The Pirates of Penzance
The Pirates of Penzance

The Pirates of Penzance NYC Reviews and Tickets

(16 Ratings)
Members say
Delightful, Funny, Clever, Entertaining, Great staging

About the Show

Swimming pools, twinkly lights, a well-stocked Tiki Bar and beach balls welcome the audience to The Hypocrites' raucous and utterly zany beach-party adaptation of Gilbert and Sullivan’s classic operetta.

Read more Show less

Show-Score Member Reviews (16)

Sort by:
  • Default
  • Standing in our community
  • Highest first
  • Lowest first
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Only positive
  • Only negative
  • Only mixed
137 Reviews | 13 Followers
Clever, Enchanting, Entertaining, Funny, Great staging

See it if you want to see a Broadway musical comedy that doesn't get to Broadway

Don't see it if you don't like Gilbert and Sullivan Read more

200 Reviews | 51 Followers
Great singing, Great staging, Monumental, Funny

See it if you like pirates.

Don't see it if you don't like long plays. Read more

783 Reviews | 249 Followers
Delightful, Clever, Funny, Quirky, Refreshing

See it if Innovative and fun. About 1/4 of the audience sits on stage. The actors improvise extra silliness on top of an already silly show.

Don't see it if You don't like farce. You don't want liberties taken with the original script and music. Immersive/improvised elements are not your thing.

209 Reviews | 77 Followers
Delightful, Hilarious, Clever, Fluffy, Not your father's pop

See it if This was certainly different. When you see through the antics, the sight gages and people constantly moving around, it actually was a

Don't see it if fairly traditional rendition. If you can wrap your head around the concept of the spirit of G&S, you will enjoy it. it is a great Read more

228 Reviews | 62 Followers
Great writing, Great singing, Funny, Entertaining, Delightful

See it if I saw tPoP in 2005 at the City Center in Manhattan by the Gilbert&Sullivan Players. BUT this is a funny show no matter who does it. GO C IT!

Don't see it if If U don't like singing pirates, keystone kops, orphans, a diva named Mabel, & the very Model of a Modern Major General? Hal Linden or no-GO

393 Reviews | 42 Followers
Delightful, Entertaining, Funny, Great fun

See it if You are a fan of Gilbert & Sullivan and want to see a zany, fun version.This is best enjoyed by those who already know the operetta.

Don't see it if You don't like G&S or have never seen a 'classic' version of Pirates. Warning: NOT for the purists!

64 Reviews | 17 Followers
Clever, Delightful, Enchanting, Great writing, Funny

See it if you like Gilbert & Sullivan and wish there were more companies performing them. Two hours of clever silliness is much appreciated these days

Don't see it if you're not a fan of brilliant silliness and contrived plots or if under-powered singing will ruin it for you. Read more

812 Reviews | 133 Followers
Clever, Delightful, Entertaining, Funny, Great staging

See it if you enjoy a very different production of Pirates of Penzance. You will be on stage and close to the action. Very funny and unusual.

Don't see it if you don't like Gilbert and Sullivan or only a traditional interpretation. Read more

Critic Reviews (12)

The New York Times
December 1st, 2017

“This ‘Pirates’ turns out to be the most charmingly relaxed production of a Gilbert and Sullivan work that I’ve come across...An antic exuberance is built into the form and content of Gilbert and Sullivan shows. And the ensemble here, which doubles as its own band, channels that spirit with an infectious blitheness that requires no footnotes....You are sure to feel a joyful complicity with what’s occurring onstage."
Read more

Times Square Chronicles
December 4th, 2017

"This performance is exhilarating...The adaptation hits all of the major plot points and musical moments while seamlessly infusing witty pop culture references. Director Sean Graney has adapted and staged the piece with abandon...The actors are a tight musical and vocal ensemble with effusive energy...It is one thing to watch such a well-executed show, it is quite another delightful thing to participate in it so closely. It is the perfect antidote to cold winter days."
Read more

Chicago Tribune
November 28th, 2011
For a previous production

"It's hard not to have big-time fun at this carnival of a 'Pirates,' which lands in one of rare but sweet spots where a fairly outlandish off-Loop conceit meshes deliciously with the original material...The show is cast with exuberant young actors and musicians whose singing ranges from passable to pretty decent...I think this truly terrific conception would be yet funnier with a full compliment of operetta-trained singers."
Read more

Everything Musicals
October 9th, 2017
For a previous production

"A frothy atmospheric production complete with beach balls, picnic tables, and plastic wading pools. The atmosphere is true to the playful spirit of the original show, while adding some lovingly ridiculous elements of the group's own devising...The real fun here comes from the spirited and arch direction by Sean Graney, and the lovingly over-the-top performances...'Pirates' doesn't try to be anything beyond what it is, which is a rollicking good time."
Read more

May 17th, 2013
For a previous production

"Despite the aura of 'Gidget Goes Hawaiian' that surrounds the show and the profusion of cute props like rubber duckies and ukeleles, the ensemble can be forgiven because they and the artistic staff have the smarts not to mess with the original score and lyrics...Graney arranges the mayhem with a sure touch, keeping the musical values of the songs intact...It’s not always necessary to be enlightened by theater. Sometimes it’s more than enough to have a rollicking good time."
Read more

The Mercury News
October 23rd, 2015
For a previous production

"You might say this is a very spunky model of a postmodern musical...A giddy journey through immersive theater that turns the Gilbert and Sullivan chestnut into an outrageous evening of frisky song and silliness...The cheekiest aspect of Sean Graney’s staging is how cleverly he plays fast and loose with the somewhat stodgy Gilbert and Sullivan canon...A holiday show for all seasons that actually seems joyous instead of merely entertaining."
Read more

Chicago Theatre Review
December 22nd, 2014
For a previous production

"Thoroughly enjoyable, filled with audience participation and overflowing with contemporary references...More madness, mayhem and musical magic occurs in this tropical isle-inspired, lightning-paced production than audiences can even comprehend...The G&S purist may find this uniquely inventive production not to his liking. The majority of theatergoers will revel in the manic fun and unexpected frivolity and musicality Graney has brought to the theatre."
Read more

DC Theatre Scene
July 25th, 2016
For a previous production

"One wild ride of a show...This show practically leapt off of the immersive stage. The energy level of the cast stayed at such an intensity, it was almost too much to take in...I don’t want to spoil the frantic fun of the entire experience by exposing their little flourishes and embellishments, but this is a savvy and sharp group of comic actor/singer/musicians; under Graney’s direction, they not only get the G & S bits right, they add some hilarious touches."
Read more