How Show-Score Members Ranked This Year's Tony Nominated Revivals!

Do you agree with their scores?

Gamal ElSawah | May 20, 2022
Patti LuPone in "Company" Patti LuPone in "Company" | By Brinkhoff Moegenburg

The nominees have been announced, and while we won’t know Broadway’s biggest winners until the Tony Awards on Sunday, June 12th, we DO know how our members have scored this year’s Tony-nominated shows! Where do you think your fav shows stand? Read on to find out!

Best Revival of a Play

The five nominees for Best Revival of a Play each kept us on the edge of our seats this season. But who scored the highest…?

4. (TIE) American Buffalo (Show-Score Member Score: 80)

Photo by Richard Termine

In this 1975 classic, junk shop owner Don has just sold a unique buffalo nickel for $90, but worries he could have sold it for much, much more. Desperate to cash in the full value of the rare item, Don and his employee plot to steal the coin back. Lawrence Fishburne, Sam Rockwell, and Darren Criss star in David Mamet's play about greed and deception.

" 90, Great staging, Great acting, Thought-provoking, Masterful, Absorbing

See it if:  You want to experience a master class in acting with three actors on top of their game. The dialogue is sharp, crisp, and edgy. "

- Angela P 7124, Show-Score Member

4. (TIE) for colored girls who have considered suicide / when the raibow is enuf  (80)

Photo by Marc J Franklin

Ntozake Shange’s classic choreopoem returned to Broadway this year. Fearlessly new, and fiercely now, the show features seven Black women sharing their stories and finding strength in each other’s humor and passion through a fusion of poetry, dance, music, and song that explodes off the stage and resonates with all. 

"92, Entertaining, Relevant, Great staging, Great acting, Great writing

See it if: you like engaging stories, beautiful poetry, meaningful dance moves, lovely voices, brilliant projections & lighting and colorful costumes. " 

- Patrick M 4, Show-Score Member

3. Trouble in Mind (81)

Photo by Joan Marcus

The Broadway premiere of Alice Childress's 1955 play follows an experienced Black stage actress through rehearsals of a major Broadway production in a wry and moving look at the racism, identity, and ego of New York theater. Featuring a Tony-nominated performance by Broadway mainstay LaChanze.

"92, Lachanze!!!, Thought-provoking, Relevant, Great writing, Great acting

See it if: you want to see the B'way debut of a play that SHOULD have ran 60+ years ago, but whose theme remains timely. Excellent performances by all! "

- TheatreLovinTom, Show-Score Member

2. How I Learned to Drive (83)

Photo by Jeremy Daniel

The 1998 Pulitzer Prize winning memory play by Paula Vogel finally premiered on Broadway 20 years after its original premiere. Original cast members Mary-Louise Parker and David Morse reprise their roles to tell the story of a woman grappling with her memories of her experiences with her charismatic, manipulative, abusive uncle.

"92, Thought-provoking, Disturbing, Intense, Great writing, Great acting

See it if:  Acutely uncomfortable at first. Then the depth of the characters and mystery of where it is going takes over. Stunning ending. "

- Wish I Could See Them All, Show-Score Member

1. Take Me Out (84)

Photo by Joan Marcus

The return of this 2003 Tony Award winner for Best Play tells the story of a star baseball player publicly coming to terms with his sexuality. Darren Lemming (Jesse Williams) is the star center fielder for the Empires. Against the warning of fellow teammates, he steps out of the closet, revealing a barrage of long-held, unspoken prejudices. Facing some hostile teammates and fraught friendships, Darren is forced to contend with the challenges of being a gay person of color within the confines of a classic American institution. 

"97, Outstanding, Intelligent, Must see, Thought-provoking, Resonant

See it if: A well-written story with across-the-board good acting appeals to you "

- Betty 609052, Show-Score Member

Best Revival of a Musical

The three shows nominated for Best Revival of a Musical, took us back to some of our favorite show stopping memories! Who did our members score the highest?

3. Caroline, or Change (82

Photo by Joan Marcus

Transferring from an award-winning run in the West End, Tony Kushner and Jeanine Tesori's musical, Caroline, or Change starred Olivier Award-winner, Sharon D Clarke, and follows the story of an African-American maid in 1963 Louisiana. Set against the backdrop of the civil rights movement, the musical explores how, in times of great transformation, even the simplest acts can shake the earth.

"98, Profound, Great writing, Great singing, Great acting, Exquisite

See it if: you appreciate ambitious, intelligent theater that sensitively navigates tough subject matter. Sharon D Clarke is INCREDIBLE as Caroline. "

- Michael 1346, Show-Score Member

2. Company (86)

Photo by Brinkhoff Moegenburg

Sondheim's early musical about marriage, love and relationships gets a modern update in this gender-swapped revival! Bobbie’s turning 35 and all her friends keep asking when she will find the right man, settle down, and start a family. As Bobbie searches for answers, she discovers how figuring it all out in 21st-century New York could drive a person crazy. Starring Katrina Lenk, Patti LuPone, and helmed by acclaimed director Marianne Elliott.

"98, Hilarious, Must see, Exquisite, Delightful

See it if: you have been married, are married, or are thinking about getting married. It is the best show of the Broadway season. "

Ann 4, Show-Score Member

1. The Music Man (88)

Photo by Julieta Cervantes

Starring Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster, this revival of the 1957 Meredith Wilson classic follows a con man named Harold Hill, who arrives in Rock Island, IL to peddle the same musical instrument scam he’s been perpetuating all over the Midwest. However, things become complicated when he falls a little too hard for the local librarian, Marian. Could Harold be found out? 

"95, Enchanting, Masterful, Great staging, Splendid, Delightful

See it if: You want to see an extremely talented cast perform a perfect revival! You can tell just how much they all adore & care for one another. "

- JasonBKLYN, Show-Score Member


How did your favorite shows stack up? Do you disagree with their scores? Then score them for yourself, if you haven’t, and make your voice heard!

And don’t forget to Predict the Tonys with us, for a chance to win a $1,000 TodayTix gift card to see theatre!