New York | 2h 10m | Already closed

The Show-Off

From 21 critic and 32 member reviews
Members say: Dated, Disappointing, Entertaining, Slow, Funny

About the show

The Peccadillo Theater Company revives George Kelly's 1924 comedy about an egotistical braggart and his farcical attempts to retain some dignity amidst his own self-aggrandizing hyperbole. Starring Annette O'Toole. More…

Notable for its blending of comedy and drama, 'The Show-Off' revolves around a working-class Irish family in North Philadelphia in the mid '20s. Mr. and Mrs. Fisher and their three adult children are thrown into a state of turmoil when Amy, their middle child, brings home a preposterous suitor named Aubrey Piper. A compulsive liar with delusions of grandeur, Aubrey meets his match in Mrs. Fisher (Annette O'Toole), the crusty, no-nonsense matriarch of the family. A battle of wits ensues and the outcome is a vindication (of sorts!) of the American con man.

2h 10m | Already closed | Theatre at St. Clement's (Midtown W)


"George Kelly's 1924 consistently amusing dramatic comedy shows how un-musty a 93-year-old play can be thanks to the adroitly addressed direction of Dan Wackerman and his responsive ensemble...It remains for the many splendid performers and their delivery of Kelly's crisp dialogue to glide over the play's few exposed seams...This is no resurrected trifle, but a well-written and worthy revival of a comedy classic." Full Review

Stage Buddy

"It’s a frothy, silly period piece with a lot of heart and some interesting comments regarding the institution of marriage...The direction here, by the discerning Wackerman, is right on point...This is a well-heeled company, an embarrassment of riches...Has a production team that knows how to show off their inimitable expertise, and it’s really delightful. So, tell a fib or two, a harmless little white lie, steal a little time away from the rest of your busy schedules and catch 'The Show-Off.'" Full Review

The Huffington Post

"Peccadillo Theater Company is doing its gallant bit to revive interest in playwright Kelly with its super production...In a series of clever plot fiddling, Kelly keeps his cards close to his playwright’s chest. As possibly his best achievement he keeps Aubrey one of those figures you love to hate...Director Wackerman is a dab hand at these wonderful American chestnuts. The cast measures up to everything he’s obviously asked of them." Full Review

Show Showdown

"The Peccadillo's production of Kelly's odd but effective comedy is more than solid. It is wry and real, and it manages to show the play's relevance to today while never betraying its place in the past...Kelly's excellent writing is fabulously supported by Wackerman's direction and the wonderful acting of, in particular, O'Toole as Amy's humorously frustrated mother Mrs. Fisher and Hudson as Amy's sister Clara, who cannot figure out why her husband doesn't quite love her." Full Review

Broad Street Review

"Feels like a discovery...Kelly’s 1924 comedy marries a drawing-room aesthetic to the politics of the day...Wackerman further downplays the inherent comedy in Aubrey’s outlandish posturing, which serves to foreground the play’s surprisingly radical underpinnings...Gould certainly finds the funny in Aubrey’s most idiosyncratic turns of phrase...A fine staging." Full Review


"How a playwright and director balance our distaste for a blowhard throughout three acts requires skill. Kelly’s writing shows skill. Wackerman reveals a sensitivity to this problem. However, astute acting handles the potential issues of our annoyance...O'Toole propels the production. Thankfully, her feisty performance stirs the pot of laughter and moves the character dynamic toward conclusion." Full Review

Off Off Online

"Kelly’s title character, Aubrey Piper, is a great creation, an annoying rascal and a liar, and one waits impatiently for him to get his comeuppance...The pudgy Gould inflicts every irritation that his obnoxious character can put upon the others as he swans around the gorgeously detailed living room and parlor...In the final moments, Kelly springs a last twist that proves darkly ironic yet feels just right." Full Review


"This play in which the action takes place nearly a century ago might seem to offer an escape from modern travails. But the play’s themes are (uncomfortably) timeless...Gould is eerily good as the self-deluded Aubrey Piper — a character we initially love to hate. Gould is appropriately pompous and boastful, and dominates most conversations. Tirosh Schneider as Joe also stands out as the bright-eyed and good-hearted teenage whiz kid." Full Review

