The Plough and the Stars NYC Reviews and Tickets
Show-Score Member Reviews (55)
See it if Seeing this classic play performed to perfection by the Irish company is unforgettable. The actors are marvelous and the set is brilliant.
Don't see it if You have trouble understanding thick accents. You don’t enjoy historical melodrama.
See it if You like classic Irish theatre, are interested in the 1916 uprising
Don't see it if You struggle with strong accents, don't like the slight melodrama of a period piece, aren't interested in Irish history
See it if you like theater that unpacks a historical period and digs into how the characters react to it.
Don't see it if you need something that's relevant to modern times.
See it if The innocents of Irish tenement drink & gab first half, then in the second, the Civil Wartime toll calculated for those innocents. Maryann!
Don't see it if Varied accessible brogues of large talented cast. Uprisings are messy. Maryann Plunkett leaves the stage. Read more
See it if ...you haven't seen anything from O'Casey. It is basically 4 short stories with interesting characters. Some funny moments, some sad. Great!
Don't see it if ...you have an issue with accents. If you do go, don't get frustrated. After about 5 minutes, your ear will tune itself to the Irish.
See it if You are a fan of O'Casey, Irish history, and/or fine ensemble acting. A terrific beginning to the Dublin Trilogy.
Don't see it if You don't like historically-based theatre or are bothered by voracious arguing and threats of violence.
See it if you have a hard time understanding thick accents, but enjoy a challenge.
Don't see it if you have a hard time understanding thick accents, and don't enjoy a challenge. I understood about 10%; the rest was accents.
See it if Slice of real life in the Ireland of 1916 and the struggle of creating the Republic. Strong writing, performances, effective staging.
Don't see it if You have a problem with accents or are looking for a "stage Irish" interpretation this is not for you. This is real life in Dublin tenement Read more
Critic Reviews (15)
“Starts off in such a jolly manner that you may think you’re in for a comedy....Moore’s naturalistic production makes us care for everybody, no matter how vituperative, pigheaded or cartoonishly comical, and the cast is largely excellent...Each character is lovingly rendered, honoring the play’s complexity...’The Plough and the Stars’ illustrates the company’s approach at its most successful...The show has an elemental appeal that testifies to the timeless power of a story well told.”
Read more
"Staged with unmannered directness by Charlotte Moore and acted by an ensemble cast whose members sound as though they’d just stepped off the morning plane from Dublin, it will leave you wondering why O’Casey’s plays aren’t done by every top-tier theater company in America...The abject desperation of Ms. O’Malley’s performance is but one of countless great things about this production. I cannot begin to catalog its virtues."
Read more
“Director Charlotte Moore has done an outstanding job eliciting the humor of the first two acts before immersing us in the tragic events of the play's second half. The cast is exceptional, with hilarious performances...One of the theater's foremost antiwar playwrights, O'Casey is unsparing in his depiction of violence in "The Plough and the Stars," and Irish Repertory Theatre has produced this trilogy in three equally unsparing and masterfully executed productions."
Read more
“The Irish Rep's Sean O'Casey trilogy ends on a note of triumph with Moore's staging of this little-seen report from the embattled streets of Dublin...’The Plough and the Stars’ is a polyphonic display of voices -- comic, tragic, wounded, furious -- bearing witness to a city at war with itself...This is the most expansive play in the trilogy, and it has a design to match...This stunning revival thrills even as its observations continue to prove heartbreakingly relevant.”
Read more
“This moving revival is the perfect capstone to O'Casey's heartbreaking examination of struggling, tenement families...A solid cast with outstanding supporting performances...‘The Plough and the Stars’ takes a dim view of Irish nationalism, is contemptuous of any sentimentalizing of war and is rightfully scornful of the misery brought on by the curse of poverty. Many consider it O'Casey's masterpiece so do yourself a favor and see it in this timeless and heartfelt production.”
Read more
“Directed by Moore with enormous vigor and unflinching honesty (I’m tempted to call it her best work in a long list of outstanding work)—is a must-see. It certainly is as played by a flawless troupe within Corcoran’s four cleverly shifting sets...O’Casey’s ability to fuse comedy and tragedy into the same moment becomes indisputable...The characters throb with life. And with death...’The Plough and the Stars’ is greatly distinguished by the players.”
Read more
“Given a masterful production here, it remains a fine, moving study of everyday individuals swept up in ugly circumstances...’The Plough and the Stars’ begins more rather than less as a comedy, which grows nearly farcical...’The Plough and the Stars' throbs with robust life. Charlotte Moore, the theater’s artistic director, skillfully unites her 14 players into a finely-meshed ensemble. All of the performances are never less than vibrant.”
Read more
"It still sends chills down one's spine as a play that sprung from the blood-stained soil of reality...The current production...has much going for it. Its chief aces are its realistic set design and the superb acting ensemble...In Moore's new staging...one can truly listen to the bittersweet music in his drama and reflect on the real sacrifices of people who are never mentioned in the pages of history books."
Read more