Mystery / Thriller (NY Reviews) (9)

Heart-stopping shows on Broadway and beyond that are filled with intrigue!

Let Show-Score's community of avid theatre fans tell you the best Broadway theatre and Off-Broadway theatre shows that are full of mystery!

Read New York Theatre reviews from our members and their picks for the best mystery/thriller theatre shows running in and around New York right now!

92
Must See!
4K+ Reviews
Open run
NYC: Midtown W

Josh Groban and Annaleigh Ashford star in a new revival of Stephen Sondheim's bloody good classic.

87
Excellent
7 Reviews
Ends Mar 16
NYC: Brooklyn

A campy, gothic coming-of-age story about identity-consumption and the fear of not knowing yourself.

83
Great
515 Reviews
Ends Mar 10
NYC: Midtown W

Rachel Bonds' new play explores survival and human connection when Ana takes on a new student.

82
Great
64 Reviews
Ends Mar 31
NYC: Midtown W

A son confronts his long-gone mother's puzzling return in a world premiere featuring Cynthia Nixon.

67
Middling
154 Reviews
Ends Jun 2024
NYC: Midtown W

A bloody comedy that lovingly parodies the popular horror movie of the same name.

60
Middling
652 Reviews
Open run
NYC: Midtown W

Put on your detective hat and solve the longest running murder mystery show in New York City.

Unreviewed
Ends Mar 10
NYC: Brooklyn

In a Christie-sty;e mystery, a pre-announced murder leads Miss Marple to unveil hidden motives.

Score it Buy from $35
Unreviewed
Opens May 31
NYC: Midtown W

An evening of queer horror featuring chilling one-acts and a captivating, spine-tingling experience.

Score it Buy from $35
Unreviewed
Opens Apr 08
NYC: East Village

A new play delving into the complex history of a haunted family farm, amid current societal tensions.