City Cabaret

"May not be as funny in 2017 as it seemed in 1924 and at times may even feel a bit tiresome...O'Toole nails most of her snappy quips...Orelove moves nicely from the love-struck fiancée to a young wife...Gould comes short of being an illegal huckster but is convincing as Aubrey...Unfortunately, the building of the story develops slowly and the direction by Wackerman fails to keep a snappy pace. The sudden death in the middle brings in a tragic element that is handled with an edge of clumsiness." Full Review

Theatre's Leiter Side

"There are laughs in 'The Show-Off' but most are chuckles and only a few land big, although Kelly's comedy can be praised for its spontaneous rather than deliberate quality. On the other hand…there are long stretches…whose naturalistic tone is surprisingly serious (and dull)…This is definitely not a show-off revival… but it should prove satisfying enough for theatregoers curious about the most popular play by one of America's foremost, if largely forgotten, dramatists of the 1920s and 1930s." Full Review

Front Row Center

"There’s a reason it’s so little revived, it really isn’t a great play. And what may have been funny and topical in 1924, is nigh unto incomprehensible in 2017...Although I will admit that the second act is better than the first, the ending is jaw-droppingly ridiculous, and just plain unbelievable. It’s a shame really that so much good work has been put into the production of a play that just can’t reward the effort of either the actors and crew or the audience." Full Review


"Perhaps Kelly's great success has grown too old for contemporary audiences to be easily familiar with its comedic targets...The rather thin plot is stretched to the limit, leading to a possible redemption for the rascal. The period flavor presented by director Wackerman's talented ensemble helps coax the material along, but 'The Show-Off' comes off more as a historic curiosity than a worthy obscurity." Full Review


"An American classic of long standing, George Kelly's 'The Show-Off' may have dated. However, as has often been seen with legendary Moliere comedies, the right style will make all the difference. Dan Wackerman's handling of 'The Show-Off' has deflated the high-jinks and satire that is very much in evidence in this long admired character study of a typically American type. It is left to the right director to bring out the brilliance in this 1920's comedy in some future revival." Full Review

Village Voice

"The story’s tricky mix of comical and serious doings makes the play a challenging one to produce, and the Peccadillo Theater Company’s new revival does not effectively fuse its contrasts. There needs to be a subtle stylization to the acting and the visuals, but such an effect eludes Wackerman, the company’s artistic director, whose flat-footed staging yields a mostly dull occasion. Moreover, the fuzzy acoustics of the Theatre at St. Clement’s are no friend to Kelly’s should-be-snappy dialogue." Full Review


"'The Show-Off' is ostensibly a comedy, but the truth is that it's not very funny, at least not as directed by Dan Wackerman...One wonders if we would actually laugh at this jazz-age clown as portrayed by a more natural comedian; here, we just grimace to the sound of crickets...American audiences have delighted in the redemption of this shyster for 92 years (and six Broadway revivals), but 2017 might just be the year that 'The Show-Off' ceases to amuse." Full Review

The New York Times

"A disjointed production...Its chief asset is Annette O’Toole...The dramatic sparks between Ms. O’Toole and Mr. Schneider suggest what the production might have been if all of the principals were operating on the same aesthetic plane. Instead, there is an awkward jumble of acting styles...In the battle between Mrs. Fisher and this vulgar interloper, the deck is heavily stacked, and that makes 'The Show-Off' no fun at all." Full Review

Woman Around Town

"The first question is why revive this piece...Aubrey ranges from irritating to infuriating. Amy is stupid. Clara switches her judgment and behavior without sufficient underpinning. Frank is a cipher...The second is a matter of two acting styles at war...Wackerman, who moves his players around with great skill and captivating small business, has given us far better in terms of performance...In order for a play like this to work at all, casting must be believable and style consistent." Full Review

