Mystery / Thriller (NYC Reviews) (5)
Heart-stopping shows on Broadway and beyond that are filled with intrigue!
Let Show-Score's community of avid theatre fans tell you the best Broadway theatre and Off-Broadway theatre shows that are full of mystery!
Read New York Theatre reviews from our members and their picks for the best mystery/thriller theatre shows running in and around New York right now!
57
Average
852 Reviews
Open run
NYC: Midtown W
Put on your detective hat and solve the longest running murder mystery show in New York City.
-
Unreviewed
Opens Sep 24
NYC: West Village
Guests attend a 1914 séance where secrets and beliefs are put to the test.
-
Unreviewed
Starts Nov 2026
NYC: Upper E Side
A true-crime musical about journalist Dorothy Kilgallen and the JFK assassination mystery.
-
Unreviewed
Starts Jul 22
NYC: Midtown W
A new algorithm challenges friends’ control over their own life choices.
-
Unreviewed
Starts Oct 2026
NYC: West Village
A supernatural thriller exploring belief, grief, and the possibility of ghosts.