“Not only a delightfully imagined tale about Peter Pan's twinkling friend Tinkerbell, it's also one of the most musically satisfying works at the festival this year. Hopefully it's also one that finds its way to a commercial venue...Under Rachel Klein's direction, the actors show off their dancing and vocal chops to great effect in energetic numbers...With a little tinkering to the story and some smoothing out of the occasionally stiff choreography, this show looks poised to fly.” Full Review
"The new family-friendly musical bursts with magic and mystery, adventure and romance, with a colorful design, captivating score, and spirited choreography that hold appeal for all ages…The show’s thoroughly engaging music ranges from heartfelt solo ballads to full-company blockbusters with strong vocals and harmonies from the entire cast…The ambitious movement is spectacular and exhilarating, though the execution is, at present, a bit shaky at times." Full Review
"Melodic and energetic numbers flood the song stack…They're the aural embodiment of in-the-moment fun…But the line between 'magical' and 'workmanlike' is unsettlingly thin here, and the show ends up playing like a cynical, even desperate, ploy for attention…Noble plays Tink to the hilt, with a bright, smile-making belt voice and no shortage of spunk…If hers is a story that needs to be told, 'Tink!' doesn't prove it—but it's good enough to send you back to the original." Full Review
“Nominally, the show is a prequel about the mischievous fairy Tinker Bell, but she is overshadowed by the dashing James, a pirate with an uncanny ability to prance around in tight pants...The show targets a young audience, but often comes across like an involuntary satire of contemporary entitled children...What you may remember most from the show is not Lena Gabrielle and Greg Kerestan’s humdrum, synthesizer-heavy score, but the flashy visuals.” Full Review
"'Tink' had all the makings of a kids' show yet there was a plethora of adult themes…There are flashy kid production numbers and then Broadway pop songs that live in a different musical…No matter how cute 'Tink' is, it desperately needed to be trimmed…'Tink' was an overly ambitious production...It was colorful. And it was way too much…This cast was buoyant and full of spirit. They had fun despite the madness of the musical…Right now, this candy-coated musical will just leave you with a cavity." Full Review
"The book strips this lovable character of any charm or enchantment…The attempt to parallel socio-economic issues of modern day is heavy-handed…The broad direction of Ms. Klein manages to serve the material but creates arrogant caricatures in lieu of impressionable fictional characters. The cast is top-rate...Although the concept seems like interesting material for a musical, perhaps it is better left as a fleeting thought...'Peter Pan' is a tough act to follow." Full Review
"'Tink!,' wants to be the 'Peter Pan' version of 'Wicked' and fails miserably. It’s not that it’s bad; worse, it's mediocre...This is a show completely devoid of magic…The over-direction by Ms. Klein consists of pushing boxes all over the stage without making sure her actors had clear-cut layered performances. She allows them to overact, mug and the script to by mangled…The show is perfect community theatre, but as for more, it needs more fairy dust." Full Review
See it if Tinkerbell without Peter Pan done so well you wonder what took so long for someone to do it. Loved the two leads. One of NYMFs best.
Don't see it if You have no heart and you don't like family shows like Matilda and Peter and the Starcatcher.
See it if Enjoy watching a touching script with a beautiful score and sharply crafted musical staging with lots of action.
Don't see it if You're not interested in musical theatre with strong actors, clever writing, and elaborate choreography.
See it if you want to feel like a child again and take part in a stunning fantasy world with great showstopping numbers
Don't see it if you want a fully completed musical rather than one still in development
See it if you are looking for a fun show with a pop score based on classic characters. A show that parents can enjoy watching along with their family.
Don't see it if you are turned off by Peter Pan stories.
See it if You have kids--you'll like it too. I see this going to B'way because it has something for everyone in the familiar Peter Pan setting.
Don't see it if You have already overdosed on the entire Peter Pan thing.
See it if You're a fan of Peter Pan, and want a retelling of it with some fantastic music, colorful costumes, and impressive dancing.
Don't see it if Your main reason for seeing it is Captain Hook - the actor playing him falls completely flat.
See it if you like Tinkerbell or shows that take familiar characters beyond what you know.
Don't see it if you don't like Tinkerbell, Peter Pan or shows that take characters beyond what you know or if you don't enjoy fantasy
See it if See it to be transported back to one of my favorite stories of Peter Pan and a new perspective of where they started from. Bring the kids
Don't see it if You don't like the Disney typo stuff
See it if you have children, love the Peter Pan universe, or are young at heart.
Don't see it if you are a mean spirited pirate who doesn't like dancing and exquisitely ripped bodies on stage.
See it if you want a backstory of Tinkerbell you enjoy new musicals that are not quite ready for prime time you like colorful, acrobatic choreography
Don't see it if you'll be bothered that it takes liberties w/Peter Pan characters you want a simple easy to follow plot you don't want 'family-friendly'
See it if You enjoy great magic on stage, acrobatics, sharp direction, beautiful choreography, and very pretty music.
Don't see it if You aren't interested in musicals, particularly ambitious musicals.
See it if You appreciate family-friendly entertainment with catchy songs that will leave you humming long after the show ends.
Don't see it if You take yourself so seriously that you cannot enjoy an evening of enchantment and light.