Play Like A Winner (NYMF)
Closed 2h 0m
Play Like A Winner (NYMF)

Play Like A Winner (NYMF) NYC Reviews and Tickets

(28 Reviews)
Members say
Funny, Entertaining, Clever, Great singing, Great writing

About the Show

Part of the New York Musical Festival: A satire of the soccer mom world based on the award-winning play 'All About the Kids' by Caytha Jentis.

Read more Show less

Member Reviews (28)

Sort by:
  • Default
  • Standing in our community
  • Highest first
  • Lowest first
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Only positive
  • Only negative
  • Only mixed
913 Reviews | 928 Followers
Cute, Entertaining, Slow, Needs trimming, Needs a less nonsensical end

See it if It's cute and fun. Good music. Some great jokes.

Don't see it if Many of the cast are not up to their task, less in the singing than in the acting. Ending was abrupt and nonsensical. Some plot gaps. Read more

888 Reviews | 1017 Followers
Funny, Entertaining, Campy, Overly long

See it if You enjoy watching fueds between women. Act 2 is especially fun and campy w/ many laugh out loud moments. 2 leading ladies were great.

Don't see it if The setup takes too long & things don't pick up until the end of Act1. Show could easily be condensed to 80-90min & Would be much stronger. Read more

982 Reviews | 343 Followers
Repetitive, Dated, Great singing, Fluffy, Overstuffed

See it if you enjoy great voices singing good songs. PLW is meant to be satirical, but school sports headlines have been crazier. Not enough laughs.

Don't see it if you want tight plotting. Act I is far superior to Act II. Too many unnecessary songs. Too much unnec'y swearing. Altho new, PLW feels dated. Read more

459 Reviews | 117 Followers
Great singing, Fluffy, Overrated

See it if You want to see a delightful, "adult" musical done by some very good voices

Don't see it if you want your satires to be satirical. This is much closer to reality. The book and lyrics fail to bring it over the top to absurdity.

240 Reviews | 69 Followers
Clever, Delightful, Funny, Great writing, Quirky

See it if You want to see a hilarious satire of the world of soccer moms, with a razor-sharp script and great songs.

Don't see it if You're bothered by a cast that may not have the greatest voices, or you're a soccer mom who would be offended by such a caricature.

202 Reviews | 24 Followers
Great staging, Funny, Dark, Good acting, Relevant

See it if you like dark comedies that are very relevant to today's world.

Don't see it if you don't like dark comedies or stories about soccer moms.

176 Reviews | 41 Followers
Great singing, Edgy, Repetative, Static, Entertaining

See it if you enjoy solid singing and an edgy story. Fun to watch, but needs some work adding more melodies and a different angle in the story.

Don't see it if you don't like repetative motives. The storytelling is static and lacking action. Needs additional twist, ex. adding kids perspective.

103 Reviews | 16 Followers
Clever, Great singing, Hilarious

See it if you like funny, cynical musicals. You can empathize with parents looking out for the best interests of their child.

Don't see it if You are looking for something serious. Read more

Critic Reviews (4)

The New York Times
July 30th, 2017

"'Play Like a Winner' is the kind of musical comedy that sucks you in whether it’s your cup of tea or not...With book and lyrics by Erik Johnke and music by David Wolfson, this is a well-polished, occasionally foul-mouthed caricature of suburban soccer-mom life, aimed squarely at that demographic...The fine cast is led by Jessica Tyler Wright...Toward the end it’s a little like playing 'Clue,' where you know the victim and the murder weapon and you’re waiting to find out whodunit."
Read more

July 28th, 2017

"The subject lends itself well to dark satire...But Erik Johnke (book and lyrics) and David Wolfson (music) have not yet struck the comic tone that, like good satire does, unearths buried truths beneath the surface of the material. As of now, 'Play Like a Winner' leans on simple melodies and crude shock value that make you uncomfortable without the payoff of satisfying insight. It's a play that might win a few laughs, but that's not enough of a winning strategy."
Read more

July 30th, 2017

"The book and lyrics are not clever enough to produce the undercurrents of a true satire but rather remain on the surface with a loutish book and relying on vulgar lyrics to produce laughs...The music is unobtrusive and produces some pleasant melodies but at times does not support the intent of the song. The cast is remarkable and does what they can to elevate the material...It may provide a bit of raunchy fun but needs to revamp and find its target audience."
Read more

Times Square Chronicles
July 29th, 2017

“The cast is blessed with powerful voices and sound terrific on David Wolfson's score. They also managed to create moments of hilarity from the script and lyrics by Erik Johnke…What’s lacking is strong comedic choices and a devilish sense of humor. The show needs to blindside you with a unique twist. Right now, it’s a little crude and not that amusing. The songs, though tuneful, don’t stand out. In the end, the game has been played, but it’s more like a tied score.”
Read more