. However, it hits them with such confidence and charm that the result is irresistible.
Read more