Already closed | Midtown W

Hey, Look Me Over!

From 104 member  reviews
Members say: Entertaining, Great singing, Delightful, Funny, Clever

About the show

Encores! kicks off its 25th season with a new musical about Broadway gems they have not yet revived. Featuring a star-studded cast including Tony Winner Bebe Neuwirth and Tony nominee Vanessa Williams.


Bob Martin, as his beloved Man in Chair character from 'The Drowsy Chaperone,' plays an opinionated Encores! subscriber who leads the audience on a guided (and sometimes mis-guided) tour of his favorite scenes and songs from musicals he’s always wanted to see at City Center: 'All American,' 'George M!,' 'Greenwillow,' 'Jamaica,' 'Mack & Mabel,' 'Milk and Honey,' 'Sail Away,' and 'Wildcat.'

Member Reviews (104)


Entertaining, Great singing, Delightful, Funny, Clever
Avg Score

Entertaining, Great choreography, Great singing, Fluffy fun

See it if you love well-performed Broadway songs. HLMO is chock-full of them. Bob Martin (Drowsy Chaperone) is your charming tour guide. Uplifting.

Don't see it if you want only old favorites; many songs are obscure...a few aren't good. Great orchestra occasionally overpowers. Little context given for

Also songs (a couple of lines to set the scene would be an improvement). Th... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Delightful, Entertaining, Great singing, Great staging

See it if you wish to see 9 partials from musicals from 1958 - 1974, a perfect period to revisiit for us. This is a wonderful 25th anniv idea.

Don't see it if you are fixed on an entire production of one show ala the tradition for Encores (The variety worked here) We did miss Joel Grey though.

Scenes from 7 celebrated but rarely-produced musicals: some rich, others forgettable

See it if 2 hear gorgeous tunes like "Never Will I Marry;" see young stars A. Socha/C. Duncan, and always-fine Judy Kuhn shine; first class dance

Don't see it if great old stars Vanessa Williams and Bebe Neuwirth past their prime vocally; only a few performances evoked major applause

Inconsistent, Incoherent, Uneven

See it if you'd love a delightful return of Man In Chair from The Drowsy Chaperone. (He hosts the evening and is just as wonderful as ever.)

Don't see it if you'd be frustrated by seeing 15 minutes of scenes and songs from each musical, which is rarely enough time to care about what's happening.

Great acting, Great singing, Must see, Delightful, Entertaining

See it if You want to see highlights from rarely seen musicals. You want to see amazing performers.

Don't see it if You want more well-known musicals. You don't like the revue format. You want a contemporary musical.

Great singing, Interesting to see these forgotten shows, For someone who loves musicals and broadway history

See it if To see some unforgettable numbers. I really enjoyed it although songs were uneven. Stay to the end for last two numbers.

Don't see it if If you do not enjoy musicals and have no interest in seeing shows that were not hits, for whatever reason, in their time.

Also Excellent talkback with many key members of the cast, Artistic Directo... Read more Read less

Entertaining, Delightful, Great singing, Fluffy, Dated

See it if You want to hear mostly obscure musical theatre songs & scores performed by a top-notch orchestra and your favorite Broadway stars.

Don't see it if You think flop musicals were flops for a reason and there’s no need to rehash them, especially in snippets over 2.5 hours.

Entertaining, Great singing, Delightful

See it if you like to hear excerpts from lesser known musicals with a great cast and wonderful orchestra. Great Encores.

Don't see it if you like only well known musicals or do not like musicals without full staging.

Also Some of these shows will not be seen again on Encores but I think at l... Read more Read less

Banal, Disappointing, A cavalcade of scenes from grade b musicals given a lifeless presentation, Overrated

See it if The "Mack & Mabel" section is the best thing about this Encores! presentation. Douglas Sills & Alexandra Socha are at the top of their game

Don't see it if you are not into musicals that are now mostly forgotten and stand no chance of a revival.

Lost broadway jukebox, Great singing + blatting, Bob martin = treasure, Some great / some not, Thoroughly entertaining

See it if a peek at lost Broadway treasures & not so treasureables in context with scenework & full orchestra sung by BWY luminaries delights you

Don't see it if have no interest in BWY history, Bob Martin connective tissue, lush singing & orchestrations, or cherrypicking numbers from underheard shows

Great choreography, Delightful, Entertaining

See it if you love Bob Martin (and who doesn't) and/or old musicals. It's a fun show.

Don't see it if you want a fully fledged musical (which is what Encores does now). It's a fun show with a bunch of ridiculously talented performers!

Encores revue with outstanding cast

See it if Well worth seeing. Two or three numbers from obscure Golden Age musicals. Bebe Neuwirth got a big hand for Noel Coward's Sail Away.

Don't see it if Clifton Duncan brought down the house with Greenwillow numbers. A surprise star in the last segment capped an enjoyably unusual Bway special

Ambitious, Great singing, Indulgent

See it if enjoy hearing old chestnuts from great American musicals

Don't see it if obscure shows that did not last on Broadway are of no interest to you

Grab bag, Entertaining, Great singing

See it if you want to see bits of former relatively unsuccessful musicals that had redeeming values. Some wonderful performers do the honors.

