The First Noel
Closed 1h 30m
The First Noel

The First Noel NYC Reviews and Tickets

(7 Ratings)
Members say
Great singing, Entertaining, Delightful, Absorbing, Emotional

About the Show

After its 2015 premiere, the Classical Theatre of Harlem brings back its original holiday musical, which tells a universal story of love in a variety of song styles.

Read more Show less

Show-Score Member Reviews (7)

Sort by:
  • Default
  • Standing in our community
  • Highest first
  • Lowest first
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Only positive
  • Only negative
  • Only mixed
216 Reviews | 58 Followers
Great singing, Great staging, Thought-provoking, Touching, Creative

See it if you want to see a new twist on dealing with grief

Don't see it if you are too close to losing a child or sister Read more

132 Reviews | 46 Followers
Entertaining, Great singing, Delightful, Absorbing, Emotional

See it if you appreciate family drama, like Harlem/NYC stories, holiday music, and stories that mix past and present.

Don't see it if you dislike holiday musicals, gospel music, or drama involving personal tragedy.

561 Reviews | 99 Followers
Delightful, Great singing, Resonant, Refreshing, Emotional

See it if you can overlook the plot heavy-handedness to enjoy the thoroughly earnest, terrifically performed Harlem Christmas tale that will move you.

Don't see it if you don't want to hear a team of incredibly talented vocalists that surpass most any you'll ever hear, especially Soara-Joye Ross.

252 Reviews | 61 Followers
Absorbing, Enchanting, Great singing, Great staging, Profound

See it if You want to see a profound show with great vocals at the famous Apollo. Wonderful holiday show leaves you feeling warm.

Don't see it if If you a downtown snob who won't travel uptown, don't like holiday shows or are a Scrooge.

216 Reviews | 223 Followers
Entertaining, Great acting, Great singing, Brings out all if your emotions!

See it if This story has a little of everything, so if you like to trigger all of your emotions while being entertained, this one will work for you.

Don't see it if Tired of a sad story that ends happily, skip this. I enjoyed it, but I'm a sap for happy endings. Brought tears to my eyes.

158 Reviews | 201 Followers
Family dysfunction in a harlem brownstone

See it if The vocal talent & musicians are impressive but story is not engaging-- too many elements just underdeveloped & the characters uninteresting

Don't see it if Heavy handed on the gospel, which is pretty impressively executed, but if that's not your thing--don't bother Read more

16 Reviews | 5 Followers
Funny, Great singing, Relevant, Great acting, Entertaining

See it if I loved everything about this play - story, singing, audience reaction. Left theater happy and with love in my heart

Don't see it if the location is not good for you. can't find other reasons

Critic Reviews (8)

The New York Times
December 15th, 2016

"The good news is that the vocalists and the band are still terrific. But the show has also retained the flaws it had the first time around, and gained some new ones in the larger space...The score, a pop-gospel-jazz mix of original and classic songs, is the pulse of the piece. But when the music stops, the show feels like a 1980s sitcom crossed with an after-school special. Dream sequences are not as lucid as they were last year, and genuinely comic elements don’t pop the way they did."
Read more

Talkin' Broadway
December 13th, 2016

"The symbolism, like the plot itself, is more than a little heavy-handed…But if you can get past this, and the rather hokey framing device, ‘The First Noel’ is a powerful story that's anything but hackneyed. The writers don't shy from addressing genuine anguish that comes from a believable place…So compelling is all this drama that the score itself becomes, if not superfluous, then at least secondary…The lead cast members are all superb."
Read more

Stage Buddy
December 27th, 2016

"Each and every actor was simply fabulous…though there were moments between scenes of the different generations of the family that didn’t quite transition smoothly every time...There are many joyous moments with a good sprinklings of jokes, but the show's most powerful, hair-on-the-back-of-your-neck-raising moments come when the talented performers are belting out magnificent songs…Engaging, thoughtful, and powerful, 'The First Noel' is sure to fill your heart with seasonal joy."
Read more

Plays to See
December 13th, 2016

"The plot is formulaically sweet, if a little predictable. But it’s not necessarily the story that draws you in…Throughout the show, the ensemble buoys the performance with choreography and musical numbers that can range from pop to gospel to Christmas carols...The ensemble helps make this show visually captivating…With a brilliant cast and a rousing repertoire, it’s a show that invites audience members of all ages to sing, dance, clap, and celebrate Harlem and the spirit of Christmas."
Read more

December 14th, 2016

"‘The First Noel’ does a wonderful job of reminding us about the true meaning of Christmas…And if the story wasn’t powerful enough, it has all the bells and whistles a top musical should have. From an eclectic score to flawless dance sequences and melodious voices—there wasn’t a single moment that wasn’t fully charged and entertaining. This cast and production make a strong case that 'The First Noel' should be on the boards for many Christmases to come."
Read more

The New York Times
December 15th, 2015
For a previous production

"This good-looking, high-energy show is packed with vocal talent and propelled by a terrific five-piece band...It’s a memory play with music: pop, gospel and holiday...Calibrated to appeal to multigenerational family audiences, 'The First Noel' errs on the side of saccharine. But when the band plays and the singers sing, you’ll let the music move you anyway."
Read more

Theater Pizzazz
December 22nd, 2015
For a previous production

"'The First Noel' is a story of healing and welcoming the hopeful message of the holiday season. The two outstanding features of this production are Broadnax’s innovative staging and the marvelous voices of this cast…'The First Noel' gives audiences a fine way to celebrate Christmas. By the end of the show, you may very well want to jump onstage to take part in all that hugging and kissing."
Read more

American Theater Web
December 22nd, 2015
For a previous production

"Christmas memories don’t get much more tuneful or joyously poignant than those found in the new musical 'The First Noel'…Beyond just being tuneful joys, the numbers sound terrific in the intimate space thanks to powerhouse vocals from both the principals and the ensemble…The show unfolds seemingly all around theatergoers, which makes it nearly impossible to not get pulled into the tale and its redemptive and happy ending."
Read more