Mystery / Thriller (NY Reviews) (18)

Heart-stopping shows on Broadway and beyond that are filled with intrigue!

Let Show-Score's community of avid theatre fans tell you the best Broadway theatre and Off-Broadway theatre shows that are full of mystery!

Read New York Theatre reviews from our members and their picks for the best mystery/thriller theatre shows running in and around New York right now!

93
Must See!
11 Reviews
Ends Jun 2023
NYC: Brooklyn

An immersive whodunit with a healthy dose of comedy and BIPOC joy.

86
Excellent
125 Reviews
Opens Mar 26
NYC: Midtown W

Josh Groban and Annaleigh Ashford star in a new revival of Stephen Sondheim's bloody good classic.

85
Excellent
1K+ Reviews
Open run
NYC: Chelsea

An award-winning site-specific Macbeth-meets-Hitchcock performance piece by Britain's Punchdrunk.

83
Great
153 Reviews
Ends Apr 30
NYC: Chelsea

The McKittrick Hotel presents the National Theatre of Scotland's music-filled folk-theater fable.

83
Great
250 Reviews
Ends Apr 30
NYC: Midtown W

A musical parody of the hit Netflix series "Stranger Things."

78
Good
70 Reviews
Ends Apr 16
NYC: Upper W Side

A man with secrets boards a train and meets others who, like him, are looking to begin anew.

74
Good
99 Reviews
Ends Apr 01
NYC: West Village

A bloody, darkly comic Elizabethan noir, inspired by true events.

63
Middling
12 Reviews
Opens Apr 10
NYC: Midtown W

A viciously funny musical by the Tony and Pulitzer winning writer behind A Strange Loop.

49
Unpopular
384 Reviews
Open run
NYC: Midtown W

Put on your detective hat and solve the longest running murder mystery show in New York City.

83
Great
8 Reviews
Ends Apr 01
NYC: East Village

The young women of Salem are brought to new life as they navigate the bloody trials of adolescence.

80
Great
1 Review
Ends Apr 02
NYC: Brooklyn

A new production of Agatha Christie's bloody thriller.

71
Good
8 Reviews
Ends Mar 26
NYC: Midtown W

Mariana Carreño’s darkly humorous new play puts quirky characters in situations stranger than them.

Score it Buy from $30
Unreviewed
Opens May 30
NYC: Upper W Side

A new production of Wagner's classic opera about The Flying Dutchman.

Score it Buy from $42
Unreviewed
Opens Jun 15
NYC: Greenwich V

A gory, feminist musical comedy about the teen we all keep buried in our hearts and old diaries.

Score it Buy from $49
Unreviewed
Starts Apr 29
NYC: Midtown W

A new horror play about a couple stranded at an eerie house during a raging blizzard.

Score it Buy from $30
Unreviewed
Starts Mar 30
NYC: Midtown W

A play about how and why we let technology in our homes, and the unexpected changes they can bring.

Score it Buy from $47
Unreviewed
Opens Apr 18
NYC: Greenwich V

A lesser-known Agatha Christie tale set to the stage, featuring murder, betrayal, and secrets.

Score it Buy from $36
Unreviewed
Opens Apr 19
NYC: Soho/Tribeca

A musical comedy about comedian Maggie Lalley's journey through teenage witchcraft and sexuality.