(Off-Broadway) The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical NYC Reviews and Tickets
Show-Score Member Reviews (157)
See it if You are a fan of the books and enjoy quirky shows. It was enjoyable and had great acting and staging.
Don't see it if You don't like very lighthearted shows, or shows for kids.
See it if You want to see a rock musical with a story from the Percy Jackson book. It is great for the 8-teen set, but not just for kids.
Don't see it if You want to see something thought-provoking or moving - this is just a great musical to a known 'coming of age' story.
See it if You enjoyed the books. Need an evening of light fun.
Don't see it if You want a large theatre production with all the sparkle of broadway. Read more
See it if you like adventure tales and new musicals. The music was catchy, acting was solid and the show was thoroughly enjoyable for adults and kids.
Don't see it if you prefer highly polished productions, don't like rock-musicals, or don't have patience for shows aimed at young audiences.
See it if You enjoy a fresh take on Greek Mythology; children/teens in your life who love the books; strong vocals
Don't see it if You want a super polished show with expensive sets or a large production
See it if you're a tween/teen, a fan of the Percy Jackson series, or want to see something new and entertaining.
Don't see it if you're a curmudgeon Read more
See it if you like a high energy show, with fun upbeat rock music. Great voices. Perfect for ages 8-14.
Don't see it if You are expecting an adult geared production. The props and costumes felt like an innovative college production. But talent was great.
See it if You're a fan of the book series by Rick Riordan and enjoy YA type shows. Also if you enjoy mythology.
Don't see it if You're looking for deep, meaningful adult type shows. This is a great family show to take the kids to.
Critic Reviews (22)
"A slam-dunk crowd-pleaser for fans of the book and others...The story is action-packed and compelling, with both warmth and wisecracks, and the added bonus of an empowering takeaway message...Chris McCarrell does Percy proud. With his leading young man looks, strong voice, agility and stage presence, he is a sword-wielding talent to keep your eyes on...McCarrell is well supported by a versatile ensemble who play multiple roles."
Read more
“In other hands this could have been cheesy; in Brackett’s team’s hands, it’s exhilarating…The battles are fun, the dialogue is endearing, the lighting design is captivating, and the sound effects add so much to the environment that losing yourself in the play becomes easy. The relationships between characters are enjoyable…The musical numbers, which are hit-and miss-throughout the production, are elevated by a cast that is just having such a great time it’s infectious."
Read more
"A charming off-Broadway musical that will appeal to all ages...If you’re not familiar with the story beforehand, it may be a bit of a struggle, at first, to follow the quick-paced plot. Once it gets going, though, the show is so engaging that it doesn’t matter...It has all the right ingredients—the combination of stellar words, music, and acting with the inventive set and prop use—to make 'The Lightning Thief' a long-lasting and successful show...Truly a delight."
Read more
"This production works on both levels: it’s accessible to the uninitiated mere mortals who want a good show, and it’s chock-full of things to love for the most ardent of demigod fans...It’s really impressive, considering the shoestring budget the show’s running on, how much they accomplished...Chris McCarrell is an absolutely flawless Percy...Great music, great acting, and a great story combine to make it one of the best nights of theatre we’ve seen."
Read more
"With amazing talent, catchy songs, heaps of humor, and a relatable story line with themes kids can relate to, demigod or mere mortal, it's a must-see for fans...The songs are witty, fun, and resonate with kids of all ages...Though this is a fantastical tale about ancient Greek gods and modern-day demigods, the theme is universal—adolescents struggling to find their place while trying to prove themselves to their parents, using their intellect and special gifts to make tough choices."
Read more
“This musical, based upon Rick Riordan‘s beloved book, is full of sarcasm, action, confusion, angst, and bravery...This production is filled with incredibly talented New York actors…McCarrell is a young Drew Gehling, charming the pants off of every ensemble member, and all those watching in the audience…‘The Lightning Thief’ is sure to invite fans of all ages, making everyone who enters its space laugh, possibly cry (?), and feel like a little kid all over again.”
Read more