Don't see it if you don't like musicals. It's apparent why some of these shows didn't make it.

Also Highlights were Clifton Duncan (Greenwillow), Bebe Neuwirth (Sail Away... Read more Read less

Disappointing, Slow, Confusing

See it if you want to experience some old forgotten bits of old forgotten musicals. A standout performance by D. Sills. And special surprise at end.

Don't see it if you are hoptng for full blown show. Just snippets. If you are not familiar with the old shows, you will not know the story.

Also Why did Encores decided to do this ?? Much more enjoyable to see one f... Read more Read less

Absorbing, Entertaining, Great singing, Intelligent, Quirky

See it if You love musicals and want to be introduced to some treasures from the past. I'm so greatful to be introduced to Mack & Mabel

Don't see it if You want a full story, this is more of a review. Some numbers are stronger than others

Also Standout of the night- Alexandra Socha

Delightful, Great singing, Slow

See it if You want the Man in the Chair to walk you through some un-revived Broadway show excerpts. Robert Martin is Delightful. Clever concept show.

Don't see it if You mind unevenly paced show. Robert Martin was great, but there is a reason many of the shows haven't been revived. Saw the closing perf.

Also They spent what seemed like an eternity on Greenwillow, and I would ha... Read more Read less

Delightful, Entertaining, Great singing, Masterful, Dizzying

See it if you love musical theater and have a fondness for shows that did not have long runs.

Don't see it if you're plot-driven and do not care for revues.

Also I thoroughly enjoyed myself reliving some of my favorite show tunes. S... Read more Read less

Disappointing, Entertaining, Great singing, Confusing

See it if See shows that won't be revived - even by Encores.

Don't see it if Wanted a better crop of shows and songs.

Clever, Disappointing, Great singing, Intelligent, Uneven

See it if You want a melange of greatest hits from lesser musicals hosted by the droll, hysterical man in chair

Don't see it if You want full scenes and context for those songs

Dated, Disappointing, Excruciating, Indulgent, Overrated

See it if you are feeling nostalgic for a vaudeville revue that your grandparents used to tell you about.

Don't see it if a hodgepodge of musical numbers from old Broadway musicals that should NEVER be revived isn’t your cup of tea.

Also Hey Look Me Over is a musical review that showed up DOA, dead on arriv... Read more Read less

Entertaining, Delightful, Great singing, Refreshing, Exquisite

See it if Select scenes and songs from old musicals are of interest to you. To date, the shows displayed hadn't been given full revivals. Cast shines.

Don't see it if Old,classic musicals are not of interest.You will recognize many of the songs.You may regret not seeing some of the greatest musical stars.

Cliched, Disjointed, Some highs, Some lows, Bebe neuwirth

See it if You just enjoy Bway music of all types, without plot or context. You love Bebe Neuwirth and will go to any lenghts to see her do 1 song.

Don't see it if The above is not true.

Also Bebe Neuwirth's number was brilliant. It reminded me of why I love, no... Read more Read less

Delightful, Enchanting, Entertaining, Funny, Thoroughly satisfying

See it if you *love* musicals and want terrifically-performed songs/scenes from often forgotten/neglected works. Splendid buffet for musical lovers!

Don't see it if you won't appreciate a hilariously curated tour of 8 lesser-known musicals. A true feast for musical lovers; decent meal for all others.

Entertaining, Great singing, Funny, Top notch broadway performers, Absorbing

See it if You love a musical from overture to outre that ranges from rootin'-tootin' to deepest drama to hilariously snarky.

Don't see it if You can't withstand stretches of dialogue that demonstrate why some of these shows were flops.

Also Delightful for just about every minute of the production. Rousing perf... Read more Read less

February 8th, 2018
"A peculiar and inevitably incoherent assemblage conceived...Though Mr. Martin’s interstitial jokes are often funny, they are not substantive enough to make the selections seem anything more than convenient...There are remarkable performances along the way...For the most part 'Hey, Look Me Over!'...
read more
February 8th, 2018
"Martin's presence was particularly helpful since 'Hey, Look Me Over!' proves to be a textbook example of a mixed bag...There is the superb 30-piece orchestra conducted by Rob Berman, delivering lush orchestrations of the music...The problem is, since it's safe to say that all but the most ardent...
read more
February 8th, 2018
"Offers slivers of 10 lesser-known musicals...And for good reason, they’ve all got issues — and a sliver is enough, thanks very much. Still, Encores! deserves credit for trying out an experiment and assembling a game cast...This 2 1/2-hour revue isn’t about wall-to-wall hits and showstoppers. Sti...
read more
February 8th, 2018
"An unusual and uneven tour of various musicals...This is not a concert, but rather a super sampler of overtures, songs, and dialogue from each musical...The resulting show is sometimes enjoyable but often clunky and disorienting, with some great solos and duets followed by insipid dialogue and e...
read more

Related content