Times Square Chronicles

"Using Annette O’Toole as the mother is a waste of her talents and feels like miscasting...I wish this story had been more explored. The success of the night is Tirosh Schneider who plays the youngest Fisher child, Joe. It is his storyline that gives us that inevitable happy ending...This show feels dated under Dan Wackerman’s direction but is pleasing to look at thanks to Harry Feiner’s scenic and lighting design. Sometimes shows should be left in the closet as time has passed them by." Full Review

Time Out New York

"In this mostly miscast production, indifferently staged by the troupe’s artistic director, Wackerman, nothing shines. To be fair, however, it’s not just the staging that seems lacking; 'The Show-Off' doesn’t have much underneath its dust...Though meant to amuse, the antics of this lying narcissist don’t seem very funny, and sudsy subplots inspire the actors to play Act II like a drama—with deadly results...They say that comedy is tragedy plus time. Comedy plus time, in this case, is tragic." Full Review

Applause! Applause!

“The play is about a working-class Irish family living in North Philadelphia. Josie and Neil Fisher's daughter Amy is hopelessly in love with Aubrey Piper, an obnoxious, toupee-wearing blowhard. Unfortunately, Annette O'Toole as Mrs. Fisher, and Ian Gould as Aubrey Piper, fail to deliver the performances required to engage and interest the audience. That said, the set is beautiful and the costumes are period appropriate. There are also some talented and charismatic actors in the cast.” Full Review

Lighting & Sound America

"The current Peccadillo revival leaves one wondering why it should be considered a comedy at all...Dan Wackerman's production lays bare the creaks in Kelly's script. It begins with a flurry of exposition that leaves one wondering if it will ever get going. A subplot, about the youngest member of the Fisher clan and his industrial invention, is the baldest of plot devices...Indeed, the designers' contributions are far more compelling than the text that they have worked so assiduously to support." Full Review

Delightful, Funny, Great acting, Resonant, Good directing, stage design, & costumes

See it if Love satire/comedy with good dialogues & distinct characters portrayed by good cast. Like old American plays with good period set & costumes

Don't see it if U don't like revival of dated period defined plays because U unfairly judge them with today's perspective without appreciating their value.

Also Peccadillo Theater Company does not disappoint with the revival of Ame... Read more Read less

Entertaining, Funny, Great acting, Resonant, Great writing

See it if you enjoy a glimpse into a time past. There are strong characters, taught writing with a twist ending. I prefer "nostalgic" to dated.

Don't see it if you cannot enjoy (or understand?) a play that is set in a time before the internet. There is still shine on this old play.

Delightful, Entertaining, Quirky, Fluffy, Underrated

See it if you would like to see a comedy with some serious notes, set in the 1920's. An old-fashioned, annoying focal point who makes good.

Don't see it if you dislike family comedy-dramas set in the 1920's, with a main character that entertains, but that you detest.

Also It's funny. Most of the bad reviews I see on Show-Score complain that ... Read more Read less

Great staging, Well acted, Intelligent, Seriocomic, Writing holds up

See it if you enjoy a well-crafted play, but could be played for more comedy.

Don't see it if Edward Albee is your cup of tea.

Refreshing, Quirky, Wilder-esque, Entertaining, Dated

See it if you want an escape from the usual fare to a place and time that was pure, simple, and delightful. This show was sweet without being cloying.

Don't see it if you need harsh anything for a theatrical experience to be worthwhile. This is a delicate piece, perfectly performed, and very charming too.

Entertaining, Dated, Ambitious, Good acting, Pointless

See it if You want to see a pleasant but pointless play. To me it seems to be a well done production of a not very good play.

Don't see it if You’re looking for something with a lot of depth or meaning. This is well done but I just don’t get what it was done for.

Clever, Entertaining, Funny

See it if you like a witty comedy about characters who are regular people, not over the top. I enjoyed the playwright's true to life dialogue.

Don't see it if you like dark comedy or dysfunctional families. The interactions between family members are very realistic and often very funny.

Clever, Entertaining, Ambitious

See it if Good ensemble play about a family in the 1920's . Traditional and representative of another time. Funny and sad. Well acted.

Don't see it if You do not like dated dramas about families and relationships.

