Open run Sleep No More 868 reviews
86 Overall Score

A unique award-winning theatrical event: a site-specific Macbeth-meets-Hitchcock performance piece by Britain's Punchdrunk.

Open run The Ryan Case 1873 14 reviews
79 Overall Score

Live In Theater presents an interactive murder mystery experience that plunges you into the dark underbelly of the Five Points neighborhood of 19th-century New York.

Ends Nov 04 Goodbody 39 reviews
78 Overall Score

The Crook Theater Company presents their first original work, an ultra-violent, profane fantasia that is both comic and shocking.

Open run The Lombardi Case 1975 13 reviews
76 Overall Score

Live In Theater presents an interactive murder mystery experience set in the underworld of 1970s New York City.

Ends Nov 11 The Nap (Broadway) 384 reviews
73 Overall Score

MTC presents a new comedy by the author of the rollicking, award-winning Broadway comedy 'One Man, Two Guvnors,' which offers a comic look at the world of snooker – the British version of pool.

Ends Nov 27 Your Invisible Corset 21 reviews
72 Overall Score

Hunger & Thirst Theatre presents a new, rewritten expansion of their 2016 production of "Dracula," which weaves modern feminist themes into traditional the monster story.

Ends Nov 11 Sleepy Hollow 21 reviews
66 Overall Score

Be Bold Productions presents their original musical based on "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow."

Ends Dec 31 Frankenstein (Write Act Repert... 20 reviews
61 Overall Score

Write Act Repertory's production of Mary Shelley's classic Gothic horror classic is a sweeping, romantic musical faithful to the novel in its exploration of the question: "Without love, what is life?"

Open run Perfect Crime 260 reviews
48 Overall Score

A long running psychological murder mystery (the longest-running play in New York) in a very small theatre in the heart of midtown.

Ends Oct 31 Killing An Evening with Edgar ... 2 reviews
85 Overall Score

Summoners Ensemble Theatre presents a solo performance of three of Poe's thrilling tales, "The Tell-Tale Heart," "The Cask of Amontillado," and "The Raven."

Opens Nov 06 13 Dead Dreams of Eugene 2 reviews
85 Overall Score

This two-person shadow-puppet play with songs revolves around a bizarre true story of Midwestern town who blames a spate of nightmares on the unidentified corpse the town displayed for decades.

In Previews: Opens Nov 07 Eve's Song 2 reviews
75 Overall Score

Filled with dark humor and boiling suspense, "Eve's Song" is a genre-bending new drama that examines our present racial climate through the story of the haunting of a black family in America.

Ends Nov 03 The Bloody Deed of 1857 9 reviews
74 Overall Score

This new supernatural, immersive adventure explores an unsolved murder from 1850s New York and the restless ghosts it left behind.

Ends Nov 10 The Girl Who Handcuffed Houdini 8 reviews
72 Overall Score

This immersive theater piece invites the audience into a surreal Prohibition-era time capsule featuring magic, séances, absinthe and more, as it explores the mysterious death of Harry Houdini.

Ends Oct 28 10th Annual H.P. Lovecraft Fes... 1 reviews
70 Overall Score

Radiotheatre mounts its 10th annual horror fest featuring ten terrifying tales by H.P. Lovecraft, performed in repertory as dramatized radio shows.

Open run Truffles 5 reviews
69 Overall Score

This dinner theater piece invites you to dress in your finest, and come take a seat at Chef Bruno's fictional high-end, five-star Restaurant, enjoy a 3-course meal, and solve the mystery.

Previews start Oct 26 Words on the Street 0 reviews
- Overall Score

Based on a book of poetry by Anna Rabinowitz, this hybrid performance event features a diverse ensemble of 7 performers wielding original music, text, and video to tell the story of a crime in which all humanity is…