Fun, dated, interesting

See it if you like old plays.....the set is fantastic, puts today's broadway to shame. acting is good. takes a few twists and turns to keep interest

Don't see it if old plays which are slow and dated turn you off. Repetitious and kinda long.

Underrated, Ok

See it if you like revivals of old plays. See how the older generations related. Most of the acting was pretty good. The staging/costumes were nice

Don't see it if you don't like revivals or shows ab out family dynamics.

Clever, Entertaining, Funny

See it if you like to be entertained. you like to be surprised. you enjoy period pieces

Don't see it if vindicatio of an ethically questionable character bothers you. You need something profound and thought provoking

Disappointing, Dated, Slow, Relevant

See it if Period piece suprisingly relevant proving pomposity never goes out of style Ensemble uneven but leads O'Toole & Gould sustain interest

Don't see it if Wackerman's weak direction never finds balance between dark & light comedy Dark side (bordering on harsh & shrill) wins but a few laughs had

Dated, Slow, Thought-provoking

See it if You want to see an interesting old play which has a a very dull first act. Hang in there...It get better. Very annoying lead character.

Don't see it if If you've seen another production of it. In spite of a gorgeous set, I have a feeling that this show has been done better. not very funny

Cliched, Disappointing, Funny, Dated

See it if If you like period pieces. Keep your expectations low. It was an okay production.

Don't see it if Nothing really grabbed me. The acting was cartoonist and stiff. I am a patient audience but I noticed many left at intermission.

Dated, Disappointing, Slow

See it if if you have a great interest in Kelly's plays or if you're enamored with plays from this period.

Don't see it if you're looking for something that will engage you. Very slow, and some of the acting uninspired.

Disappointing, Slow, Good design elements, Badly directed

See it if Curious about early 20th cent. dramatist George Kelly and American theatre history. Annette O'Toole solid but misguided performance.

Don't see it if No humanity under the struggles & pretensions of middle class America 1920s. Empty performances, humorless pointless production.

Dated, Disappointing, Overrated, Slow

See it if You are curious about this show in theater history. Why was it revived? It's not a very good play

Don't see it if You have something better to do.

Also It was last revived with the great Helen Hayes in the lead. Maybe ther... Read more Read less

Cliched, Dated, Disappointing

See it if for whatever reason you have some fondness for this dated, dusty, play and a production that doesn't help hide it's flaws.

Don't see it if if you're expecting a funny and or relevant production.

Ambitious, Dated, Fluffy, Quirky

See it if Annette O'Toole is truly a wonderful actress who elevates the dated material and the other actors. The production never got the tone right.

Don't see it if The 1st act is short but doesn't establish why anyone would stay for the second act, which is twice as long as the first and feels like it.

Quirky, Indulgent, Strident

See it if You are a die-hard fan of Annette O'Toole.

Don't see it if You enjoy good acting and direction. This is a satire not a strangely serious critique of society.

Absolutely awful

See it if someone threatens your life if you don't attend...(by the end of the play you'll confess to anything to stop the torture from on stage)

Don't see it if you have any artistic taste at all... the set is great, and some of the authentic costumes but.... that's it....stay away if you're smart

Delightful, Great acting, Relevant, Must see, Funny

See it if If you enjoy a period, "well-made play" that is pertinent to this day.

Don't see it if You'd rather play tetris than shower or eat.

During previews
Cliched, Great acting, Silly

See it if you like old fashioned plays with a character that you just want to slap. Annette O'Toole is wonderful.

Don't see it if you can't imagine that these customs actually existed.

During previews
Great acting, Fluffy, Dated, Cliched, Entertaining

See it if you enjoy old fashioned plays. Annette O'Toole is excellent in her role.

Don't see it if you don't find traditional ideas about marriage and family structure interesting.

During previews
Dated, Disappointing, Good performances

See it if 1920's classic comedies are your thing and you don't mind that the material is dated and not relevant. Annette O'Toole is wonderful.

Don't see it if You're looking for an entertainment that suits a modern sensibility and isn't full of 1920's slang.

Cast & Creatives (15)